The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: Underground Comix and the Bronze Age

Attendees at the San Diego Comic-Con in 1982 | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 8 of 9

Underground Comix and the Bronze Age

Between 1968 and 1985 cartoonists who answered to no editor proved that comics could be about anything, the mainstream grew darker, artists began to win back their rights, and the graphic novel got its name.

By · · 9-minute read

Alan Light · CC BY 2.0

On February 25, 1968, a twenty-four-year-old cartoonist named Robert Crumb stood on the corner of Haight and Ashbury streets in San Francisco with his pregnant wife, selling copies of a comic book out of a baby carriage. He had drawn every page himself. A friend had printed it. The cover said “Zap Comix” and, in a box in the corner, “Fair warning: for adult intellectuals only.”

It was the start of a movement that lasted about seven years and changed what the word “comics” could mean. This chapter follows it, and then turns to the newsstand comics of the same years, where the Code loosened, the artists organized, and a new way of selling comics made room for both kinds.

1968Robert Crumb sells Zap Comix no. 1 in San Francisco
1971Comics Code revised
1973Miller v. California changes obscenity law
1975Siegel and Shuster win pensions and credit
1978A Contract with God

Why “comix”

The underground cartoonists had grown up in the 1950s on two things: the EC comics that the Comics Code had killed, and Harvey Kurtzman’s Mad, which taught a generation to distrust advertising, television and authority in general. In the early 1960s they drew for college humor magazines and then for the “underground” newspapers that sprang up with the antiwar movement, such as the East Village Other and the Berkeley Barb.

The spelling with an x marked the difference from newsstand comics. Comix were for adults. They were printed in black and white, with color covers, on the small presses that produced rock concert posters, and sold through the “head shops” that sold pipes and incense. They never went near a distributor or the Code office. The artists owned their work, kept their original pages and were paid a royalty on every copy sold, none of which was true at Marvel or DC.

And nothing was forbidden. The comix were about sex, drugs, politics and the artists’ own lives, and they went out of their way to violate every clause of the Code.

Crumb

Robert Crumb had spent his childhood in Philadelphia and Delaware drawing homemade comics with his brother, and his twenties designing greeting cards in Cleveland. His style came from sources forty years out of date, the big-footed, rubber-limbed cartoons of the 1920s and 1930s, such as Mutt and Jeff and the early animated films. He drew with a fine pen and filled every surface with crosshatching.

That old-fashioned, friendly-looking manner was applied to material nobody had put in a comic. His characters include Mr. Natural, a bearded guru who is probably a fraud, Flakey Foont, his anxious disciple, and Fritz the Cat, a smooth-talking student. Crumb also drew, in remorseless detail, his own lusts, resentments and neuroses. His work can be brilliantly observed and very funny. It also contains violent sexual fantasies about women and grotesque racial caricatures. Crumb has always said these were the contents of an American mind dumped honestly on the page, and many readers, then and since, have found them indefensible. Both reactions are part of his reputation.

Others gathered around Zap. S. Clay Wilson drew pirates and bikers in scenes of total depravity, and his example persuaded Crumb that there should be no limits. Victor Moscoso and Rick Griffin came from psychedelic poster design. Gilbert Shelton, from Texas, created the Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers, three amiable drug-seekers whose adventures were the underground’s biggest seller. Spain Rodriguez drew a revolutionary avenger called Trashman.

The cartoonist Robert Crumb signing a copy of his illustrated Book of Genesis in 2012 | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Robert Crumb in 2012. He sold the first issue of Zap Comix on the streets of San Francisco in 1968 and remains the best-known underground cartoonist.poppet with a camera · CC BY 2.0
The cartoonist Gilbert Shelton, creator of the Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Gilbert Shelton, creator of The Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers, the best-selling underground comic.BennyOnTheLoose · CC BY-SA 4.0

Women and the personal

The early underground was a boys’ club, and much of what it printed was hostile to women. Women cartoonists answered by starting their own books. Trina Robbins organized It Ain’t Me, Babe in 1970, the first comic book produced entirely by women, and helped found the anthology Wimmen’s Comix in 1972, which ran for twenty years. Its contributors wrote about abortion, sexuality, work and family from experience.

The most influential single underground comic may be one that is seldom read now. In 1972 Justin Green published Binky Brown Meets the Holy Virgin Mary, some forty pages about his own Catholic boyhood and the obsessive-compulsive disorder that tormented it. It was the first long autobiographical comic. Art Spiegelman said later that without Binky Brown there would have been no Maus. Harvey Pekar, a hospital file clerk in Cleveland who could not draw, began in 1976 to write stories about his daily life for others to illustrate, under the title American Splendor. The confessional strain became the main line of serious comics for the next fifty years.

The law arrives

Comix were prosecuted from the beginning. Zap no. 4, published in 1969, contained a Crumb story so offensive that police arrested booksellers on both coasts for selling it, and a New York court found the issue obscene.

