The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Black Holes

The supermassive black hole in galaxy M87 imaged in polarized light by the Event Horizon Telescope

Outer Space › Space, Time & Physics

Space, Time & Physics · Relativity

Black Holes: Where Gravity Wins

A black hole is a region where gravity is so strong that the escape speed exceeds the speed of light. Nothing that crosses the boundary comes back, and that includes light.

By · · 12-minute read

EHT Collaboration · CC BY 4.0

To leave Earth for good, a rocket must reach about 11.2 kilometers per second. Squeeze the same mass into a smaller ball and the escape speed at the surface climbs. Squeeze Earth to the size of a marble, about 9 millimeters in radius, and the escape speed reaches the speed of light. Since nothing moves faster than light, nothing gets out. That is a black hole.

The English clergyman John Michell reasoned his way to such “dark stars” in 1783 using Newton’s physics. The modern version came in 1916, weeks after Einstein published general relativity, when the German astronomer Karl Schwarzschild solved the new equations for a single concentrated mass while serving with the army on the Russian front. His solution contained a critical radius at which time, as seen from outside, appears to stop. He died that May. For decades most physicists, Einstein included, treated the result as a mathematical curiosity that nature would somehow avoid.

Karl Schwarzschild with his family in an outdoor portrait
Karl Schwarzschild (second from left) with his family. He found the first exact solution of Einstein’s equations in 1916.Unknown author · Public domain
J. Robert Oppenheimer in 1944
J. Robert Oppenheimer. In 1939, with Hartland Snyder, he showed that a massive enough star must collapse without limit.Unknown author · Public domain

How a black hole forms

A star spends its life in a standoff. Gravity pulls inward and the heat of nuclear fusion pushes back. When the fuel runs out, gravity wins, and what is left depends on mass.

A star like the Sun ends as a white dwarf, an Earth-sized ember held up by the pressure of its electrons. In 1930 a 19-year-old Indian student, Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, calculated on the boat to England that this support fails above about 1.4 solar masses. A heavier core collapses further into a neutron star, a city-sized ball with more mass than the Sun. Above roughly two to three solar masses nothing known can stop the collapse. The core falls inside its own horizon and a black hole is born, often during a supernova.

The name came later. John Wheeler began using “black hole” in lectures in 1967 and it stuck.

2.95 kmHorizon radius for each solar mass
4.3 million SunsSagittarius A*, the Milky Way’s central black hole
6.5 billion SunsM87*, the first black hole imaged
1,560 lyGaia BH1, the nearest known black hole
HundredsBlack-hole mergers and candidates detected by gravitational waves

Anatomy of a black hole

The event horizon is the surface of no return. It is not a physical skin, and an astronaut falling through a large black hole’s horizon would notice nothing special at that instant. It is a boundary in spacetime: inside it, every possible path leads inward.

The singularity is where the equations say the collapsed matter ends up, a point (or, for a spinning hole, a ring) of unlimited density. Most physicists read this as the place where general relativity stops working, to be replaced by a quantum theory of gravity nobody yet has.

The accretion disk is what we see. Gas spiraling inward is heated by friction to millions of degrees and glows in X-rays. Some black holes also launch narrow jets of particles at nearly light speed along their spin axes.

The shadow is the dark center in the famous images, about two and a half times wider than the horizon itself, where light rays are captured rather than bent around to the observer.

Computer visualization of a black hole with its glowing accretion disk warped by gravity into a double-humped shape
A NASA Goddard visualization of a black hole seen nearly edge-on. Gravity bends light from the far side of the disk up and over the top, so the disk appears to arch above and below the hole.NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center/Jeremy Schnittman, cmglee · CC BY-SA 4.0

Finding the invisible

Black holes give off no light of their own, so they are found by their effects.

Cygnus X-1. A rocket-borne detector found a strong X-ray source in the constellation Cygnus in 1964. By the early 1970s astronomers had tied it to a blue supergiant star being whirled around every 5.6 days by an unseen companion far too heavy to be a neutron star. Stephen Hawking bet Kip Thorne in 1974 that it was not a black hole and conceded in 1990. Current measurements put the hole at about 21 solar masses.

Optical sky image of Cygnus X-1 beside an artist's illustration of the black hole pulling gas from its companion star
Cygnus X-1: at left the real sky, at right an artist’s view of gas streaming from the supergiant star onto the black hole.Optical: DSS; Illustration: NASA/CXC/M.Weiss · Public domain
Stephen Hawking giving a lecture at NASA's 50th anniversary in 2008
Stephen Hawking in 2008. In 1974 he showed that black holes should slowly radiate energy.NASA/Paul Alers · Public domain

The center of our galaxy. Beginning in the 1990s, teams led by Reinhard Genzel in Germany and Andrea Ghez in California tracked individual stars whipping around an empty spot in Sagittarius. One star, S2, completes an orbit in 16 years at speeds up to nearly 3 percent of light speed. The orbits require about 4.3 million solar masses inside a region smaller than our solar system. Genzel and Ghez shared the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics with Roger Penrose, who had proved in 1965 that black holes are an unavoidable consequence of general relativity.

