The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Comic Book Art: Before Comics: Picture Stories from Hogarth to Töpffer

A page from Rodolphe Töpffer’s picture story Les Amours de Monsieur Vieux Bois, with hand-drawn panels and handwritten captions | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Comic Book Art

Comic Book Art · Chapter 1 of 9

Before Comics: Picture Stories from Hogarth to Töpffer

The comic strip had no single inventor. It was assembled over two centuries by satirists, printmakers and a Swiss schoolmaster who drew to amuse his students.

By · · 8-minute read

Rodolphe Töpffer · Public domain

People have told stories in rows of pictures for as long as there have been walls to carve. Egyptian tomb paintings, the spiral of reliefs on Trajan’s Column in Rome and the Bayeux Tapestry, which shows the Norman conquest of England in an embroidered strip 230 feet long, all ask the viewer to read images in order. Medieval manuscripts and stained-glass windows did the same with the lives of the saints, and sometimes put the characters’ words on scrolls coming out of their mouths.

None of these is a comic in the modern sense. A comic is a printed thing, made in many copies for a paying public, and it tells its story mainly through the pictures. That required the printing press, a market of readers, and artists willing to work for it. All three came together in the eighteenth century.

1732Hogarth’s A Harlot’s Progress
1827Töpffer draws Monsieur Vieux Bois
1841Punch founded in London
1865Busch’s Max and Moritz
1884Ally Sloper’s Half Holiday

Hogarth’s progress

William Hogarth was a London engraver who wanted to be a painter and found that neither trade paid. In 1731 he had the idea of painting, as he put it, “modern moral subjects,” and treating them “as a dramatic writer: my picture is my stage, and men and women my players.” The first was A Harlot’s Progress, six scenes following a country girl named Moll Hackabout from her arrival in London to her death from disease at twenty-three. He engraved the paintings himself and sold the prints by subscription in 1732. More than twelve hundred sets were ordered in advance.

A Rake’s Progress followed in 1735. In eight plates Tom Rakewell inherits a fortune, abandons the girl he has made pregnant, wastes the money on tailors, gamblers and prostitutes, marries a rich old woman, loses her fortune too, and ends chained and half naked on the floor of Bedlam, the London madhouse, while fashionable ladies stroll through to look at the lunatics.

The scenes are not panels in a strip. Each is a full, crowded picture, and months or years pass between them. But the reader must carry the characters from one image to the next and work out what has happened in between, and that is the basic act of reading comics. Hogarth packed the rooms with clues: pictures on the walls, letters on the floor, a dog stealing a watch. They rewarded slow reading and made the prints popular with people who could not afford paintings.

His success had a legal consequence. Cheap pirate copies of the Harlot appeared within weeks. Hogarth and his fellow engravers petitioned Parliament, and in 1735 it passed the Engravers’ Copyright Act, known ever since as Hogarth’s Act, which gave the designer of a print the sole right to it for fourteen years. He held back the Rake until the day the law took effect. It was the first copyright law to protect visual artists, and disputes over who owns a drawn character run through every later chapter of this history.

William Hogarth’s engraving of the final scene of A Rake’s Progress: Tom Rakewell lies half naked on the floor of Bedlam asylum | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
William Hogarth, A Rake’s Progress, plate 8 (1735). Tom Rakewell ends in Bedlam, comforted by the woman he abandoned in plate 1.William Hogarth · CC0
James Gillray’s hand-colored caricature of William Pitt and Napoleon carving up a globe shaped like a plum pudding | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
James Gillray, The Plumb-pudding in Danger (1805). Pitt and Napoleon carve up the world. It is often called the most famous political cartoon ever made.James Gillray · Public domain

The caricaturists

The generation after Hogarth turned the satirical print into a weekly business. In London between about 1780 and 1820, print shops issued hand-colored etchings on the scandal of the moment and displayed the newest in their windows, where crowds gathered to laugh at them. The masters were James Gillray, who drew George III as a penny-pinching farmer and Napoleon as a tiny, raging “Little Boney,” and Thomas Rowlandson, whose fat squires and pretty girls tumble through hundreds of comic scenes.

These artists added most of the remaining tools. They exaggerated faces and bodies until a public figure could be recognized from a nose or a waistline. They filled their prints with speech balloons, which they drew as long, wobbling loops of text. And they began to divide a single sheet into a grid of small scenes. Rowlandson’s Tours of Dr. Syntax, issued from 1809, followed one recurring comic character, a bony clergyman on a bad horse, through dozens of plates with verses underneath. Dr. Syntax hats, wigs and coats were sold in the shops, which makes him one of the first merchandised cartoon characters.

The schoolmaster of Geneva

The man with the best claim to have invented the comic strip did it for fun and was embarrassed by it. Rodolphe Töpffer was born in Geneva in 1799, the son of a painter. He meant to be a painter himself until an eye disease made close work in color impossible, so he became a schoolmaster and ran a boarding school for boys.

