The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: Adventure Strips and the First Comic Books

The cover of New Fun no. 1, February 1935, a tabloid-size comic magazine with a western strip on the cover | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 4 of 9

Adventure Strips and the First Comic Books

In 1929 the funnies turned serious, with spacemen, jungle lords and detectives drawn like magazine illustrations. Five years later a salesman found a new way to sell them, and the comic book was invented almost by accident.

By · · 8-minute read

Script by Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson , pencils and inks by… · Public domain

On January 7, 1929, two new strips appeared in American newspapers. In one, a mining engineer overcome by gas wakes up five hundred years in the future. In the other, an English lord’s infant son is raised by apes in the African jungle. Buck Rogers in the 25th Century and Tarzan had almost nothing in common with the family comedies around them. There were no jokes and no last-panel punch line. The stories continued from day to day, and readers had to buy tomorrow’s paper to find out what happened.

Within five years the adventure strip was the dominant kind of comic, and its artists had brought in a new way of drawing. Within ten, the strips had given birth to a separate product, the comic book, which is the subject of the rest of this history.

1929Buck Rogers and Tarzan debut on the same day
1933Funnies on Parade, a giveaway reprint
1934Famous Funnies no. 1 goes on sale for 10 cents
1935New Fun, the first comic book of new material
1937Detective Comics no. 1

Why 1929?

The continued story was not new. Newspapers had learned in the 1920s that suspense sold papers. Little Orphan Annie, begun in 1924, kept its heroine in peril for weeks at a time, and Roy Crane’s Wash Tubbs sent a small comic character off on treasure hunts that grew steadily more dangerous. What changed in 1929 was the source material and the look.

Both of the new strips were adapted from pulp fiction. The pulps were thick magazines printed on rough wood-pulp paper, sold for a dime or fifteen cents, each devoted to a kind of story: westerns, detective stories, air war, jungle adventure and, from 1926, “scientifiction.” Buck Rogers came from a novella in Amazing Stories. Tarzan had first appeared in a pulp in 1912 and was already the hero of a string of best-selling novels and films.

The pulps supplied the comics with their subject matter for the next thirty years, and later with their publishers, writers and business methods as well. The Depression, which began ten months after these strips started, supplied the audience. People who could afford no other entertainment could afford a newspaper, and they wanted escape.

The first Buck Rogers daily comic strips from January 1929, in which the hero is trapped in a mine and wakes in the future | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
The first Buck Rogers dailies, January 1929, drawn by Dick Calkins. Ray guns, rocket ships and jumping belts entered the language through this strip.Philip Francis Nowlan / Dick Calkins · Public domain
The first Tarzan daily strips from January 1929, drawn by Hal Foster with text captions beneath each panel | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
The first Tarzan dailies, January 1929, drawn by Hal Foster. The story is told in captions under the pictures, without balloons.Hal Foster · Public domain

Hal Foster and the illustrators

Buck Rogers was drawn stiffly, and its appeal was in its ideas. Tarzan was something else. The advertising agency that packaged it hired a commercial illustrator from Winnipeg named Harold Foster, who had never drawn a comic and looked down on them.

Foster drew the way the best magazine and book illustrators drew. His figures had correct anatomy and real weight. He composed each panel like a painting, with a foreground, a middle distance and a horizon, and he lit it consistently. He used no speech balloons, which he thought ugly. When he took over the color Sunday Tarzan page in 1931, readers saw running, climbing and fighting bodies drawn with a naturalism that the comics had never attempted.

In 1937 Foster left Tarzan to create a strip of his own. Prince Valiant in the Days of King Arthur was a full-page Sunday feature about a Viking prince at Camelot, researched down to the buckles on the armor. He spent fifty hours or more on each page and drew it for thirty-four years. Almost every artist who drew comic-book heroes in the following decade studied Foster, and many simply traced him.

Raymond and Caniff

Two younger artists completed the new style. Alex Raymond was twenty-four when King Features gave him three strips to start at once in January 1934. The best known, Flash Gordon, was created to compete with Buck Rogers. A polo-playing Yale man, his girlfriend and a mad scientist land on the planet Mongo and battle its emperor, Ming the Merciless. Raymond’s drawing developed month by month into something close to fashion illustration, with long sweeping brush lines, heroic profiles and gleaming, impossible cities. His work was the main model for the idealized heroes of the comic books.

Milton Caniff’s Terry and the Pirates, which began in October 1934 and was set on the coast of China, worked differently. Caniff, with his studio mate Noel Sickles, built pictures out of solid black shadow. Faces, uniforms and ships were modeled in a few shapes of pure black against white, as in a high-contrast photograph, which was fast to draw, printed well on bad paper and looked like a movie. He also cut his stories like films, with long shots, close-ups and changes of angle, and wrote sharp, adult dialogue. The combination of Raymond’s line and Caniff’s shadows is, in effect, the drawing style of American comic books.

