The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: Little Nemo, Krazy Kat and the Sunday Page as Art

Winsor McCay’s Little Nemo in Slumberland Sunday page of September 29, 1907, with tall architectural panels in color | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 3 of 9

Little Nemo, Krazy Kat and the Sunday Page as Art

Between 1905 and the late 1920s a handful of newspaper artists were handed a full page in color every week and used it to make some of the most inventive drawing of the century.

By · · 9-minute read

Winsor McCay · Public domain

A Sunday comic page in 1905 was enormous. Newspapers were printed on sheets about seventeen inches wide and twenty-three inches high, and a major feature got the whole of one. It was printed in color, and the engravers and pressmen had by now learned to register the plates accurately and to mix tints by overlaying dots of red, yellow and blue. No magazine and almost no book offered an artist that much space in color.

Most cartoonists filled it with the knockabout comedy described in the last chapter. A few saw that the page could be designed as a whole, and that nothing required a comic to be only a joke.

1905Little Nemo in Slumberland begins
1907Mutt and Jeff, the first lasting daily strip
1913Krazy Kat gets its own strip
1914McCay’s Gertie the Dinosaur
1921Skeezix arrives in Gasoline Alley

Winsor McCay

Winsor McCay grew up in Michigan and learned to draw in the dime museums of Detroit and Cincinnati, where he painted posters and did lightning sketches of customers for a quarter. He was hired by the New York Herald in 1903, at about thirty-five, and within two years was producing several features at once.

Dream of the Rarebit Fiend, which he began in 1904 for the Evening Telegram under the pen name Silas, was a strip for adults. Each episode is a nightmare brought on by eating Welsh rarebit, a dish of melted cheese on toast, before bed. A man’s wife grows until she fills the room. A commuter melts in the heat. A bed gallops out of the window. In the last panel the dreamer wakes up and swears off cheese. The strip let McCay draw anatomy, architecture and machinery distorting step by step from panel to panel, and it is close in spirit to the Surrealist painting of twenty years later.

On October 15, 1905, the Herald published the first page of Little Nemo in Slumberland. The setup never changed. Each night a small boy in a nightshirt is summoned to the palace of King Morpheus, the ruler of dreams, to be a playmate for the Princess. Each night something goes wrong on the way, and in the last small panel, at the lower right, Nemo wakes up, usually on the floor beside his bed.

The second Little Nemo in Slumberland Sunday page, October 22, 1905, in which Nemo falls among giant mushrooms | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Little Nemo in Slumberland, October 22, 1905, the second episode. Nemo walks into a forest of giant mushrooms that collapses on him.Winsor McCay · Public domain
The famous Little Nemo page of July 26, 1908 in which Nemo’s bed grows long legs and walks through the city | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
The “walking bed” page of July 26, 1908. As the bed’s legs grow, McCay stretches the panels taller to keep pace.Winsor McCay · Public domain

How a Nemo page works

What McCay did with that formula had no precedent. He treated the page as a single design in which the shape of the panels is part of the story. When Nemo’s bed grows legs and strides over the rooftops, the panels grow taller as the legs lengthen. When a mushroom forest collapses, the frames tilt. When the characters shrink, the panels shrink with them. A staircase descends through three tiers of the page in one continuous drawing, cut by the panel borders into moments.

His drawing came out of the architecture of the day, the white palaces of the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair and the towers and electric lights of Coney Island, which was a short trolley ride from his house. He drew colonnades, domes and receding avenues in exact perspective, freehand, at great speed, and populated them with elephants, dragons, clowns and crowds. The line is thin and even, borrowed from Art Nouveau posters. The color was worked out with the Herald‘s engravers, the best in the business. It is flat and decorative, full of pale greens, pinks and golds that no other newspaper matched.

The strip is weak in ways that matter. The dialogue is stilted and crammed into balloons that are too small. The characters barely have personalities. And one of the regular cast, a grass-skirted “jungle imp,” is a racist caricature of the kind that was routine in the popular art of the period and is painful to look at now. The pages survive on their visual imagination, which has influenced illustrators, animators and filmmakers ever since.

Little Nemo ran in the Herald until 1911, moved to Hearst’s papers under another title until 1914, and was revived in the 1920s. It was never as popular as the slapstick strips. It was admired, though, and it was adapted as a Broadway musical with a score by Victor Herbert in 1908.

The man who drew cartoons that moved

McCay also had a stage act, in which he drew pictures at speed. Around 1910 he became interested in the new animated films and decided to make one. He drew some four thousand images of the Nemo characters on rice paper, had them photographed frame by frame, and showed the result in his act in 1911.

Gertie the Dinosaur, finished in 1914, went further. McCay stood on stage beside the screen with a whip and gave orders to a cartoon brontosaurus, who obeyed, sulked, cried when scolded and caught a pumpkin he appeared to toss her. At the end he walked behind the screen and reappeared as a drawing, riding off on her back. Gertie was the first animated character with a personality, and the film required about ten thousand drawings, each made by McCay with the background retraced by an assistant. Walt Disney’s animators later acknowledged it as the beginning of their art. McCay himself was disgusted by what the cartoon studios made of it. “Animation should be an art,” he told a dinner of animators in 1927. “What you fellows have done with it is make it into a trade.”