To entertain his pupils he drew long comic stories in notebooks, with a few pictures to a page, each in a wobbly hand-drawn frame with a line or two of text beneath. The first, The Loves of Mr. Vieux Bois, dates from 1827. Its hero is a lovesick gentleman who tries to kill himself several times, fails, elopes with his “beloved object,” and is chased across the countryside by a rival. Friends passed the notebooks around, and one found its way to the aged Goethe in Weimar, who was delighted. “If for the future he would choose a less frivolous subject,” Goethe said, “he would produce things beyond all conception.”

With that encouragement Töpffer began to publish. The Story of Mr. Jabot appeared in 1833 or 1835, and six more albums followed before his death in 1846. He reproduced them by a process called autography, which let him draw and write directly with a pen on transfer paper so that the pictures and the handwriting came out in the same loose line.

What makes these albums comics, and not illustrated stories, is something Töpffer understood and explained. “The drawings, without the text, would have only an obscure meaning,” he wrote. “The text, without the drawings, would mean nothing.” He varied the width of his panels to control time, so that a row of narrow frames makes a chase speed up. He cut back and forth between two actions happening at once. He repeated a picture with small changes to show a man’s mood shifting. And in an essay of 1845 he argued that this new kind of “literature in prints” had a future, because it spoke directly to children and to ordinary people. Mr. Vieux Bois was pirated in London and then in New York, where it was published in 1842 as The Adventures of Mr. Obadiah Oldbuck. That pirated edition is the first comic book printed in the United States.

A page of panels from Rodolphe Töpffer’s Histoire de Monsieur Jabot showing a foolish dandy at a ball | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
Rodolphe Töpffer, Histoire de M. Jabot, published in the 1830s. Hand-drawn frames, handwritten captions and a hero who cannot stop embarrassing himself.Rodolphe Töpffer · Public domain
Wilhelm Busch’s drawing from Max and Moritz of the two boys being ground up in a mill | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
Wilhelm Busch, Max und Moritz (1865). The two bad boys meet their end in the miller’s grinder and are eaten by ducks.Wilhelm Busch · Public domain

Punch and the word “cartoon”

Lithography and then the steam press made illustrated magazines cheap. In Paris, Charles Philipon founded the satirical weekly La Caricature in 1830 and the daily Le Charivari in 1832, and employed Honoré Daumier, who went to prison for six months for drawing King Louis-Philippe as a bloated giant swallowing the nation’s taxes. In London, Punch began in 1841 and lasted until 2002.

Punch gave the English language a word. In 1843 the government held an exhibition of designs for wall paintings in the new Houses of Parliament. Such full-size preparatory drawings were called cartoons. Punch responded with a series of its own “cartoons,” the first showing a crowd of ragged paupers staring at the pictures, and the name stuck to humorous drawings in general.

These magazines did not usually run strips. What they established was a profession. By the 1860s a talented draftsman in London, Paris, Munich or New York could make a living drawing for the weekly humor press, and publishers were looking for features that would bring readers back.

Max and Moritz

The most influential picture story of the century came from Germany. Wilhelm Busch was a failed painter living in his home village in Lower Saxony when he sent a publisher in Munich a tale in verse about two horrible boys. Max und Moritz: A Story of Boys in Seven Tricks came out in 1865.

In each trick the pair torment a different villager. They kill a widow’s chickens, saw through a bridge so that the tailor falls in the stream, fill the schoolmaster’s pipe with gunpowder and put beetles in their uncle’s bed. In the seventh they are caught slitting grain sacks, and the farmer has them ground up at the mill. Nobody in the village is sorry.

Busch’s drawing is quick, rubbery and violent, and he was a master of showing motion and impact with a few lines. The rhymed couplets are still quoted by German speakers the way English speakers quote nursery rhymes. The book sold slowly at first and then never stopped, and it was translated into dozens of languages. Its importance to American comics is direct. In 1897 an editor at William Randolph Hearst’s New York Journal asked a young German-born artist to create something like Max and Moritz. The result was The Katzenjammer Kids, described in the next chapter.

The first comics star

Britain produced the first recurring comic character to carry a publication on his own. Ally Sloper, a gin-soaked schemer with a bulbous nose and a battered top hat, first appeared in the magazine Judy in 1867. His adventures were written by Charles Ross and for many years drawn by Ross’s wife, the French artist Marie Duval, one of the first women to work as a cartoonist. His name is a joke. A man who “slopes” off down the alley is one who is avoiding the rent collector.

In 1884 he was given a weekly paper of his own, Ally Sloper’s Half Holiday, which sold for a penny and was aimed at the clerks and working men who now had Saturday afternoons off. At its height it is said to have sold some 350,000 copies a week. There were Sloper mugs, pipes, sweets and music-hall songs, and W. C. Fields is said to have borrowed something of his look.

