The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: The Golden Age, 1938 to 1945

The cover of Wonderworld Comics no. 7 (1939) by Lou Fine, with a caped hero in dynamic action | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 5 of 9

The Golden Age, 1938 to 1945

A rejected newspaper strip about a strongman from another planet turned a struggling sideline into an industry selling tens of millions of copies a month, most of them drawn by artists barely out of their teens.

By · · 8-minute read

Lou Fine · Public domain

In the spring of 1938 the company that would become DC Comics was putting together a fourth title, to be called Action Comics, and had no lead feature. Its editor, Vin Sullivan, was shown a newspaper strip that had been turned down by every syndicate in the country over the previous four years. The samples were cut apart with scissors, pasted onto comic-book pages and sent to the printer.

The strip was Superman. Action Comics no. 1, dated June 1938, went on sale that April with a cover showing a man in a blue costume and red cape smashing a green sedan against a rock. Within a year it was selling half a million copies a month, and every publisher in New York was looking for a costumed hero of its own.

1938Superman appears in Action Comics no. 1
$130Paid to Siegel and Shuster for all rights
1939First comic book devoted to one hero
1941Heroes fight Hitler months before Pearl Harbor
25 millionComic books sold per month by 1943

Two boys from Cleveland

Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster met at Glenville High School in Cleveland in 1931. Both were the sons of Jewish immigrants, both were shy and poor, and both were devoted to science fiction pulps, newspaper strips and the movies. Siegel wrote and Shuster drew, on wrapping paper when the family could afford nothing better.

Siegel later said the idea came to him on a hot night in 1934 when he could not sleep. The elements were all borrowed. The strength and the leaping came from a 1930 novel, Philip Wylie’s Gladiator. The double identity came from Zorro and the Scarlet Pimpernel. The tights and cape came from circus strongmen and Flash Gordon. The origin, with the infant sent away in a small vessel from a doomed home to be raised by strangers, has often been compared to the story of Moses.

What was new was the combination, and the tone. The Superman of 1938 does not fight monsters or mad scientists. He terrorizes a wife-beater, stops a lynching, forces a mine owner to experience his own unsafe mine, and wrecks the cars of reckless drivers. He is a Depression-era avenger of the helpless, and he enjoys it. For children who felt powerless, he was a fantasy of power, and the mild, bespectacled Clark Kent was the proof that nobody could tell what you really were.

One hundred and thirty dollars

On March 1, 1938, Siegel and Shuster signed a release prepared by the publisher. For thirteen pages of art and script they received a check for $130, ten dollars a page. The document transferred “all goodwill attached thereto and exclusive right to the use of the characters and story” to Detective Comics, Inc.

This was standard practice, and they were glad to be published. For some years they did well. They were paid for producing the feature, hired assistants, and by 1940 were sharing an income of several tens of thousands of dollars a year, which was a great deal of money. But they did not own Superman and had no share in the radio show, the animated cartoons, the toys or the newspaper strip beyond what the company chose to give.

In 1947 they sued to recover the rights. A New York court referee found that the 1938 release was valid and that the company owned the character. The two men accepted a settlement of about $94,000, gave up all further claims, and were fired. Their names came off the feature. Shuster, whose eyesight was failing, ended up working as a messenger. The case became the cautionary tale of the industry, and its later chapters, which ran until the 2010s, are picked up later in this history.

Photograph of Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, the young creators of Superman, at work in the early 1940s | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Jerry Siegel, standing, and Joe Shuster, the creators of Superman. They sold all rights to the character in 1938 for $130.Unknown author Unknown author · Public domain
Lou Fine’s original ink drawing for the cover of Hit Comics no. 5 (1940), with a hero in a dramatic foreshortened pose | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Lou Fine’s original art for the cover of Hit Comics no. 5 (1940). Other artists studied Fine’s elegant, elongated figures.Lou Fine · Public domain

The gold rush

A second hit followed a year later. In Detective Comics no. 27, dated May 1939, the artist Bob Kane and the writer Bill Finger introduced a hero with no powers at all, a rich man who dresses as a bat to frighten criminals. He was drawn from the pulps and from the shadowy look of gangster and horror films. Finger, who devised the costume, the origin and most of the character’s world, was not credited for seventy-five years. That summer Superman was given a quarterly magazine to himself, the first comic book devoted to a single character.

