The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: The Silver Age, 1956 to 1970

The writer and editor Stan Lee photographed in 1975 | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 7 of 9

The Silver Age, 1956 to 1970

The superhero came back as science fiction, then as soap opera. In a few years around 1961 a small group of middle-aged artists in New York invented the look and the mythology that still fill movie screens.

By · · 8-minute read

Alan Light · CC BY 2.0

By 1955 the American comic book looked finished. The Comics Code had outlawed its most popular kinds of story. Television was in two-thirds of American homes and gave children free what comics charged a dime for. Publishers were closing every month, and the artists who remained drew talking animals, tame westerns and romances in which nobody was allowed to do much.

The revival came from the least likely source, the costumed heroes who had been dropped as old-fashioned ten years before. Collectors later named the period that followed the Silver Age, by analogy with the Golden one. It is the period in which most of the characters now known around the world were created or re-created. Because all of that work is still under copyright, this chapter is illustrated mainly with photographs of the people who made it.

1956A new Flash in Showcase no. 4 starts the revival
1961Marvel’s first superhero team
1962Ditko and Lee’s teenage hero debuts
1964First comic book convention, New York
1970Kirby leaves Marvel for DC

A new Flash

DC Comics had come through the 1950s in better shape than its rivals. It had kept three of its heroes in print without a break, and it had a new try-out title called Showcase, in which a different feature was tested each issue. For the fourth issue, dated October 1956, the editor Julius Schwartz proposed bringing back a wartime hero who ran at super speed.

Schwartz was a former science fiction literary agent, and he kept only the name and the power. The new version was a police scientist who gains his speed in a laboratory accident involving lightning and chemicals, and who takes his name from a comic book he read as a boy. The writers Robert Kanigher and John Broome gave the stories a puzzle-solving, pseudo-scientific flavor. The artist was Carmine Infantino.

Infantino had been drawing comics since his teens and had come to dislike the cluttered look of the forties. His pages for the new feature were spare and horizontal. The hero is a thin red figure leaning forward at an extreme angle, trailed by a row of fading after-images. The city behind him is a low skyline of clean modern slabs, with a great deal of empty sky. The inker Murphy Anderson gave DC’s art of the period its polished surface. The whole effect was of industrial design, optimistic and up to date, and it suited the years of Sputnik and the jet airliner.

It sold. Schwartz went on to remake a hero with a magic ring as a test pilot recruited into an interplanetary police force, drawn by Gil Kane with the lithe grace of a gymnast, and others followed. In 1960 he gathered them into a team.

The comic artist Carmine Infantino photographed late in life at a convention | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Carmine Infantino, whose sleek, modern design for a revived speedster in 1956 opened the Silver Age. He later became publisher of DC Comics.Super Festivals from Ft. Lauderdale, USA · CC BY 2.0
A page of science fiction comic art from Race for the Moon no. 2 (1958), drawn by Jack Kirby and inked by Al Williamson | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
A page from Race for the Moon no. 2 (1958), drawn by Jack Kirby and inked by Al Williamson for Harvey Comics. Its copyright was not renewed, which makes it one of the few Silver Age Kirby pages that can be freely shown.Jack Kirby · Public domain

The house of monsters

The team’s sales came to the attention of Martin Goodman, the publisher who had put out Marvel Comics in 1939. His company, which went under several names, had shrunk to a single office after its distributor collapsed in 1957. It published eight comics a month, mostly stories about giant monsters with names like Fin Fang Foom.

Its staff was one man, Goodman’s wife’s cousin, who had been hired as an office boy in 1939 at sixteen and made editor at eighteen. Stanley Lieber had long since begun signing his work “Stan Lee,” saving his real name for the novel he meant to write. By 1961 he was nearly forty and thinking of quitting.

The monster stories were drawn by two freelancers. Jack Kirby had returned to Goodman’s company in 1958, out of necessity, after a business failure and a lawsuit had closed other doors. He was drawing three or four complete stories a month, at the lowest page rate of his career. Steve Ditko, a quiet, intensely private man from Johnstown, Pennsylvania, drew the short twist-ending fantasies at the back of each issue in a wiry, angular, slightly eerie style all his own.

When Goodman ordered a superhero team, Lee and Kirby produced one that broke most of the rules. The four heroes of their first issue, dated November 1961, have no secret identities and at first no costumes. They are a family and bicker like one. One of them has been turned into a lumpy orange monster and hates the others for it.

