The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: The Modern Age and the Graphic Novel

Crowds in the Sails Pavilion at the San Diego Comic-Con in 2012 | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 9 of 9

The Modern Age and the Graphic Novel

Since 1986 comics have won the Pulitzer Prize, crashed as a speculative bubble, gone digital, absorbed manga, filled bookstores and school libraries, and supplied Hollywood with its most valuable stories.

By · · 9-minute read

William Tung from USA · CC BY-SA 2.0

Three books published within a few months of one another in 1986 are the usual starting point for the modern period. One was a memoir of the Holocaust with mice for Jews. One retired a famous hero as a bitter old man in a decaying city. One was a murder mystery about has-been crime fighters that was also an argument about power. Newspapers that had never reviewed a comic ran headlines along the lines of “Comics Aren’t Just for Kids Anymore,” and have gone on running them ever since.

The forty years since then are harder to summarize than any earlier period, because comics stopped being one thing. This chapter follows several stories that ran side by side.

1986Maus, Watchmen and The Dark Knight Returns
1992Maus receives a Pulitzer Prize; Image Comics founded
1996Marvel files for bankruptcy
2011Comics Code abandoned
2034First Superman story enters the U.S. public domain

Maus

The first volume of Art Spiegelman’s Maus, collected from the chapters he had serialized in Raw, was published by Pantheon in 1986. The second followed in 1991.

The book tells two stories at once. In one, set in Poland between the mid-1930s and 1945, Vladek Spiegelman, a young textile salesman, marries, loses his first son, hides, is betrayed and survives Auschwitz. In the other, set in Queens around 1980, his son Art visits the old man, tapes his recollections and tries to cope with a father who is stingy, manipulative and impossible, and whom the camps did not make a better person.

The drawing is small, scratchy and plain, in black and white. The animal masks, with Jews as mice, Germans as cats and Poles as pigs, take the Nazi language of vermin and races literally, and the book keeps reminding the reader that the device is inadequate. It does not allow itself to be sentimental at any point.

In 1992 the Pulitzer Prize board gave Maus a Special Award, since it fit none of the regular categories. The New York Times moved it from the fiction to the nonfiction bestseller list after Spiegelman wrote in to object. The Museum of Modern Art exhibited the original pages. It was the first comic to be accepted without reservation as literature, and it is still being argued over. In 2022 a school board in Tennessee removed it from the eighth-grade curriculum, and it returned to the top of the sales charts.

The dark knight and the watchmen

The other two books of 1986 came from DC, which had begun letting its best creators work with unusual freedom. Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns imagined its hero at fifty-five, coming out of retirement in a city of street gangs and television pundits. Miller drew it in blocky, brutal shapes, with pages cut into grids of sixteen small panels broken up by talking heads on TV screens, and the colorist Lynn Varley gave it a muted, painted palette that newsstand comics had never had.

Watchmen, written by the Englishman Alan Moore and drawn by Dave Gibbons, was issued in twelve parts in 1986 and 1987. It supposes that costumed vigilantes really appeared in America in 1938, and asks what kind of people would do that and what their existence would do to history. It is constructed like a watch. Nearly every page is a strict grid of nine panels. Images repeat and rhyme from scene to scene, and one chapter is laid out so that its second half mirrors its first. Time magazine later put it on its list of the hundred best English-language novels since 1923.

Moore was the first of a group of British writers recruited by DC, among them Neil Gaiman, whose fantasy series The Sandman brought in readers, many of them women, who had never bought a comic. Their success made the writer the star of mainstream comics for a time. Moore’s relations with DC ended badly. He had been told that the rights to Watchmen would return to its creators when the book went out of print. It has never gone out of print.