Gravitational waves. Since 2015 LIGO and its partner detectors have recorded black holes colliding, a method that needs no light at all. See Spacetime and Gravity.

The pictures

On April 10, 2019, the Event Horizon Telescope collaboration released the first image of a black hole’s shadow. Eight radio observatories at six sites, from Hawaii to Spain to the South Pole, had observed together in April 2017, their data combined to act as one dish the size of Earth. The target was M87*, a 6.5-billion-solar-mass black hole 55 million light-years away in the galaxy Messier 87. Its horizon is about four times wider than the orbit of Neptune.

On May 12, 2022, the same team showed Sagittarius A, our own galaxy’s black hole, about 27,000 light-years away. It is 1,500 times lighter than M87 and its surroundings flicker within minutes, which made the image harder to build.

The first image of a black hole: a bright orange ring around a dark center in galaxy M87
M87*, released April 10, 2019. The ring is hot gas; the dark center is the shadow.Event Horizon Telescope , uploader cropped and converted TIF to JPG · CC BY 4.0
Sagittarius A* in polarized light, a ring with spiral lines showing magnetic fields
Sagittarius A* in polarized light (2024). The lines trace magnetic fields at the edge of the Milky Way’s black hole.EHT Collaboration · CC BY 4.0
Hubble image of the bright jet streaming from the core of galaxy M87
The 5,000-light-year jet from M87’s core, photographed by Hubble. The black hole powers it.NASA and The Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA) · Public domain

Do black holes last forever?

In 1974 Stephen Hawking applied quantum theory to the horizon and found that black holes are not perfectly black. They should leak a faint glow, now called Hawking radiation, and slowly lose mass. For a black hole of stellar mass the glow is far colder than the leftover heat of the Big Bang, so today such holes gain more than they lose. Given unimaginable spans of time, around 10^67 years for one solar mass, they would evaporate.

That raised a problem still unsettled: what becomes of the information about everything that fell in? Quantum physics says information cannot be destroyed, and Hawking’s calculation seemed to say it is. Work on this “information paradox” has driven much of theoretical physics for fifty years.

Roger Penrose
Roger Penrose, whose 1965 theorem showed that collapse to a singularity is unavoidable once a horizon forms.Left: From User:Gangulybiswarup Right: From User:HHgarching · CC BY 3.0
Artist's concept of a star being torn apart by a supermassive black hole
An artist’s concept of a tidal disruption event: a star that strayed too close is pulled into a stream of gas.NRAO/AUI/NSF/NASA · Public domain
Check yourself

What defines the event horizon?

Inside the horizon every path leads inward.

Which black hole was the first to be imaged, in 2019?

The Event Horizon Telescope imaged M87* using 2017 data.

If the Sun were replaced by a black hole of the same mass, Earth would:

Gravity at Earth’s distance depends on mass, which would be unchanged.

Questions people ask

What is a black hole in simple terms?

A black hole is a region of space where matter has been compressed so much that its gravity prevents anything, including light, from escaping once it crosses a boundary called the event horizon.

How big is a black hole?

The horizon radius is about 2.95 kilometers for each solar mass. A 10-solar-mass black hole is about 60 km across; Sagittarius A at 4.3 million solar masses is about 25 million km across; M87 is larger than our solar system.

What is the closest black hole to Earth?

The nearest known is Gaia BH1, about 1,560 light-years away in the constellation Ophiuchus, found in 2022 from the wobble of its Sun-like companion star.

Could a black hole swallow the Earth?

There is no known black hole anywhere near the solar system. Black holes do not suck in distant objects; at a distance their gravity is the same as any other object of equal mass.

Has anyone actually seen a black hole?

Astronomers have imaged the shadows of two: M87 in 2019 and Sagittarius A in 2022, using the Event Horizon Telescope. Others are detected through X-rays, the orbits of nearby stars and gravitational waves.

Sources and further reading

  1. Event Horizon Telescope: first M87 results (2019)
  2. Event Horizon Telescope: Sagittarius A* (2022)
  3. Nobel Prize in Physics 2020 — Penrose, Genzel, Ghez
  4. NASA: Black holes
  5. El-Badry et al. (2023), Gaia BH1, MNRAS
  6. Miller-Jones et al. (2021), Cygnus X-1 mass, Science
  7. Hawking, "Black hole explosions?" Nature (1974)
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, where the Outer Space collection sits beside the site’s history, Lake Norman and law sections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.