Heroes with problems

The formula was repeated over the next three years in a burst of invention with few parallels in popular art. Kirby and Lee produced a scientist who turns into a rampaging green brute, a Norse god, a band of teenage mutants feared by the public, an armored arms manufacturer and a team of all of them together. Ditko and Lee, in a title about to be cancelled, introduced a bookish high-school student from Queens who gains the powers of a spider, tries to make money from them, and through his own selfishness lets his uncle be murdered.

That character was the purest statement of the idea. He worries about rent, girls and his aunt’s health. He catches cold. The newspaper calls him a menace. Ditko drew him as a skinny teenager in a costume that covers his whole face, so that any reader could imagine himself inside it, and posed him in contorted, crouching, upside-down positions no hero had taken before. Ditko also created a sorcerer who travels through other dimensions, which he drew as abstract landscapes of floating doors, ribbons and eyes. College students in the mid-sixties assumed the artist was taking drugs. He was a strict follower of the philosopher Ayn Rand and did not so much as drink.

The stories were continued from month to month and from one title to another, so that the whole line formed a single fictional world. Lee wrote the dialogue in a wisecracking, self-mocking voice and filled the letters pages and editorials with chatter that made readers feel like members of a club. By the late sixties the comics were selling on college campuses, and a magazine survey found that students ranked two of the characters alongside Bob Dylan and Che Guevara as revolutionary icons.

The comic artist Jack Kirby at his drawing board | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Jack Kirby at his drawing board. In the 1960s he drew as many as five pages a day and co-created most of the Marvel characters.Susan Skaar · CC BY 3.0
A rare photograph of the comic artist Steve Ditko in 1959 | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Steve Ditko in 1959, one of very few photographs of him. He gave almost no interviews in the last fifty years of his life.Unknown author Unknown author · Public domain

The Marvel method

How this work was made matters, because it has been argued over in courtrooms. Lee was editing and scripting the entire line and could not write full scripts for everything. So he reversed the usual order. He would talk over a plot with the artist, sometimes at length and sometimes in a few sentences. The artist then drew the whole story, deciding the scenes, the pacing, the action and often the characters, and wrote notes in the margins explaining what was going on. Lee added the dialogue and captions afterward.

This became known as the Marvel method. With an artist of Kirby’s or Ditko’s imagination it meant that the person at the drawing board was doing most of what a writer does. Kirby said in later years that he had plotted the stories and created the characters himself. Lee maintained that the ideas began with him. The credits on the comics read “Written by Stan Lee,” and the artists were paid only their page rate for the drawing.

Ditko quit without explanation at the end of 1965 and never worked with Lee again. Kirby stayed until 1970, growing angrier as the characters were licensed for cartoons and toys and as press coverage treated Lee as their sole creator. Then he walked out and signed with DC. The legal dispute over what he was owed outlived him and was not settled until 2014.

Kirby’s style

Kirby’s drawing in these years became steadily more extreme and more his own. Figures are built from blocks, with squared-off fingers and kneecaps like machined parts. Bodies are thrown at the reader in violent foreshortening, so that a fist is larger than the head behind it. Machinery covers whole pages in dense, invented detail that explains nothing and suggests limitless power. Outer space and raw energy are shown as fields of black dots in clusters, an effect fans named “Kirby Krackle.” He pasted up photo-collages for cosmic scenes, and he turned the double-page spread into a regular feature.

It is not realistic drawing, and it was never meant to be. It is a system of signs for force and scale, and it has been absorbed into the visual language of comics, animation and film so completely that its source is easy to overlook. Kirby produced it at a rate of three to five pages a day, at a board in the basement of his house on Long Island, with a cigar and the television on.

Experiments

By the late sixties a younger generation was arriving, the first to have grown up as fans. Jim Steranko, a former stage magician and escape artist, drew a spy series for Marvel between 1966 and 1968 that borrowed from op art, Surrealism, film editing and psychedelic posters, including a famous opening sequence of several pages without a word. Neal Adams came to DC from advertising and newspaper strips with a command of realistic anatomy and dramatic lighting that made most other comics look flat. He would shortly use his standing to press publishers on the treatment of artists.

Outside the superhero lines, a small publisher, James Warren, found a way around the Code. In 1964 he launched Creepy, a black-and-white horror comic printed at magazine size and sold beside Time and Life, where the Code did not apply. He hired the old EC artists to draw it.