The writer Alan Moore, bearded, photographed at a public appearance | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Alan Moore, writer of Watchmen, V for Vendetta and From Hell. He was the first of a wave of British writers who reshaped American comics in the 1980s.Fimb · CC BY 2.0
The comic artists Jim Lee and Frank Miller on stage together in 2018 | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Jim Lee, left, and Frank Miller in 2018. Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns (1986) set the tone for a generation of darker superhero comics, and Lee co-founded Image Comics in 1992.Daniel Benavides · CC BY 2.0

Boom and bust

The lesson the industry drew from 1986 was mainly that grimness sold. The comics of the next decade were crowded with heavily armed antiheroes, and the artists who drew them became celebrities. In 1990 and 1991 Marvel launched three new series drawn by Todd McFarlane, Rob Liefeld and Jim Lee, and each sold in the millions. Lee’s first issue, with five different covers, sold more than eight million copies. It is still the best-selling comic book of all time.

Those figures were not readers. News stories about old comics selling for fortunes had drawn in speculators, who bought new first issues by the case as investments. Publishers fed them with foil covers, holograms, sealed bags and “collector’s editions.” In 1992 DC killed off its oldest hero in an issue that sold millions of copies to people who assumed it would be valuable. He was back within a year.

The seven most popular artists at Marvel decided they were making other people rich. In 1992 McFarlane, Lee, Liefeld and four colleagues quit together and founded Image Comics, a company organized on a single rule: the creators own everything, and Image owns only its own name. It was the most direct challenge the big two had ever faced, and for a time Image was the second-largest publisher in the country.

The bubble burst in 1993. Speculators discovered that comics printed by the million were worth less than their cover price, and they left. Over the next few years about two-thirds of the comic shops in North America closed. Marvel, which had been bought and loaded with debt by the financier Ronald Perelman, filed for bankruptcy protection in December 1996.

New tools

The look of comics changed more in these years than at any time since the 1930s, and the cause was technology. For half a century color had been limited to the sixty-four flat tints described in an earlier chapter, printed on newsprint. In the late 1980s publishers began using better paper, and in the early 1990s the colorists moved to computers. Steve Oliff’s studio colored the American edition of the Japanese epic Akira digitally in 1988. By the mid-1990s every major comic was colored in software, with gradients, glows and modeling that could imitate painting.

Lettering, which had always been done by hand with a pen, went digital as well. Many artists now draw on a tablet from start to finish, and the “original art” is a file. Others pencil on paper and scan it. The division of labor is the same as in the old shops, with a writer, a penciler, an inker, a colorist and a letterer, but they may live on different continents and never meet.

Manga

Japan had built the largest comics industry in the world while America was not looking. After the war a young doctor named Osamu Tezuka, who loved Disney films, had begun drawing long stories with a cinematic flow, using many panels for a single action and large, expressive eyes for his characters. Over forty years he produced some 150,000 pages. By the 1980s Japanese comics, called manga, were printed in weekly magazines as thick as telephone directories, read by adults as well as children, and covered every subject from cooking and golf to history and romance.

Translations reached American comic shops in 1987. The breakthrough came around 2002, when the publisher Tokyopop began issuing manga as small, inexpensive paperbacks, printed in the original right-to-left reading order, and got them into chain bookstores. Teenagers, and above all teenage girls, whom American comic publishers had ignored for thirty years, bought them in great numbers. By the mid-2000s manga outsold American comics in bookstores, and in recent years it has accounted for a large share of all comics sold in the United States.

Its influence on drawing is everywhere. A generation of American and European artists grew up with its pacing, its speed lines, its emotional shorthand and its habit of slowing down to dwell on a moment.

The comic artist and publisher Todd McFarlane at a convention | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Todd McFarlane, one of the seven artists who left Marvel in 1992 to found Image Comics, where creators keep ownership of their work.Gage Skidmore · CC BY-SA 3.0
The cartoonist Raina Telgemeier speaking at a book industry event | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Raina Telgemeier, whose graphic memoirs for young readers, beginning with Smile in 2010, have sold millions of copies.Rhododendrites · CC BY-SA 4.0

The bookstore and the classroom

The term “graphic novel” came to mean any comic with a spine, and a great deal of the best work of the last twenty-five years has been published that way, by book publishers, for readers who never enter a comic shop.

