The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: Crime, Horror and the Comics Code

A cover of Crime Does Not Pay no. 42 (1945), the best-selling crime comic of the 1940s, showing a violent gangster scene | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 6 of 9

Crime, Horror and the Comics Code

After the war, comic books grew up faster than the country was ready for. By 1954 they were being burned in schoolyards, denounced by a psychiatrist and investigated by the United States Senate.

By · · 9-minute read

Charles Biro · Public domain

The superheroes did not survive the peace. Within two years of the end of the Second World War most of the costumed characters had been cancelled, and by 1950 only a handful were still in print. The readers had changed. Millions of servicemen had picked up the comic-book habit and did not drop it when they came home, and the children of 1940 were now teenagers.

Publishers went looking for what this older audience wanted, and found it. The result was the most varied, most profitable and most reckless period in the history of American comics. It ended in 1954 with an act of self-censorship stricter than anything applied to films, radio or books.

1942Crime Does Not Pay begins
1948First mass comic book burnings
1950EC launches its horror titles
April 1954Senate hearings in New York
October 1954Comics Code adopted

Crime does not pay

The first of the new kinds had started during the war. In 1942 the publisher Lev Gleason and his editors Charles Biro and Bob Wood brought out Crime Does Not Pay, a comic that retold the careers of real gangsters and murderers, narrated by a top-hatted ghost called Mr. Crime. Every story ended with the criminal shot, hanged or electrocuted, as the title promised. What came before the ending was page after page of robbery, beating and killing, drawn with relish. The covers boasted that it was read by more than six million people a month.

After 1945 it was imitated by every publisher in the business. By 1948 there were some thirty crime titles on the stands, with names like Crime Must Pay the Penalty, Gangsters Can’t Win and Lawbreakers Always Lose, and crime made up about one comic book in seven.

Romance arrived at the same moment. Joe Simon and Jack Kirby, the team who had drawn patriotic heroes before the war, noticed that there was nothing on the stands for teenage girls and adult women. Their Young Romance appeared in 1947 with a banner reading “Designed for the more adult readers of comics.” It sold out, and within three years there were more than a hundred romance titles. They were drawn with a new attention to faces, fashion and feeling, and for a time they outsold everything else.

There were also westerns, war comics, funny animals, teen humor, and the hugely successful Classics Illustrated, which adapted famous novels. By the early 1950s some 650 different comic titles were being published, and sales were approaching a billion copies a year.

The cover of Crime Does Not Pay no. 33 (1944), with gangsters in a violent scene and the title in large letters | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Crime Does Not Pay no. 33 (1944). The comic claimed a readership of more than six million and started a flood of imitations.Charles Biro · Public domain
The cover of Young Romance no. 11 (1949), the first romance comic, with a dramatic love scene | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Young Romance no. 11 (1949). Created by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby in 1947, it opened comics to a large female readership.Jack Kirby · Public domain

EC

The most admired comics of the period came from a small company that had been failing. Educational Comics was founded by Max Gaines, the salesman who had helped invent the comic book, to publish Bible stories and history. He was killed in a boating accident in 1947, and the firm passed to his son William, a twenty-five-year-old chemistry student who had no interest in comics.

Bill Gaines found that he loved it. With his editor, the artist Al Feldstein, he renamed the company Entertaining Comics and in 1950 launched what he called a “New Trend”: two science fiction titles, two of crime and suspense, two war comics edited by Harvey Kurtzman, and three of horror, The Crypt of Terror (soon Tales from the Crypt), The Vault of Horror and The Haunt of Fear.

Gaines and Feldstein plotted a story a day. The horror tales ran to a formula: a cruel husband, a cheating wife or a greedy partner commits a murder and is punished in some ghastly and fitting way, usually by the corpse. They were introduced by three cackling hosts who made terrible puns. The science fiction was thoughtful, and the suspense stories attacked lynching, police brutality and anti-Semitism at a time when almost no popular entertainment did.