A 1950s horror comic cover drawn by Steve Ditko for Charlton Comics' The Thing | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
A cover by Steve Ditko for the Charlton horror title The Thing in the mid-1950s. His spidery line and theatrical hands are already recognizable.Steve Ditko, modified by Simon Kirby · Public domain
Will Eisner, Jack Kirby and Rosalind Kirby together at the San Diego Comic-Con in 1982 | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Will Eisner, left, with Jack and Rosalind Kirby at the San Diego Comic-Con in 1982. Both men had started in the comic shops of the 1930s.Alan Light · CC BY 2.0

Pop

Fine artists noticed. In 1961 and 1962 the painter Roy Lichtenstein began enlarging single panels from romance and war comics to the size of murals, reproducing the black outlines, flat primary colors and Ben-Day dots by hand. Andy Warhol painted comic-strip characters in the same months and stopped when he saw that Lichtenstein had got there first. Pop art made its creators famous and rich.

The artists whose panels had been enlarged were less pleased. The originals had been drawn by working professionals such as Irv Novick, Russ Heath and Tony Abruzzo, who were not named, not asked and not paid, and who were working for a modest page rate. Whether a Lichtenstein is a transformation of its source or a copy of it is still disputed among critics and among lawyers. What the episode established was that the look of the comic book, the thing the Code and the critics had treated as trash, could hang in a museum.

Television made the same point more loudly. A deliberately absurd live-action series about a DC hero ran from 1966 to 1968, with sound effects lettered across the screen, and for a year or two comic books sold better than they had since the early fifties.

The fans

The most lasting development of the decade was the audience organizing itself. Schwartz and Lee both printed readers’ full addresses on their letters pages, and the readers wrote to each other. They published mimeographed fan magazines with indexes, histories and interviews. In 1964 about a hundred of them met in a rented hall in New York for what is usually counted as the first comic book convention. San Diego’s began in 1970 with three hundred people.

These fans did the first serious research on who had drawn what. For decades publishers had kept artists anonymous, and it was amateur historians who identified the hands, tracked down the survivors and recorded their recollections. The first price guide for old comics appeared in 1970. A copy of a 1938 comic that had sold for a dime was by then worth several hundred dollars, and the idea that a comic book was something to keep took hold.

By 1970 the two big companies had a fan base, a mythology and a house style apiece. They also had a workforce that had started to ask who owned all of it. Meanwhile, in San Francisco, cartoonists who wanted nothing to do with either company were printing comics of a very different kind.

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Stan Lee 1975 cropped — Comic Book Art
Stan Lee 1975 croppedAlan Light · CC BY 2.0
Jack-Kirby art-of-jack-kirby wyman-skaar 3 — Comic Book Art
Jack-Kirby art-of-jack-kirby wyman-skaar 3Susan Skaar · CC BY 3.0
Jack Kirby 1982 San Diego Comic Con — Comic Book Art
Jack Kirby 1982 San Diego Comic ConAlan Light · CC BY 2.0
Carmine Infantino (7885487662) — Comic Book Art
Carmine Infantino (7885487662)Super Festivals from Ft. Lauderdale, USA · CC BY 2.0
Carmine Infantino (7885488864) — Comic Book Art
Carmine Infantino (7885488864)Super Festivals from Ft. Lauderdale, USA · CC BY 2.0

Questions people ask

What is the Silver Age of comic books?

The period from 1956 to about 1970, when superheroes returned to popularity. It began with DC’s new version of the Flash in Showcase no. 4 and includes the creation of most of Marvel’s best-known characters.

Who created the Marvel characters?

Most were created between 1961 and 1965 by the artists Jack Kirby and Steve Ditko working with the writer-editor Stan Lee. How credit should be divided among them has been disputed for decades.

What is the Marvel method?

A way of producing comics in which the writer gives the artist a plot outline, the artist draws the whole story and paces it, and the writer adds dialogue afterward. It gave artists such as Jack Kirby and Steve Ditko a large role in the storytelling.

What is Kirby Krackle?

A fan term for the clusters of black dots Jack Kirby used from the mid-1960s to represent cosmic energy, explosions and outer space.

Did Roy Lichtenstein copy comic book artists?

Many of his best-known Pop paintings of the early 1960s were based closely on individual panels by comic artists such as Irv Novick, Russ Heath and Tony Abruzzo, who were not credited or paid. Critics still debate whether the paintings transform their sources.

When was the first comic book convention?

A gathering of about a hundred fans in New York in 1964 is generally considered the first. The San Diego convention, now the largest in the United States, began in 1970.

Sources and further reading

  1. Jack Kirby Museum & Research Center |
  2. Grand Comics Database — Silver Age credits
  3. Silver Age of Comic Books — overview
  4. Library of Congress — original art for the first appearance of Ditko and Lee’s teenage hero
  5. The Museum of Modern Art — Roy Lichtenstein and Pop art
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.