The decisive blow was a Supreme Court case that had nothing to do with comics. In Miller v. California, decided in June 1973, the Court rewrote the test for obscenity. Material could be banned if, among other things, it offended “contemporary community standards” and lacked “serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value.” The important phrase was “community standards.” It meant that what was legal in San Francisco might be criminal in a small town, and that a shop owner could not know in advance.

Head shops, which were already under pressure from new laws against drug paraphernalia, stopped carrying anything that might attract the police. The underground’s distribution system fell apart within a year. Many publishers folded. The survivors turned to smaller and more serious work.

Relevance and the revised Code

The newsstand comics had been watching. In 1970 the writer Denny O’Neil and the artist Neal Adams took over a failing DC title and sent its two heroes on the road across America to confront racism, poverty, pollution and overpopulation. In the most famous scene an old Black man asks the space-policeman hero why he has helped the blue skins and the orange skins on other planets and never bothered with the black skins. The series won awards and press coverage, and was cancelled for low sales.

The next year an official of the federal Department of Health, Education and Welfare asked Stan Lee for a story about the dangers of drugs. The Code forbade any depiction of narcotics, even to condemn them, and the Code office refused approval. Marvel published the three issues without the seal in the spring of 1971. Nothing happened. The newsstands carried them, the press praised them, and the Code was shown to be weaker than everyone had assumed.

It was rewritten that year. Drug use could now be shown if presented as a vicious habit. Corrupt officials were allowed if they were punished. Vampires, ghouls and werewolves were permitted “when handled in the classic tradition,” which let the horror comic return in tamer form.

Collectors date the Bronze Age from about this point. Its comics are grimmer and more self-conscious than those of the sixties. A hero’s girlfriend was killed and stayed dead. Antiheroes with guns appeared. There were barbarians, kung fu fighters, and a talking duck. Jack Kirby, at DC, wrote and drew an interlocking saga of warring gods across four titles, the most ambitious thing he ever attempted, and saw it cancelled. A revived team of mutants, with an international cast written by Chris Claremont and drawn by Dave Cockrum and then John Byrne, became the best-selling comic in America. Frank Miller, in his early twenties, turned a second-string title into a crime drama staged in rain, shadow and silence, borrowing from film noir and from Japanese comics.

The cartoonist and comics historian Trina Robbins at the San Diego Comic-Con in 1982 | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Trina Robbins at the San Diego Comic-Con in 1982. She organized the first all-women comic book in 1970 and later wrote the standard histories of women cartoonists.Alan Light · CC BY 2.0
Joe Shuster, co-creator of Superman, photographed in 1975 | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Joe Shuster in 1975, the year he and Jerry Siegel were finally granted pensions and a permanent creator credit.DC Comics · Public domain

The fight for credit

Since 1938 the men who made up the characters had owned nothing. In the 1970s that began to change, and the change started with the two who had been treated worst.

In 1975 Warner Communications, which now owned DC, announced a big-budget film of its first and most famous hero and was reported to have paid three million dollars for the screen rights. Jerry Siegel, then working as a mail clerk in Los Angeles for about seven thousand dollars a year, sent a nine-page press release to newspapers. It was headed with a curse on the movie and told the story of the 1938 contract. Joe Shuster was by then nearly blind and living with his brother in Queens.

Neal Adams, the most admired artist in the business, and Jerry Robinson, a veteran cartoonist who had drawn for DC in the forties and was president of the National Cartoonists Society, took up the cause. They brought the two men to New York, got them on television and let the press do the rest. With the film’s publicity at stake, Warner settled two days before Christmas. Siegel and Shuster each received a pension of twenty thousand dollars a year for life, later raised, with medical coverage. Their credit line was restored to every comic, film and television show, and it has been there ever since.

A new Copyright Act, passed in 1976 and in force from 1978, gave the movement a legal tool. It defined “work made for hire” more narrowly and gave authors and their heirs a right, which cannot be signed away, to terminate old transfers of copyright after a set number of years. Publishers responded by requiring freelancers to sign explicit work-for-hire agreements. Adams urged artists to refuse. The termination right produced decades of litigation by the Siegel and Shuster heirs and by the family of Jack Kirby.

Kirby’s own campaign was about paper. Publishers had always kept or destroyed the original drawings. In the mid-1970s the companies began returning current artwork to the artists, who could sell it to collectors. Marvel held some thousands of older Kirby pages and in 1984 offered to return eighty-eight of them, on condition that he sign a four-page release giving up all claims to the characters. Other artists had been asked to sign one page. The comics press and many of his colleagues took his side, and in 1987 Marvel returned about two thousand pages on more ordinary terms. Most of what he had drawn in the sixties was already gone.

The direct market

The old way of selling comics was failing. Newsstands and drugstores took comics on consignment and returned the unsold copies for credit, and many simply did not bother to put them out. In 1972 a Brooklyn schoolteacher and convention organizer, Phil Seuling, made the publishers an offer. He would buy comics at a deeper discount and give up the right to return them, and he would sell them to the specialty shops that fans had started to open.