What set EC apart was the art. Gaines paid the highest rates in the business, let artists sign their work and encouraged each to draw in his own manner. Graham Ingels drew rotting, dripping corpses. Jack Davis’s figures were all elbows and motion. Wally Wood filled his spaceships with intricate machinery, Johnny Craig drew with clean, cool precision, and Bernard Krigstein broke a few seconds of action into dozens of thin panels. Kurtzman’s war stories, which he researched obsessively and laid out himself, showed combat as frightening and pointless. In 1952 he started a humor comic called Mad.

EC’s success produced, once again, a crowd of imitators with less talent and fewer scruples. By 1954 there were more than forty horror titles on sale, and some of them showed things that had never been printed for children.

The cover of the horror comic Chamber of Chills no. 19 (1953) from Harvey Publications, with a macabre image | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Chamber of Chills no. 19 (1953), one of dozens of horror comics that followed EC’s lead in the early 1950s.Lee Elias · Public domain
The cover of Weird Mysteries no. 7 (1953), a pre-Code horror comic with a grotesque scene | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Weird Mysteries no. 7 (1953). Covers like this were exhibits in the campaign against comic books.Bernard Baily · Public domain

The backlash

Complaints about comic books were as old as the comic book. In 1940 the literary editor of the Chicago Daily News, Sterling North, had called them “a poisonous mushroom growth” and “a national disgrace.” After the war the complaints sharpened, because of a new public fear. Newspapers and politicians were convinced that the country faced an epidemic of juvenile delinquency, and they wanted a cause.

In 1948 the campaign took off. That spring a New York psychiatrist, Dr. Fredric Wertham, spoke at a symposium called “The Psychopathology of Comic Books,” and Collier’s magazine ran an article about his views under the title “Horror in the Nursery.” In the autumn, in the town of Spencer, West Virginia, schoolchildren under the direction of teachers and clergy piled two thousand comic books in the schoolyard and burned them. Burnings followed in Binghamton, New York, in Chicago and elsewhere, most of them organized by Catholic parishes and scout troops. They took place only three years after the end of a war against a regime known for burning books, and some commentators pointed that out.

Cities and states tried to legislate. Los Angeles County made it a crime to sell a crime comic to anyone under eighteen. More than fifty cities passed some kind of restriction, and New York’s legislature passed several bills, which the governor vetoed.

The courts were a barrier. In Winters v. New York, decided in March 1948, the Supreme Court struck down a New York law that banned publications “principally made up of criminal news, police reports, or accounts of criminal deeds, or pictures, or stories of deeds of bloodshed, lust or crime.” The case concerned a true-crime magazine, but the reasoning covered comics. The statute was too vague, the Court held, and it added that lurid entertainment was protected speech: “Though we can see nothing of any possible value to society in these magazines, they are as much entitled to the protection of free speech as the best of literature.” California courts later struck down the Los Angeles measure as well. Government censorship of comics was not going to be easy.

Dr. Wertham

Fredric Wertham was not a crank. He was a German-born psychiatrist who had trained under the leading figures of his field, and he had spent his career on unfashionable causes. He ran a low-cost clinic in Harlem, at a time when almost no psychiatric care was available to Black New Yorkers, and his research on the effects of school segregation was used by the lawyers who argued Brown v. Board of Education.

Many of the troubled children he saw read comic books, as nearly all children did. Wertham concluded that the comics were a cause. His book Seduction of the Innocent, published in April 1954, argued that crime comics taught children to steal, torture and kill, that their advertisements sold knives and air rifles, and that they gave a distorted picture of sex. He reproduced some of the worst panels he could find. He also made claims that became notorious: that the home life of one famous hero and his young ward was “a wish dream of two homosexuals living together,” and that a well-known heroine gave girls the wrong ideas about a woman’s place.

The book has not worn well. A researcher who examined Wertham’s papers after they were opened in 2010 found that he had altered ages, combined cases and omitted facts that did not fit. He had no control groups and little interest in any. But he was right that many of the comics were brutal and that they were being sold to small children without any restriction, and in 1954 he was believed.

