The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Where It Ended: The Paper, the Ship and the Memory

The Battleship Missouri Memorial at Pearl Harbor, overlooking the Arizona Memorial.
The Instrument of Surrender.
The marker on the surrender deck.
Missouri and the Arizona Memorial.
Develop the photograph · 4 real photographs

Pacific Theater · Japan · Chapter 9 of 9 · 1945 – today

Where It Ended: The Paper, the Ship and the Memory

A document in Washington, a battleship moored beside the Arizona, a dent that was never repaired, and what the morning of 2 September 1945 came to mean.

By Christopher Adkins · The Lake Norman Brief · 6 min read

The Battleship Missouri Memorial at Pearl Harbor, overlooking the Arizona Memorial. Wikimedia Commons
The Instrument of Surrender. Wikimedia Commons
The marker on the surrender deck. Wikimedia Commons
Missouri and the Arizona Memorial. Wikimedia Commons

The table from the crew’s mess is at Annapolis. The paper is in Washington. The ship is at Pearl Harbor, pointing at the wreck where the American war began.

Key facts

7 Sep 1945The Allied copy is presented to President Truman
Fewer than 500Words in the Instrument of Surrender
1991Missouri fires her guns in the Gulf War
29 Jan 1999The Battleship Missouri Memorial opens at Pearl Harbor
11 Apr 1945A kamikaze strikes Missouri off Okinawa
5 Sep 1945USS North Carolina anchors in Tokyo Bay

The paper

Two documents were signed on 2 September. The Allied copy, in its leather folder, was flown to Washington by Col. Bernard Theilen, presented to President Truman at the White House on 7 September and placed in the National Archives, which still holds it. The Japanese copy, with Sutherland’s corrections in the margin (Chapter 6), went to the Foreign Ministry in Tokyo and is kept in its Diplomatic Archives; a facsimile is shown at the Edo-Tokyo Museum.

The instrument itself is eight short paragraphs. It accepts the Potsdam Declaration, proclaims the unconditional surrender of all Japanese forces, orders them to cease hostilities and preserve their ships and aircraft, commands all officials to obey the Supreme Commander, promises the release of Allied prisoners, and states that the authority of the Emperor and the government shall be subject to the Supreme Commander. It runs to fewer than five hundred words.

Gallery · 5 photographs · select to enlarge

The documents

The Instrument of Surrender, signed 2 September 1945.
The Instrument of Surrender, signed 2 September 1945.Photo: United States War Department [2] [3] · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
The Instrument of Surrender: the signature page.
The Instrument of Surrender: the signature page.Photo: World Imaging · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
A copy of the Japanese version of the surrender document, displayed aboard the Missouri.
A copy of the Japanese version of the surrender document, displayed aboard the Missouri.Photo: The original uploader was Briaryos at English Wikipedia . · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
A facsimile of the Instrument of Surrender at the Edo-Tokyo Museum.
A facsimile of the Instrument of Surrender at the Edo-Tokyo Museum.Photo: Joe Mabel on Flickr as Joe Mabel from Seattle, US · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
A Navy officer views an exhibit of the Japanese surrender documents.
A Navy officer views an exhibit of the Japanese surrender documents.Photo: General Services Administration. National Archives and Records Service. 1949-198 · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The ship

Missouri went on to a long life. She was the only American battleship in commission when the Korean War began and fired the first battleship bombardment of that war. She was laid up in 1955 at Bremerton, Washington, where for thirty years visitors walked her deck to look at a bronze plaque set into the teak. In 1986 she was modernized with cruise missiles and recommissioned, and in January 1991, forty-six years after Tokyo Bay, she fired Tomahawks and her sixteen-inch guns in the Gulf War. She was decommissioned for the last time in 1992.

In 1998 she was towed to Pearl Harbor and moored on Battleship Row at Ford Island, where she opened as a museum on 29 January 1999, fifty-five years to the day after her launching. She lies bow-on to the sunken Arizona, a few hundred yards away. Visitors can stand at the beginning and the end of the American war in the same glance.