After that the heroes came by the dozen. A pulp publisher named Martin Goodman bought a package from a studio in 1939 and issued it as Marvel Comics no. 1, featuring a flaming android and an angry prince from under the sea. Fawcett Publications introduced a boy who turns into the world’s mightiest mortal by saying a magic word, in stories drawn by C. C. Beck in a clean, humorous style, and by the middle of the war his magazine was outselling Superman’s. A psychologist, William Moulton Marston, who had helped develop the lie detector, created an Amazon princess with a magic lasso because he thought comics needed a heroine who conquered by love. There was a hero who ran fast, one who shrank, one who stretched, one who wore a flag.

Nobody knows exactly how many costumed characters appeared between 1938 and 1945. Estimates run past seven hundred. They were published by some thirty companies, most of them operating from a few rooms in midtown Manhattan. Many of these firms later went out of business or failed to renew their copyrights, and their heroes, among them the Black Terror, the Fighting Yank, the original Daredevil and the Blue Beetle of the 1940s, are now in the public domain. Their covers illustrate this chapter.

One early case set the legal limits. In 1939 the publisher Victor Fox, who had been an accountant for the company that owned Superman, hired the Eisner and Iger shop to produce a strongman in a red costume called Wonder Man. DC sued at once. Will Eisner later said that Fox had asked for a copy of Superman and that he had testified to that effect, though the trial record suggests he was less forthright at the time. The court found for DC, and Wonder Man appeared exactly once. The decision, Detective Comics v. Bruns Publications, was the first to hold that a comic-book character’s distinctive combination of traits could be protected by copyright.

The cover of Daredevil Battles Hitler no. 1 (July 1941), with costumed heroes attacking a giant figure of Adolf Hitler | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Daredevil Battles Hitler no. 1, dated July 1941, five months before the United States entered the war. This Daredevil, published by Lev Gleason, is unrelated to the later Marvel character.Charles Biro · Public domain
A wartime cover of Speed Comics no. 22 with costumed heroes fighting Axis soldiers | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Speed Comics no. 22 (1942). Wartime covers routinely showed heroes punching, drowning or bombing the enemy.“Glaven” · Public domain

The artists

The shops described in the previous chapter expanded to meet the demand, and the drawing improved quickly, because the best of these young men were competing with one another.

Lou Fine, who worked in the Eisner and Iger shop and then for Quality Comics, was the artist the others admired most. He had been partly paralyzed by polio as a boy, and he drew figures of exaggerated grace, long-limbed and twisting, that seem to float off the page. His covers for Wonderworld, Hit and Fantastic Comics are among the finest of the period. Reed Crandall, his colleague at Quality, brought the same polish to aviation and adventure stories. Mac Raboy, at Fawcett, spent so long on each delicately modeled page that his editors despaired of deadlines.

Jack Kirby, born Jacob Kurtzberg on the Lower East Side, was the opposite kind of artist. His figures do not float. They hurl themselves across the page with legs spread impossibly wide and fists coming out at the reader. In 1940 he teamed up with Joe Simon, a tall, businesslike editor, and their first great creation, a super-soldier dressed in the American flag, appeared at the end of that year with a cover that showed him punching Adolf Hitler in the jaw. Kirby broke figures through the panel borders, spread a single image across two pages, and drew fights as continuous choreography. His approach became the action vocabulary of the whole medium.

Will Eisner left the shop business in 1940 to produce a sixteen-page comic book inserted in Sunday newspapers. Its lead feature, The Spirit, about a masked detective in a rumpled blue suit, became his laboratory. He opened each story with a full-page design in which the title was built into the scenery, as letters formed by buildings, puddles or blowing newspapers. He used rain, shadow, odd camera angles and silent sequences, and wrote short stories about ordinary city people in which the hero sometimes barely appeared.

Jack Cole created Plastic Man for Police Comics in 1941. He was a reformed crook who could stretch into any shape, and Cole drew him winding through panels as a red ribbon in pages of manic comic invention. There were a few women at the drawing boards. Lily Renée and Fran Hopper worked at Fiction House, and Tarpé Mills created her own costumed heroine for the newspapers.

The cover of Police Comics no. 1 (August 1941), the issue that introduced Jack Cole’s Plastic Man | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Police Comics no. 1 (August 1941), published by Quality Comics. The issue introduced Jack Cole’s Plastic Man.Gil Fox, The original uploader was J Greb at English… · Public domain
The cover of Master Comics no. 12 (1941) from Fawcett Publications, with a costumed hero in action | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Master Comics no. 12 (1941), from Fawcett Publications. Fawcett’s heroes were DC’s strongest competition during the war.Mac Raboy · Public domain

Comics go to war

Many of the publishers, editors and artists were Jewish, and they did not wait for Pearl Harbor. From early 1940 comic-book heroes were fighting thinly disguised and then openly named Nazis. Simon and Kirby received hate mail and threats from American Nazi sympathizers over their flag-draped hero, and the mayor of New York, Fiorello La Guardia, is said to have telephoned to promise them police protection.