The cover of Fredric Wertham’s 1954 book Seduction of the Innocent | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Seduction of the Innocent (1954), the book in which the psychiatrist Fredric Wertham accused comic books of causing juvenile delinquency.Original text by Fredric Wertham M.D. · Public domain
Portrait of Senator Estes Kefauver of Tennessee | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Senator Estes Kefauver of Tennessee, the best-known member of the Senate subcommittee that held hearings on comic books in April 1954.Unknown author · Public domain

The hearings

Two days after the book appeared, on April 21, 1954, the Senate Subcommittee to Investigate Juvenile Delinquency opened public hearings on comic books in the federal courthouse at Foley Square in Manhattan. The chairman was Robert Hendrickson of New Jersey. The member everyone watched was Estes Kefauver of Tennessee, whose televised hearings on organized crime had made him a presidential contender. These hearings were televised too.

The staff had prepared displays of horror and crime covers on easels around the room. Wertham testified in the afternoon as the star witness. “I think Hitler was a beginner compared to the comic-book industry,” he told the senators. “They get the children much younger.”

Bill Gaines had volunteered to appear, alone among the major publishers, and he followed Wertham to the stand. He had been taking diet pills to stay alert and they were wearing off. He read a defiant statement, saying that he had published the first horror comic and was proud of it, and that it would be as hard to explain the harmless thrill of a horror story to Dr. Wertham as to explain the sublimity of love to a frigid old maid.

Then the committee’s counsel asked whether there was any limit to what he would print. Only the bounds of good taste, Gaines said. Kefauver picked up a copy of Crime SuspenStories no. 22. “This seems to be a man with a bloody ax holding a woman’s head up, which has been severed from her body. Do you think that is in good taste?”

“Yes, sir, I do, for the cover of a horror comic,” Gaines answered. “A cover in bad taste, for example, might be defined as holding the head a little higher so that the neck could be seen dripping blood from it.”

“You have blood coming out of her mouth.”

“A little.”

The exchange was on the front page of the New York Times the next morning. The subcommittee’s report, issued the following year, did not call for a law. It did not need to.

The Code

The publishers moved before anyone could move against them. In September 1954 most of them formed the Comics Magazine Association of America and hired a New York magistrate, Charles Murphy, as its “czar.” The association adopted a code on October 26 and set up an office, the Comics Code Authority, to enforce it. Every page of every comic was to be submitted before printing. Approved books carried a seal on the cover shaped like a postage stamp.

The Code was far stricter than the Hollywood production code on which it was modeled. Policemen, judges and government officials were never to be shown in a way that created disrespect for authority. In every instance good was to triumph over evil. No comic could use the words “horror” or “terror” in its title, and “crime” could not appear alone or in large type. Scenes dealing with “walking dead, torture, vampires and vampirism, ghouls, cannibalism and werewolfism” were prohibited. Divorce was not to be treated humorously or shown as desirable. Females were to be drawn realistically, without exaggeration of any physical qualities.

Legally the Code was a private agreement, so the First Amendment did not apply to it. In practice it had the force of law, because the wholesalers who delivered magazines to newsstands refused to handle comics without the seal. The title rules had plainly been written with EC’s three best sellers in mind.

Photograph of the publisher William M. Gaines in 1972, bearded and smiling | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
William M. Gaines in 1972. His testimony before the Senate subcommittee in 1954 became the most famous moment of the comic book controversy.John Putnam · Public domain
A 1954 newspaper photograph of Los Angeles councilman Ernest Debs examining a pile of crime and horror comic books | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Los Angeles city councilman Ernest Debs with a pile of comic books in 1954, when cities across the country were considering bans.Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 4.0

What it cost

Gaines cancelled his horror and crime comics and tried a line of cleaner titles. The Code office fought him over those as well. The last straw was a science fiction story called “Judgment Day,” in which an astronaut inspects a planet of robots who are segregated by color and declares them unfit to join the galactic republic. In the final panel he takes off his helmet, and he is a Black man. The Code administrator demanded that the character be changed. Gaines threatened to hold a press conference, printed the story as drawn, and then quit publishing comic books. He kept only Mad, which he turned into a magazine, outside the Code’s reach. It became one of the great successes of American publishing.

The rest of the industry shrank by more than half. Of the 650 titles on sale in 1954, about 250 were left two years later. Some fifteen publishers closed, and a scandal that broke up the country’s largest magazine distributor in 1957 finished several more. Hundreds of artists and writers left the field for advertising, illustration or other work, and many never mentioned their years in comics again.