This “direct market” suited everyone. Publishers got guaranteed sales. Shops could order exactly what their customers wanted. By the early 1980s there were several thousand comic shops in North America, and they accounted for most of the big companies’ sales.

The shops also made room for publishers too small for newsstands. New companies offered creators ownership of their work and royalties, and the big two had to match them to keep their talent. Two young men in New Hampshire printed three thousand copies of a black-and-white parody about turtles with their tax refund in 1984 and became millionaires. A comic no longer needed the Code seal, since no shop cared. The underground’s principles of creator ownership and freedom of content had reached the mainstream through a change in distribution.

The cartoonist Art Spiegelman, creator of Maus, in 2007 | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Art Spiegelman in 2007. He began serializing Maus, about his father’s survival of Auschwitz, in the magazine Raw in 1980.Chris Anthony Diaz · CC BY 2.0
Jack Kirby at the San Diego Comic-Con in 1982 | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Jack Kirby in 1982. His long dispute with Marvel over the return of his original artwork made creators’ rights a public issue.Alan Light · CC BY 2.0

The graphic novel

Will Eisner had left comic books in the early 1950s to produce instructional comics for the Army and for businesses. At a convention in 1971 he met the underground cartoonists and saw that they were doing what he had always wanted to do, which was to make comics for grown-ups.

In 1978, at sixty-one, he published A Contract with God, and Other Tenement Stories. It contained four linked tales set in a Bronx apartment house during the Depression, drawn in sepia, with no panel borders and the lettering worked into the pictures. The title story is about a devout man who rages at God after the death of his daughter, and it came from the death of Eisner’s own daughter. To get it into bookstores he called it a “graphic novel.” He did not invent the term, but his book fixed it in use.

Two years later Art Spiegelman, a veteran of the underground, and his wife, Françoise Mouly, started an oversized magazine of experimental comics called Raw. Bound into each issue from the second onward was a small booklet with a chapter of a work Spiegelman had been preparing for years. It was the story of his father, a Polish Jew who survived Auschwitz, and of his own difficult relationship with him. The Jews are drawn as mice and the Germans as cats. It was called Maus, and what it did to the standing of comics is the opening of the last chapter.

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

San Diego Comic-Con 1982 (1118158318) — Comic Book Art
San Diego Comic-Con 1982 (1118158318)Alan Light · CC BY 2.0
San Diego Comic-Con 1982 (1118158342) — Comic Book Art
San Diego Comic-Con 1982 (1118158342)Alan Light · CC BY 2.0
Jerry Siegel and Bob Clampett — Comic Book Art
Jerry Siegel and Bob ClampettAlan Light · CC BY 2.0
Goodman Goes Playboy page 4 panel 1 — Comic Book Art
Goodman Goes Playboy page 4 panel 1Harvey Kurtzman and Will Elder · Public domain
Robert Crumb - Lucca Comics & Games 2014 1 — Comic Book Art
Robert Crumb – Lucca Comics & Games 2014 1Niccolò Caranti · CC BY-SA 4.0
Jack Kirby 1982 San Diego Comic Con — Comic Book Art
Jack Kirby 1982 San Diego Comic ConAlan Light · CC BY 2.0

Questions people ask

What are underground comix?

Self-published or small-press comics for adults that appeared in the United States from 1968 to the mid-1970s, sold through head shops outside the Comics Code. Robert Crumb’s Zap Comix is the best known.

Why is “comix” spelled with an x?

To distinguish adult, uncensored underground work from mainstream newsstand comics. The x also suggested X-rated content.

How did Miller v. California affect comics?

The 1973 Supreme Court decision allowed obscenity to be judged by local “community standards.” Shops that sold underground comix feared prosecution and stopped carrying them, which collapsed the underground’s distribution.

When did Siegel and Shuster get credit for Superman?

In December 1975, after a publicity campaign led by Neal Adams and Jerry Robinson, Warner Communications granted them lifetime pensions and restored their creator credit.

What is the direct market?

A system begun in 1972 by Phil Seuling in which comic shops buy comics from publishers at a discount on a non-returnable basis. It made specialty comic shops the main outlet for comics and opened the field to independent publishers.

What was the first graphic novel?

There is no agreed first. Will Eisner’s A Contract with God (1978) popularized the term “graphic novel” and is the usual starting point, though longer comics in book form had appeared earlier.

What is the Bronze Age of comics?

The period from about 1970 to 1985, marked by more realistic and socially conscious stories, the 1971 revision of the Comics Code, and the rise of comic shops.

Sources and further reading

  1. Miller v. California, 413 U.S. 15 (1973) — full text of the opinion
  2. Comic Book Legal Defense Fund — obscenity prosecutions and the revised Comics Code
  3. U.S. Copyright Office, Circular 30: Works Made for Hire |
  4. Underground comix — overview
  5. Will Eisner Studios — A Contract with God and the graphic novel
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.