Photograph of the cartoonist Winsor McCay in 1906, in a suit and hat | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Winsor McCay in 1906, the year after he began Little Nemo in Slumberland.Ohio State University [3] · CC BY-SA 4.0
An original drawing by Winsor McCay for his 1914 animated film Gertie the Dinosaur | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
An original drawing for Gertie the Dinosaur (1914). McCay made about ten thousand of them, each on a separate sheet.Winsor McCay · Public domain

A painter in the funny papers

The Chicago Tribune tried something different in 1906. Hoping to lift the tone of its comic section, it recruited artists from Germany, where the humor magazines were the most sophisticated in the world. One of them was Lyonel Feininger, a New Yorker by birth who had lived in Germany since he was sixteen.

Feininger produced two features. The Kin-der-Kids follows a group of children fleeing around the world in a bathtub, pursued by an aunt with a bottle of castor oil. Wee Willie Winkie’s World shows a small boy walking through a landscape in which clouds, houses and trees have faces. The drawing is all angles and silhouettes, with tall thin figures and flat fields of color, and it looks like nothing else in an American newspaper. Both ended within a year when Feininger fell out with the Tribune. He went back to painting, became one of the leading modern artists in Germany and taught at the Bauhaus. His fifty-odd comic pages are among the first places where modern art and the comics met.

The daily strip

All of this was on Sunday. The weekday paper had no regular comics until November 1907, when the San Francisco Chronicle began running a strip across the top of its sports page by a young cartoonist named Bud Fisher. Its hero, A. Mutt, was a tall, chinless racetrack gambler who bet on real horses running that day. In 1908 Mutt met a short man in a top hat in an asylum, a harmless lunatic who thought he was the boxer Jim Jeffries, and Mutt and Jeff was complete.

It was the first daily strip to last, and it fixed the format: a single row of black-and-white panels, six days a week, with a gag at the end. Fisher was also a sharp businessman. He copyrighted the strip in his own name before his employer thought to, and when he changed newspapers the courts upheld his right to take it with him. He became the first cartoonist to grow seriously rich, and spent most of his time at the racetrack while assistants drew the feature.

Krazy Kat

George Herriman was born in New Orleans in 1880 to a family of mixed African and European descent, the people called Creoles of color. They moved to Los Angeles when he was a boy, and for the rest of his life he was taken for white, or Greek, and did not correct the impression. He wore a hat indoors and out. He drew for newspapers from the age of seventeen and joined Hearst’s New York staff in 1910.

In the bottom margin of a strip called The Dingbat Family he began drawing a tiny cat and a tiny mouse. The mouse threw things at the cat. In 1913 they were given a strip of their own, and in 1916 a full page, in black and white, in the arts section of Hearst’s Sunday papers.

The plot of Krazy Kat is a triangle and never changes. Krazy, a cat of uncertain sex, loves Ignatz Mouse. Ignatz despises Krazy and expresses it by throwing a brick at the Kat’s head. Krazy takes each brick as a token of love. Offissa Pupp, a bulldog policeman who loves Krazy, tries to stop the brick and to put Ignatz in jail. Herriman drew variations on that for thirty-one years.

Everything else changes constantly. The setting is Coconino County, Arizona, a real place whose mesas and buttes Herriman loved, and in his pages the landscape shifts from panel to panel while the characters stand still: a tree becomes a rock, day becomes night, a mountain turns into a potted cactus. The panels are different in shape every week. The language is a mixture of Yiddish, Spanish, Shakespearean English and New Orleans slang, spelled as it sounds. Krazy calls the mouse “li’l dollink” and “li’l ainjil.”

A full-page Krazy Kat Sunday comic by George Herriman from May 5, 1918, with irregular panels and desert scenery | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
George Herriman, Krazy Kat, Sunday page of May 5, 1918. The desert background of Coconino County changes from one panel to the next.George Herriman · Public domain
Signed portrait photograph of the cartoonist George Herriman wearing his customary hat | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
George Herriman in the 1930s. He drew Krazy Kat from 1913 until his death in 1944.Unknown author Unknown author · Public domain

A strip for the few

Krazy Kat was not popular. Many editors found it baffling and dropped it, and at its lowest it ran in only a few dozen papers. It survived because William Randolph Hearst liked it. He gave Herriman a lifetime contract and ordered his editors to keep running the page.

Its admirers were intellectuals. The critic Gilbert Seldes, in his 1924 book The Seven Lively Arts, called it “the most amusing and fantastic and satisfactory work of art produced in America today.” The poet E. E. Cummings wrote the introduction to the first collection. President Woodrow Wilson is said to have read it at cabinet meetings. This was the first time that serious critics treated a comic strip as art, and it started an argument about the standing of comics that is the subject of much of this history.

When Herriman died in 1944, Hearst’s syndicate, for once, did not hand the strip to another artist. It ended with him.