Much of it is memoir. Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis, published in France from 2000, is an account of growing up in Tehran during the Iranian revolution, drawn in stark black and white. Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home (2006) examines her closeted father’s life and death through layers of literary reference, and it became a Broadway musical. John Lewis, the civil rights leader and congressman, told his own story in the three volumes of March, which won the National Book Award for young people’s literature in 2016. Chris Ware’s intricately diagrammed books about lonely Midwesterners have been shown in art museums.

The largest change is in who reads comics. Dav Pilkey’s Dog Man and Raina Telgemeier’s memoirs of middle school sell in the millions to children of seven to twelve, and librarians and teachers, who once confiscated comics, now use them to teach reading. In 2020 the American Library Association gave its Newbery Medal, the highest award in children’s literature, to a graphic novel, Jerry Craft’s New Kid, for the first time. Webcomics, published free online and scrolled on a phone, reach audiences in the tens of millions.

Success has brought back the censors. Graphic novels are among the books most often challenged in American schools and libraries, and the list has included Maus, Fun Home and Persepolis. The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, founded in 1986 to defend a comic shop manager prosecuted for obscenity, has had no shortage of work. The Comics Code itself faded away. DC and Archie, the last publishers to use it, dropped the seal in 2011.

The Iranian-born cartoonist and filmmaker Marjane Satrapi | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Marjane Satrapi, author of Persepolis, a memoir in comics of her childhood during the Iranian revolution.Rama · CC BY-SA 2.0 fr
The cartoonist Alison Bechdel speaking at the Boston Book Festival | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Alison Bechdel, whose graphic memoir Fun Home (2006) was adapted as a Tony Award-winning musical.Chase Elliott Clark · CC BY 2.0

Screens and money

Marvel came out of bankruptcy as a company that licensed characters to film studios, and then, in 2008, began making the films itself. The Walt Disney Company bought it the following year for about four billion dollars. The films based on characters created by Kirby, Ditko and Lee have since earned tens of billions of dollars, and the San Diego Comic-Con, which began in 1970 with three hundred fans in a hotel basement, now draws well over a hundred thousand people and is a major event on the entertainment industry’s calendar.

The artists’ families noticed. In 2009 the heirs of Jack Kirby served notices under the termination provision of the Copyright Act to reclaim his share of the characters. The lower courts ruled that his 1960s pages were “work made for hire” and belonged to Marvel. The family asked the Supreme Court to hear the case, and in September 2014, days before the justices were to consider the petition, Marvel settled on undisclosed terms. Kirby is now credited as co-creator on the films. The long litigation by the heirs of Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster ended in the publisher’s favor.

Meanwhile the drawings themselves became expensive. Original comic pages, which publishers once threw away, are sold by the major auction houses. A copy of the 1938 comic book in which the first superhero appeared sold for six million dollars in 2024. In 2022 a single page of original art from a 1984 Marvel comic sold for more than three million dollars. The Library of Congress, the Billy Ireland Cartoon Library at Ohio State University and museums in Brussels, Angoulême and Kyoto preserve what survives.

The lobby of the Billy Ireland Cartoon Library and Museum at Ohio State University | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
The Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum at Ohio State University, which holds the world’s largest collection of comic and cartoon art, including some 300,000 original drawings.Maria Rimmel · CC BY-SA 4.0
Shelves of books by the manga artist Osamu Tezuka in a bookstore | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Books by Osamu Tezuka, the “god of manga,” in a Taipei bookstore. Japanese comics now make up a large share of the comics sold worldwide.MiNe from Taipei, Taiwan · CC BY 2.0

The public domain

One more legal clock is running. Under United States law, works published before 1978 are protected for ninety-five years. On January 1 of each year another year’s worth becomes free for anyone to reprint, adapt or build on.