2 September 1945
Today
2 September 1945Today
USS Missouri in Tokyo Bay during the ceremony, and moored at Pearl Harbor as a memorial, overlooking the Arizona Memorial.Left: Photo: Ted H. Lambert (by my father, Ted H. Lambert, from his B-29) · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons Right: Photo: Petty Officer 2nd Class Mark Logico · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Gallery · 6 photographs · select to enlarge

USS Missouri, then and now

The marker on Missouri’s deck at the spot where the surrender was signed.
The marker on Missouri’s deck at the spot where the surrender was signed.Photo: U.S. Navy · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
The plaque on the surrender deck.
The plaque on the surrender deck.Photo: Camera Operator: JOC(AW) GLORIA MONTGOMERY · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
The surrender site on the deck of the Missouri at Pearl Harbor.
The surrender site on the deck of the Missouri at Pearl Harbor.Photo: Aaron Zhu · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Tugs move Missouri to her berth at Ford Island, Pearl Harbor.
Tugs move Missouri to her berth at Ford Island, Pearl Harbor.Photo: US Navy · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
The Battleship Missouri Memorial at Pearl Harbor.
The Battleship Missouri Memorial at Pearl Harbor.Photo: Petty Officer 2nd Class Mark Logico · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
A ceremony aboard the Missouri marking the anniversary of the end of the war.
A ceremony aboard the Missouri marking the anniversary of the end of the war.Photo: Petty Officer 2nd Class NPASEWest Hawaii · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The dent

On Missouri’s starboard side, aft, just below the main deck, there is a dent in the hull. On 11 April 1945, off Okinawa, a kamikaze Zero came in low through the ship’s fire and struck there. Its bomb did not explode. A wing was thrown forward and started a fire that was quickly put out, and the pilot’s body was found among the wreckage on deck. The captain, William Callaghan, whose brother had been killed commanding a cruiser force off Guadalcanal, ordered that the pilot be buried at sea the next morning with military honors. Crewmen sewed a Japanese flag overnight. Some of the crew objected. Callaghan’s view was that the man had done his duty as he saw it. The dent was never repaired.

A North Carolina connection

The battleship USS North Carolina, now a memorial at Wilmington, was with the Third Fleet off Japan when the war ended. She sent sailors and Marines ashore for the first occupation duty at Yokosuka and anchored in Tokyo Bay on 5 September to take them back aboard before sailing for home. She had been in the Pacific since the summer of 1942 and had fought from Guadalcanal to the bombardment of the Japanese home islands.

What it meant

The Second World War killed something like sixty to eighty million people. The part of it that ended in Tokyo Bay had begun, depending on how you count, at Pearl Harbor in 1941, at the Marco Polo Bridge in 1937, or in Manchuria in 1931. It ended without the invasion of Japan that both sides had prepared for, and that might have cost more lives than all the Pacific fighting before it.

The countries that signed the instrument that morning became, within a few years, something no one on the deck would have predicted. Japan and the United States became allies and have remained so for longer than the two were ever enemies. Japan has not sent its forces into combat since. The men on the Missouri could not know that. What they knew, when the aircraft came over and the sun came out, was that for the first time since 1939 no one, anywhere, was at war.

Gallery · 4 photographs · select to enlarge

Remembering

USS Missouri and the Arizona Memorial at Pearl Harbor.
USS Missouri and the Arizona Memorial at Pearl Harbor.Photo: Shellcreek · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
A memorial in Tokyo to the Treaty of San Francisco.
A memorial in Tokyo to the Treaty of San Francisco.Photo: 2008年東京で自分で撮影 · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
The Missouri seen from the Arizona Memorial.
The Missouri seen from the Arizona Memorial.Photo: Stan Shebs · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
A V-J Day parade at Pearl Harbor, 3 September 1945.
A V-J Day parade at Pearl Harbor, 3 September 1945.Photo: Navy Medicine from Washington, DC, USA · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Visiting

The Battleship Missouri Memorial at Pearl Harbor is open daily; the surrender deck is on the standard tour route and the dent can be seen from the pier side. The Instrument of Surrender is displayed at the National Archives in Washington. In North Carolina, the Battleship North Carolina at Wilmington is open year-round.

Sources and further reading

  1. National Archives, DocsTeach, “Instrument of Surrender of Japan” — the Instrument of Surrender in the National Archives
  2. National Archives, Milestone Documents, “Surrender of Japan (1945)” — the document’s history and text
  3. Battleship Missouri Memorial, “The Surrender” — the ship’s later career, the memorial and the kamikaze attack of 11 April 1945
  4. Naval History and Heritage Command, “Deck Plan of USS Missouri (BB-63) During the Surrender Ceremony” — the Navy’s record of the ceremony

The Lake Norman Brief · History collections

Keep reading the Second World War

Every collection on lkn-law.com is free to read and built from official histories, archives and public-domain photographs. The Lake Norman Brief is published by Christopher Adkins of Adkins Law, PLLC, in Huntersville, North Carolina.

Surrender in Tokyo Bay collectionAll World War II collectionsThe Manhattan Project