Other strips filled out the range. Chester Gould’s Dick Tracy (1931) brought gunfire and grotesque gangsters to the comics page in a flat, hard-edged style. Lee Falk created Mandrake the Magician in 1934 and The Phantom in 1936. The Phantom wore a skintight costume and a mask, operated from a secret lair and had no visible pupils in his eyes, and he is the clearest forerunner of the comic-book superhero.

A salesman’s idea

Collections of newspaper strips had been published in book form since the days of the Yellow Kid. They were usually oblong hardcovers or cardboard-covered albums sold in bookstores, and nobody thought of them as a separate medium.

The comic book as we know it came out of a printing plant in Waterbury, Connecticut. Eastern Color Printing produced the Sunday comic sections for a number of East Coast newspapers. In 1933 a sales manager there, Harry Wildenberg, realized that a standard newspaper page, folded in half and then in half again, made a booklet about seven and a half by ten inches, and that the color presses could print it during idle hours. He and a salesman named Maxwell Charles Gaines sold the idea to Procter & Gamble as a giveaway. Funnies on Parade, thirty-two pages of reprinted Sunday strips, was mailed to customers who sent in coupons from soap wrappers. The whole run of ten thousand was claimed within weeks.

Gaines, by his own later account, then tried an experiment. He put ten-cent stickers on a few dozen leftover copies and left them at newsstands, and they sold out over a weekend. In the spring of 1934 Eastern Color, with the Dell Publishing Company, produced a book for sale. Famous Funnies no. 1, cover-dated July 1934, had sixty-four pages of reprinted strips for a dime. It lost money on the first issue and was making a profit of thirty thousand dollars a month within a year.

The cover of Famous Funnies no. 81 with a group of newspaper comic characters | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Famous Funnies, the first comic book sold on newsstands. It reprinted Sunday newspaper strips, several to a page.H. G. Peter · Public domain
The cover of Famous Funnies no. 90 from the early 1940s | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Famous Funnies ran for 218 issues, from 1934 to 1955. The size and shape it established is still the standard American comic book.Will Rowland · Public domain

The Major

The reprint books had a built-in limit, which was the supply of strips. The syndicates soon caught on and raised their prices or started comic books of their own. The first man to see that the answer was to commission new material was one of the most colorful characters in publishing.

Major Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson was a former cavalry officer who had served on the Mexican border, in the Philippines and in Siberia, and who left the Army after publicly accusing his superiors of incompetence. He then wrote adventure stories for the pulps. In the autumn of 1934 he founded National Allied Publications, and in February 1935 he brought out New Fun, a tabloid-size magazine of thirty-six pages, in black and white inside, containing nothing but original comic features.

The Major had vision and no money. He paid artists late or not at all, and so he attracted mainly beginners who could not get work elsewhere. Two of them were teenagers from Cleveland, Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, who sold him a swashbuckler and a detective in 1935. He was soon deeply in debt to his printer and distributor, Harry Donenfeld, a tough businessman who published racy pulps. To launch a third title, Detective Comics, in early 1937, Wheeler-Nicholson had to take Donenfeld’s accountant, Jack Liebowitz, as a partner. Within a year the Major was forced out. The company, which eventually took the name DC from its detective title, belonged to Donenfeld and Liebowitz. It had on its hands an unsold feature by Siegel and Shuster that every newspaper syndicate had rejected, and what happened to it is told in the next chapter.

The shops

A sixty-four-page comic every month needed far more material than a publisher’s few staff artists could draw. Entrepreneurs set up studios to supply complete stories to order. The first was run by Harry “A” Chesler from 1936. The most important was opened that same year by Will Eisner, a nineteen-year-old from the Bronx, and his partner Jerry Iger.

A comic shop was a factory. Rows of young men, and a few women, sat at drawing boards in a loft. One wrote scripts and another roughed out the pages in pencil. Specialists drew the figures, the backgrounds, the lettering and the borders, and others went over the pencil in ink. The pay was five to ten dollars a page for the whole job, split among them. The artists were mostly the sons of immigrants, many of them Jewish, with a high-school art education and no chance of being hired by the magazine illustrators and advertising agencies they admired. Jack Kirby, Bob Kane, Lou Fine, Bernard Baily and Mort Meskin all passed through the Eisner and Iger shop.

The work belonged to the shop or the publisher. Artists were often paid with checks stamped on the back with a statement that, by endorsing it, the payee gave up all rights to the work. Almost none of them thought that mattered.