Britain went further and passed a law, the Children and Young Persons (Harmful Publications) Act of 1955, which remains in force. Canada had made crime comics illegal in 1949.

For the next fifteen years American comic books were written for children by rule. That had one unintended result. With crime, horror and romance closed off or tamed, publishers needed a kind of story that was exciting and that the Code could not object to. One of them thought of the superheroes.

The cover of a 1960s Charlton comic, Reptisaurus no. 3, with the Comics Code Authority seal in the upper corner | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
A Charlton comic of the early 1960s with the Comics Code Authority seal at the upper right. Distributors would not carry a comic without it.Charlton Comics · Public domain
The cover of Phantom Lady no. 17 (1948) by Matt Baker, showing the heroine bound to a post | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Phantom Lady no. 17 (1948), drawn by Matt Baker, one of the first Black artists to succeed in comics. Wertham reproduced this cover in his book as an example of sexual suggestion.Matt Baker, The original uploader was J Greb at English… · Public domain

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Crime Does Not Pay no. 24 — Comic Book Art
Crime Does Not Pay no. 24Charles Biro · Public domain
Crime Does Not Pay no. 22 — Comic Book Art
Crime Does Not Pay no. 22Charles Biro · Public domain
Phantom Lady 16 Fox — Comic Book Art
Phantom Lady 16 FoxMatt Baker · Public domain
Negro Romance 2 cover — Comic Book Art
Negro Romance 2 coverFawcet Comics · Public domain
Cowgirl Romances 3 — Comic Book Art
Cowgirl Romances 3Unknown author Unknown author · Public domain
Headline Comics 33 — Comic Book Art
Headline Comics 33Jack Kirby and Joe Simon · Public domain
Western True Crime -4 — Comic Book Art
Western True Crime -4Johnny Craig · Public domain
AdventuresIntoDarkness1001 — Comic Book Art
AdventuresIntoDarkness1001Ross Andru · Public domain
TrueLifeSecrets029 — Comic Book Art
TrueLifeSecrets029Liz Liz · Public domain
Photo of William Gaines (1972) (cropped) — Comic Book Art
Photo of William Gaines (1972) (cropped)John Putnam · Public domain

Questions people ask

What was the Comics Code?

A set of content rules adopted by American comic book publishers in October 1954 and enforced by the Comics Code Authority, which reviewed every comic before publication. Approved comics carried a seal on the cover.

Why was the Comics Code created?

To head off government regulation after a public campaign against crime and horror comics, Fredric Wertham’s book Seduction of the Innocent, and Senate subcommittee hearings on comic books and juvenile delinquency in April 1954.

Was the Comics Code a law?

No. It was voluntary self-regulation by the publishers’ trade association, so the First Amendment did not apply. It was effective because distributors refused to carry comics without the Code seal.

Who was Fredric Wertham?

A German-born American psychiatrist whose 1954 book Seduction of the Innocent argued that comic books caused juvenile delinquency. Later research found serious flaws in his evidence.

What did William Gaines say at the Senate hearings?

Asked by Senator Estes Kefauver whether a cover showing a severed head was in good taste, the EC publisher answered, “Yes, sir, I do, for the cover of a horror comic.” The exchange made headlines and damaged the industry’s defense.

What was Winters v. New York?

A 1948 Supreme Court decision striking down a New York law against publications made up of stories of bloodshed and crime. The Court held the law unconstitutionally vague and said such publications were entitled to free-speech protection.

When did the Comics Code end?

The Code was loosened in 1971 and 1989 and lost importance as comics moved to specialty shops. The last major publishers abandoned it in 2011.

Sources and further reading

  1. Comic Book Legal Defense Fund — history of the Comics Code and the text of the 1954 Code
  2. Winters v. New York, 333 U.S. 507 (1948) — full text of the opinion
  3. U.S. Senate Subcommittee on Juvenile Delinquency — the 1954 comic book hearings
  4. Seduction of the Innocent — the book and later criticism
  5. Grand Comics Database — indexes of pre-Code comics
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.