After December 1941 the whole industry enlisted. Covers showed heroes riding bombs, wrecking submarines and holding Hitler, Mussolini and Tojo by the scruff of the neck. The pages urged children to buy war stamps and collect scrap paper. The enemy was drawn in crude racial caricature, the Japanese above all, in images that are ugly to look at today.

The war was the making of the business. Comic books were small, light and cheap, and the armed forces bought them in huge quantities. At military post exchanges they outsold Life, Reader’s Digest and The Saturday Evening Post combined by ten to one, and one in four magazines shipped to troops overseas was a comic. By 1943 total sales had reached about twenty-five million copies a month. Paper rationing was the only limit on growth. Many of the artists were drafted, among them Kirby, who landed in Normandy and fought as an infantry scout, and Eisner, who spent the war drawing instructional comics for the Army on the maintenance of equipment.

Not all of the wartime comics were about superheroes. Walt Disney’s characters, Bugs Bunny and other film cartoon animals sold in enormous numbers in comics drawn by anonymous craftsmen, the greatest of whom, Carl Barks, was known to his readers for decades only as “the good duck artist.” A red-haired teenager from the town of Riverdale first appeared in 1941. Comics for small children and for girls were a large and steady part of the trade, and they suffered least when tastes changed.

What the Golden Age left

Most of what was published in these years was hasty and crude. Stories were written overnight and drawn by committees, and the same plots turned up under a dozen titles. The best of it has an energy that later, more polished comics rarely matched, and it established nearly everything the medium still uses: the superhero and the secret identity, the sidekick, the team of heroes, the crossover, the splash page and the monthly serial.

It also established the business terms. Publishers owned the characters outright. Writers and artists were paid a flat rate per page, received no royalties, and usually no credit. The original drawings were treated as waste and were cut up, given away or destroyed. Those arrangements went unquestioned while everyone was busy. They became the central grievance of the profession for the next fifty years.

When the war ended, the audience came home older, and the heroes who had been fighting it suddenly had nothing to do. What replaced them is the subject of the next chapter.

A cover of Planet Comics no. 34 from Fiction House, a science fiction comic with a heroine and aliens | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Planet Comics no. 34 (1945), from Fiction House, a publisher known for science fiction, jungle adventure and for employing women artists.Joe Doolin · Public domain
The cover of Startling Comics no. 10 (1941) featuring the Fighting Yank in a tricorn hat and cape | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Startling Comics no. 10 (1941), the first appearance of the Fighting Yank, one of many patriotic heroes now in the public domain.Elmer Wexler · Public domain

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Questions people ask

When did the Golden Age of comic books begin?

With Action Comics no. 1, cover-dated June 1938, which introduced Superman. It is generally said to have ended in the mid-1950s.

How much were the creators of Superman paid?

Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster received $130 for the first thirteen-page story in 1938 and signed over all rights to the character to the publisher. They later sued unsuccessfully to recover them.

Why are some Golden Age comics in the public domain?

Under the law of the time, a U.S. copyright had to be renewed after twenty-eight years. Many small publishers went out of business or did not renew, so their comics and characters passed into the public domain.

Who were the most important Golden Age comic artists?

Among them were Joe Shuster, Jack Kirby and Joe Simon, Will Eisner, Lou Fine, Jack Cole, C. C. Beck, Reed Crandall, Mac Raboy and Bill Everett.

How many comic books were sold during World War II?

By 1943 American publishers were selling about twenty-five million comic books a month. They were especially popular with servicemen and outsold leading magazines at military post exchanges.

What was the first lawsuit over a superhero?

Detective Comics v. Bruns Publications (1939 to 1940), in which the publisher of Superman successfully sued over an imitation called Wonder Man. The courts held that the character’s distinctive expression was protected by copyright.

Sources and further reading

  1. Grand Comics Database — creator credits for Golden Age comics
  2. Digital Comic Museum — free scans of public-domain Golden Age comic books
  3. Golden Age of Comic Books — overview
  4. Detective Comics, Inc. v. Bruns Publications, 111 F.2d 432 (2d Cir. 1940) — the Wonder Man decision
  5. Library of Congress — the largest public collection of comic books in the United States
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.