How a comic book was made

The process settled quickly into a routine that lasted for half a century. The art was drawn in pencil on sheets of stiff white board about twice the size of the printed page, then lettered and inked with brush and pen in solid black. The inked page was photographed and reduced to make a metal printing plate for the black lines.

Color was added by a different set of hands. A colorist painted a photostat of the page with watercolor dyes as a guide. At the engraving plant, workers, most of them women, translated the guide into three more plates, for yellow, red and blue. They did it by painting on sheets of acetate to mark where each color should go and in what strength: solid, or broken into dots at twenty-five or fifty percent. That gave sixty-four possible combinations. The dot patterns, named Ben-Day dots after the printer Benjamin Day, are the reason flesh in old comics is a field of tiny red spots.

The four plates were printed on high-speed rotary presses, on the cheapest newsprint available, at the rate of thousands of copies an hour. Colors rarely lined up exactly. Artists learned to draw for the process, with heavy outlines to contain the color and simple shapes that survived bad printing. The bold look of comic art is partly a matter of taste and largely a response to the press.

The original ink drawing for a 1936 Bringing Up Father Sunday page, showing black line art before color | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Original art for a 1936 Sunday page by George McManus. Comic art was drawn in black ink at a large size. Color was added at the engraving stage.George McManus · Public domain
The original cover art for Jumbo Comics no. 9 (1939) by Lou Fine, produced in the Eisner and Iger shop | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Cover art for Jumbo Comics no. 9 (1939) by Lou Fine, one of the stars of the Eisner and Iger shop. Publishers bought finished pages like this from the shops by the dozen.Will Eisner / Lou Fine · Public domain

On the eve

By the end of 1937 there were perhaps a dozen comic book titles on the newsstands. Most were reprints of newspaper strips. The new material was imitation strip material, such as detectives, cowboys, aviators and funny animals, and none of it was as good as what the newspapers offered for less.

The comic book had a format, a price, a distribution system and a pool of cheap talent. It did not yet have a subject of its own. That arrived in the spring of 1938, when an editor looking for a lead feature for a new title pulled a rejected newspaper strip out of a drawer.

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Famous Funnies 84 — Comic Book Art
Famous Funnies 84Unknown Unknown · Public domain
Famous Funnies 87 — Comic Book Art
Famous Funnies 87H. G. Peter · Public domain
FamousFunniesNo211 — Comic Book Art
FamousFunniesNo211Frank Frazetta · Public domain
Buck Rogers overcome by gas in a mine, 7 January 1929 — Comic Book Art
Buck Rogers overcome by gas in a mine, 7 January 1929Elyaqim Mosheh Adam אליקים משה אדם · Public domain
Buck Rogers, first three comic strips — Comic Book Art
Buck Rogers, first three comic stripsPhilip Francis Nowlan / Dick Calkins · Public domain
Planet Comics no. 2 (cover) — Comic Book Art
Planet Comics no. 2 (cover)Lou Fine · Public domain
Bringing Up Father (Victoria Daily Times, 1925-11-23) — Comic Book Art
Bringing Up Father (Victoria Daily Times, 1925-11-23)Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

Questions people ask

What was the first comic book?

Famous Funnies no. 1, published in 1934 by Eastern Color Printing and sold for ten cents, was the first comic book distributed through newsstands in the standard format. A giveaway called Funnies on Parade preceded it in 1933.

What was the first comic book with original material?

New Fun no. 1, published in February 1935 by Major Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson’s National Allied Publications, the company that became DC Comics.

What were the first adventure comic strips?

Buck Rogers and Tarzan, which both began on January 7, 1929, are usually treated as the start of the adventure strip, followed by Dick Tracy (1931), Flash Gordon and Terry and the Pirates (both 1934).

Who was Hal Foster?

A Canadian-born illustrator who drew the Tarzan newspaper strip from 1929 and created Prince Valiant in 1937. His realistic figure drawing and composition set the standard for adventure comics.

What are Ben-Day dots?

Small colored dots used in printing to create tints and shades from a few inks. In old comic books the colors were made by combining dots of yellow, red and blue at different strengths.

How did DC Comics get its name?

From Detective Comics, a title launched in 1937 by Major Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson with his creditors Harry Donenfeld and Jack Liebowitz, who took over the company the following year.

Sources and further reading

  1. Grand Comics Database — indexes of Famous Funnies, New Fun and Detective Comics
  2. Famous Funnies — publication history
  3. Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson — founder of the company that became DC Comics
  4. Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum — Milton Caniff collection
  5. Library of Congress: Cartoon Drawings |
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.