The family strips

The comics that most Americans actually read in these years were about households. George McManus’s Bringing Up Father, begun in 1913, concerns Jiggs, an Irish bricklayer who has won a fortune in a sweepstakes, and his wife Maggie, who is determined to enter high society and enforces her wishes with a rolling pin. McManus drew it in a crisp, decorative line with elaborate patterned interiors, influenced by Art Nouveau and later Art Deco, and it was translated around the world.

Cliff Sterrett’s Polly and Her Pals began as a strip about a fashionable daughter and turned, in the 1920s, into the most abstract-looking feature in the papers, with checkerboard floors, tilted rooms and trees like cutouts.

Frank King’s Gasoline Alley started in 1918 as a panel about men tinkering with their cars. On Valentine’s Day 1921 its bachelor hero, Walt Wallet, found a baby on his doorstep. King then did something no cartoonist had done. He let the child, Skeezix, grow up in real time. The characters aged a day for every day that passed. Skeezix went to school, fought in the Second World War, married and had children of his own, and the strip is still running. King’s Sunday pages of the late 1920s and early 1930s, in which a single landscape is spread across all twelve panels or drawn in the style of a woodcut, are among the most beautiful in the medium.

A 1921 Gasoline Alley Sunday page by Frank King in which Walt Wallet chases a turkey | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Frank King, Gasoline Alley, Thanksgiving 1921, the year the foundling Skeezix arrived and the characters began to age in real time.Frank King · Public domain
A Bringing Up Father Sunday page from April 1922 by George McManus with elegant patterned interiors | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
George McManus, Bringing Up Father, April 30, 1922. Jiggs and Maggie were known around the world.George McManus · Public domain

What the newspapers built

By the late 1920s the comic strip was a daily habit for most Americans. Surveys by publishers consistently found that the comics were the best-read part of the paper, ahead of the front page. The artists were celebrities with their own radio shows and endorsement deals.

The form had also proved its range. In twenty-five years it had produced McCay’s dream architecture, Herriman’s desert poetry, Feininger’s modernism and King’s novel of ordinary life. All of it was made on deadline for a product that would wrap fish the next day, and almost none of the original drawings were kept. What happened next was a change of subject. At the end of the 1920s the funnies stopped being funny.

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Little Nemo 1905-11-26 — Comic Book Art
Little Nemo 1905-11-26Winsor McCay · Public domain
Little Nemo in Slumberland (1905-10-22) bottom half — Comic Book Art
Little Nemo in Slumberland (1905-10-22) bottom halfWinsor McCay · Public domain
Dream of the Rarebit Fiend 1905-01-07detail — Comic Book Art
Dream of the Rarebit Fiend 1905-01-07detailWinsor McCay · Public domain
Dream of a Rarebit Fiend — Comic Book Art
Dream of a Rarebit FiendEdwin Stanton Porter / Winsor McCay · Public domain
Gertie the Dinosaur poster — Comic Book Art
Gertie the Dinosaur posterunknown · Public domain
Polly comic 1921 — Comic Book Art
Polly comic 1921Cliff Sterrett · Public domain
Mutt and Jeff - motorcycle cop — Comic Book Art
Mutt and Jeff – motorcycle copBud Fisher · Public domain
Bringing Up Father (1915-04-29) — Comic Book Art
Bringing Up Father (1915-04-29)George McManus · Public domain
Gasoline Alley 1921 Thanksgiving (cropped) — Comic Book Art
Gasoline Alley 1921 Thanksgiving (cropped)Frank King · Public domain
Bobbie McCay Little Nemo — Comic Book Art
Bobbie McCay Little NemoAnonymous Unknown author · Public domain

Questions people ask

What is Little Nemo in Slumberland?

A Sunday newspaper comic by Winsor McCay that ran from 1905 to 1914 and again in the 1920s. Each page shows a boy’s dream journey through fantastic architecture and ends with him waking up.

Why is Krazy Kat considered important?

George Herriman’s Krazy Kat (1913 to 1944) combined shifting desert landscapes, invented dialect and inventive page layouts. Critics such as Gilbert Seldes hailed it in the 1920s as a work of art, the first time a comic strip received that kind of attention.

Who was Winsor McCay?

An American cartoonist and animator (about 1867 to 1934) who created Little Nemo in Slumberland and Dream of the Rarebit Fiend and made the pioneering animated film Gertie the Dinosaur in 1914.

What was the first daily comic strip?

Bud Fisher’s A. Mutt, later Mutt and Jeff, which began in the San Francisco Chronicle in November 1907, was the first daily strip to succeed and established the format.

Which comic strip had characters who aged in real time?

Frank King’s Gasoline Alley. Beginning in 1921 with the arrival of the baby Skeezix, its characters grew older at the same rate as its readers.

Are early newspaper comics in the public domain?

In the United States, works published before 1930 are now in the public domain, which covers Little Nemo, the early years of Krazy Kat and most strips discussed in this chapter.

Sources and further reading

  1. Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum, Ohio State University — original art by McCay, Herriman and King
  2. Little Nemo — publication history
  3. Krazy Kat — publication history and reception
  4. Library of Congress: Cartoon Drawings |
  5. Lyonel Feininger — the painter and his comic pages
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.