The front page of the British comic weekly Ally Sloper’s Half Holiday from 1892, with a large cartoon of the bulbous-nosed Sloper | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Ally Sloper’s Half Holiday, April 2, 1892. The penny weekly was built around a single comic character and is often counted as the first comic magazine.Gilbert Dalziel · Public domain
A double page from Hokusai’s Manga sketchbooks with dozens of small comic figures in lively poses | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
A spread from the Hokusai Manga, the sketchbooks the Japanese master began publishing in 1814. The title means roughly “random drawings,” and the word was later adopted for Japanese comics.Katsushika Hokusai · Public domain

A parallel tradition

Europe was not alone. Japan had a long history of humorous picture scrolls, and in the Edo period its woodblock publishers issued cheap illustrated storybooks by the thousand. In 1814 the great printmaker Katsushika Hokusai began publishing volumes of sketches of people, animals, ghosts and landscapes under the title Manga. They were not stories, but they were full of comic invention, and they sold all over Japan and later astonished artists in Paris. After Japan opened to the West, cartoonists there combined this native tradition with the model of Punch and, later, of American newspaper strips. The word manga was taken up for the result. That story returns in the last chapter.

America, meanwhile, had its own humor weeklies. Puck, founded in New York in 1876 by the Austrian-born cartoonist Joseph Keppler, and its rivals Judge and Life printed large color lithographs on politics along with pages of small black-and-white gags. Many of the artists who would create the first newspaper strips, Richard Outcault and Frederick Opper among them, learned their trade there.

What was still missing

By the 1880s all the parts existed. There were picture sequences, panel borders, speech balloons, recurring characters and a mass readership. They had not yet been combined into one standard form, and nobody was yet making a living from comics alone. The combination took place in the United States, where two newspaper publishers with new color presses went to war over readers in the 1890s.

More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Bayeux Tapestry scene57 Harold death — Comic Book Art
Bayeux Tapestry scene57 Harold deathMyrabella · Public domain
Bayeux Tapestry 32-33 comet Halley Harold — Comic Book Art
Bayeux Tapestry 32-33 comet Halley HaroldMyrabella · Public domain
William Hogarth - A Rake's Progress, Plate II, His Levee - B1981.25.1412 - Yale Center for British Art — Comic Book Art
William Hogarth – A Rake’s Progress, Plate II, His Levee – B1981.25.1412 – Yale Center for British ArtWilliam Hogarth · CC0
A Rake's Progress, Plate 4 MET DP825201 — Comic Book Art
A Rake’s Progress, Plate 4 MET DP825201William Hogarth · CC0
A Rake's Progress, Plate 7 MET DP825210 — Comic Book Art
A Rake’s Progress, Plate 7 MET DP825210William Hogarth · CC0
Max und Moritz (Busch) 029 — Comic Book Art
Max und Moritz (Busch) 029Wilhelm Busch · Public domain
Max und Moritz (Busch) 070 — Comic Book Art
Max und Moritz (Busch) 070Wilhelm Busch · Public domain
Max und Moritz (Busch) 091 — Comic Book Art
Max und Moritz (Busch) 091Wilhelm Busch · Public domain
Ally Sloper's Half Holiday, 1 octobre 1892, couverture — Comic Book Art
Ally Sloper’s Half Holiday, 1 octobre 1892, couvertureGilbert Dalziel · Public domain
Ally Sloper by W. G. Baxter — Comic Book Art
Ally Sloper by W. G. BaxterW. G. Baxter · Public domain
The Plumb-pudding in danger (NAPOLEON 156) — Comic Book Art
The Plumb-pudding in danger (NAPOLEON 156)James Gillray · Public domain

Questions people ask

Who invented the comic strip?

No one person. The Swiss teacher Rodolphe Töpffer, who published picture stories with panels and captions in the 1830s and 1840s, is most often called the father of the comic strip. Earlier artists such as William Hogarth told stories in sequences of prints.

What is Hogarth’s Act?

The Engravers’ Copyright Act of 1735, passed by the British Parliament after William Hogarth campaigned against pirate copies of his prints. It was the first copyright law to protect visual artists.

What was the first comic book published in America?

The Adventures of Mr. Obadiah Oldbuck, an unauthorized 1842 New York edition of Rodolphe Töpffer’s Les Amours de Monsieur Vieux Bois.

Where does the word “cartoon” come from?

From the Italian cartone, a large sheet of paper used for full-size preparatory drawings. In 1843 the magazine Punch used the word jokingly for its satirical drawings, and that meaning took over.

What is Max and Moritz?

An 1865 illustrated story in verse by the German artist Wilhelm Busch about two boys who play seven cruel tricks and come to a bad end. It directly inspired the American strip The Katzenjammer Kids.

Where does the word “manga” come from?

From Japanese words meaning roughly “whimsical” or “random pictures.” The artist Hokusai used it as the title of his popular sketchbooks from 1814, and it later became the Japanese word for comics.

Sources and further reading

  1. Encyclopaedia Britannica: Comic strip — origins and history
  2. Rodolphe Töpffer — life and picture stories
  3. Tate, London — William Hogarth
  4. Engraving Copyright Act (Hogarth’s Act) |
  5. Lambiek Comiclopedia — biographies of comic artists worldwide
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.