The newspaper strips of the 1920s are now all in the public domain. The earliest versions of two famous cartoon characters, a mouse and a spinach-eating sailor, arrived in 2024 and 2025. The first story of the first superhero, published in 1938, will follow on January 1, 2034, his bat-costumed colleague a year later, and the wartime heroes soon after. Only the early stories will be free. Later additions to each character stay protected until their own terms run out, and trademarks do not expire at all, so the names and logos cannot be used in ways that confuse buyers. The disputes over exactly what is free will keep lawyers busy for years.

There is a symmetry in it. The medium began with Hogarth petitioning Parliament so that artists could own what they drew, and it spent most of the twentieth century with publishers owning nearly everything. In the present century the oldest characters will come to belong to the public, and any cartoonist with a pen or a tablet will be free to redraw them.

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Alan Moore at the ICA on June 2nd 2009 — Comic Book Art
Alan Moore at the ICA on June 2nd 2009Matt Biddulph from UK · CC BY-SA 2.0
Frank Miller and Jim Lee at DC's Pop-Up Shop - SXSW 2018 — Comic Book Art
Frank Miller and Jim Lee at DC’s Pop-Up Shop – SXSW 2018Daniel Benavides · CC BY 2.0
Todd McFarlane 02 (48686246376) — Comic Book Art
Todd McFarlane 02 (48686246376)GabboT · CC BY-SA 2.0
Raina Telgemeier 2016 — Comic Book Art
Raina Telgemeier 2016Larry D. Moore · CC BY 4.0
Alison Bechdel at Politics and Prose — Comic Book Art
Alison Bechdel at Politics and ProseMichael Rhode · CC BY 2.0
Billy Ireland Cartoon Library and Museum — Comic Book Art
Billy Ireland Cartoon Library and MuseumMaria Rimmel · CC BY-SA 4.0
Osamu Tezuka Manga Museum - panoramio — Comic Book Art
Osamu Tezuka Manga Museum – panoramioDVMG · CC BY 3.0
Art Spiegelman (2007) — Comic Book Art
Art Spiegelman (2007)Chris Anthony Diaz · CC BY 2.0

Questions people ask

What is the Modern Age of comics?

The period from about 1986 to the present. It is usually dated from the publication of Maus, Watchmen and The Dark Knight Returns, which brought comics new critical attention.

Did a comic book win the Pulitzer Prize?

Yes. Art Spiegelman’s Maus received a Pulitzer Prize Special Award in 1992, the first time a comic had been honored by the Pulitzer board.

What is the best-selling comic book of all time?

X-Men no. 1 (1991), drawn by Jim Lee and written by Chris Claremont, sold more than eight million copies, helped by multiple covers and speculative buying.

What is Image Comics?

A publisher founded in 1992 by seven popular Marvel artists, including Todd McFarlane, Jim Lee and Rob Liefeld, on the principle that creators own their work. It remains one of the largest American comics publishers.

Why did Marvel go bankrupt?

Marvel filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in December 1996 after the collapse of the comic book speculator market and heavy borrowing under its owner Ronald Perelman. It emerged in 1998 and was bought by Disney in 2009.

When will Superman and Batman enter the public domain?

In the United States the 1938 comic that introduced Superman enters the public domain on January 1, 2034, and Batman’s 1939 debut on January 1, 2035. Later versions and trademarks remain protected.

What is manga?

Japanese comics. Manga are typically published in black and white, read right to left and serialized in magazines before being collected in paperback volumes. They have been widely sold in the United States since about 2002.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Pulitzer Prizes: Art Spiegelman, Maus — 1992 Special Award
  2. Comic Book Legal Defense Fund — banned and challenged comics
  3. Duke Center for the Study of the Public Domain: Public Domain Day — what enters the public domain each year
  4. Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum, Ohio State University |
  5. U.S. Copyright Office: How long does copyright protection last? |
  6. Image Comics |
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.