The Yellow Kid and the Newspaper Wars
In the 1890s two New York publishers fought for readers with color presses and Sunday supplements. A bald street urchin in a yellow nightshirt became the prize, and the comic strip was born in the crossfire.
By Christopher Adkins · · 8-minute read
The American newspaper of the 1890s was the first true mass medium. Fast rotary presses, cheap wood-pulp paper and the telegraph let a big-city daily print half a million copies and sell them for a penny or two. The readers were the crowds pouring into the cities, many of them immigrants who were still learning English. Publishers discovered that pictures sold papers to people who could not yet read the articles.
The comic strip came out of that discovery. It was shaped by a commercial fight between two men, Joseph Pulitzer and William Randolph Hearst, and its first star was a jug-eared child from the tenements.
Pulitzer’s Sunday paper
Joseph Pulitzer was a Hungarian immigrant who had made a fortune in St. Louis and bought the failing New York World in 1883. He aimed it at working people, filled it with crusades, crimes and stunts, and by the early 1890s had the largest circulation in the country. His great innovation was the Sunday edition, a thick bundle of supplements with something for every member of the family.
In 1893 the World installed a press that could print in color, and that May it began issuing a Sunday humor supplement modeled on the weekly comic magazines Puck, Judge and Life. The early color was crude. Each color needed a separate plate, the paper stretched, and the tints landed in the wrong places. But nothing like it had ever come with a newspaper, and other cities copied it within months.
Among the artists who sold drawings to the supplement was Richard Felton Outcault, born in Lancaster, Ohio, in 1863. He had been a technical draftsman for Thomas Edison and drew for the humor weeklies on the side. His specialty was the slum child. New York’s Lower East Side was then the most crowded place on earth, and comfortable readers were both alarmed and fascinated by the children who lived in its streets.
The kid in the nightshirt
Outcault began drawing large single-panel scenes of tenement life under titles such as Hogan’s Alley. Each is a wide view of a back lot swarming with children who are staging their own version of some grown-up event, a golf tournament, a horse show or a political convention. The first of these to appear in the World ran on May 5, 1895.
In the crowd there was a small boy with big ears, a shaved head and a nightshirt that reached his feet. Slum children had their heads shaved against lice and wore hand-me-down gowns, so the figure was drawn from life. Over the following months he moved to the front of the picture. Early in 1896 the World‘s printers, testing a new quick-drying yellow ink, tried it on his nightshirt, and readers started calling him the Yellow Kid. Outcault gave him a name, Mickey Dugan, though it was hardly ever used.
The Kid did not speak in balloons at first. His words were printed on the front of his shirt, in a thick street dialect: “Say! Dis is de real ting.” He grinned straight out of the page at the reader, a commentator on the chaos behind him. He became the first comic character to be a national craze. Within a year there were Yellow Kid buttons, cigarettes, chewing gum, whiskey, sheet music, dolls and a Broadway show.


Hearst arrives
William Randolph Hearst was thirty-two, the son of a California mining millionaire, and had already turned the San Francisco Examiner into a success by imitating Pulitzer. In the autumn of 1895 he bought the New York Journal and set out to beat his model. His method was to outspend him. In January 1896 he hired away the entire staff of the Sunday World in one stroke. Pulitzer hired them back, and Hearst raised his offer and took them again within a day.
That October Hearst launched his own color comic supplement, advertised as “eight pages of iridescent polychromous effulgence that makes the rainbow look like a lead pipe.” Its star was Outcault, lured over with a large salary, and the Yellow Kid went with him. Pulitzer hired another artist, George Luks, later a well-known painter, to go on drawing Hogan’s Alley for the World. So for about a year New York had two Yellow Kids, in two papers, drawn by two men, and both publishers plastered the city with posters of him.
The fight was a milestone in the law of comics as well. Outcault had tried to copyright the Kid and found the protection uncertain. The practical outcome was a division that later cases confirmed: the World kept the title Hogan’s Alley, and Outcault was free to take his character elsewhere under a different name. The principle that a feature’s title could belong to the newspaper while the artist kept the right to draw the characters would matter a great deal in the years ahead.
Yellow journalism
The two papers were competing in more than comics. Both ran screaming headlines, faked interviews, lurid crime stories and, as rebellion spread in Spanish-ruled Cuba, daily calls for war. Critics looked for a name for this kind of newspaper. Early in 1897 Ervin Wardman, editor of the sober New York Press, began referring to “the yellow-kid journalism” of the World and the Journal, and soon shortened it to “yellow journalism.”
The phrase has outlived everything else about the character. In 1898 the cartoonist Leon Barritt summed up the affair in a drawing that showed Pulitzer and Hearst, each dressed in a yellow nightshirt, shoving at a pile of toy blocks that spell WAR. The United States declared war on Spain that April.
Outcault dropped the Kid in 1898. The craze had passed, and respectable readers had begun to complain that the feature was vulgar. Some libraries and clubs banned the yellow papers from their reading rooms. It was the first campaign against comics as a bad influence, and there would be others.


From panel to strip
The Yellow Kid pages were mostly single big pictures. The strip, a row of panels read in sequence with the dialogue in balloons, was put together by other artists in Hearst’s supplement over the next few years.
Rudolph Dirks was twenty when the Journal‘s comics editor, Rudolph Block, asked him for something in the spirit of Wilhelm Busch’s Max and Moritz. The Katzenjammer Kids began on December 12, 1897. Hans and Fritz are two boys who make war on every adult in reach, above all their mother, the Captain and the Inspector, and they are spanked in the last panel nearly every week. The characters speak a comic German-English that readers loved. Dirks was among the first to use speech balloons and a fixed series of panels every week, and he popularized much of the shorthand that cartoonists still use, including lines for speed, stars for pain and a sawing log for snoring.
Frederick Burr Opper was already a famous magazine cartoonist when Hearst hired him in 1899. His Happy Hooligan, begun in 1900, follows a kind-hearted tramp with a tin can for a hat whose every attempt to help someone lands him in the hands of the police. Opper, more than anyone, made the balloon the normal way for comic characters to talk. James Swinnerton, who had drawn little bears for Hearst in San Francisco as early as 1892, contributed tigers and small boys.
By about 1903 the form was standard. A Sunday page had a title across the top, a dozen or so panels read left to right in tiers, characters who returned every week, and a joke or a disaster in the last panel. Hearst’s rivals called his supplement “the funnies,” and the name spread to the whole medium.


Buster Brown and the business of characters
Outcault had one more hit. In May 1902, in the New York Herald, he introduced a boy as different from the Yellow Kid as he could manage. Buster Brown is the son of a wealthy suburban family, dressed in a Little Lord Fauntleroy suit with a wide hat and a pageboy haircut. He has a talking bulldog named Tige and a talent for mischief, and every page ends with a hand-lettered “resolution” in which he promises, unconvincingly, to do better.
Buster was respectable enough for the middle-class home, and Outcault had learned from his earlier experience. At the St. Louis World’s Fair of 1904 he set up a booth and sold licenses to use the character to some two hundred manufacturers. The Brown Shoe Company of St. Louis was one of them, and it sold Buster Brown shoes for more than a century, long after anyone remembered the strip. Outcault made far more from licensing than from drawing.
When Hearst hired him away from the Herald in 1906, the result was a lawsuit that settled the earlier question formally. The court held that the Herald owned the title Buster Brown and could continue it with another artist, and that Outcault could draw the same characters for Hearst so long as he did not use the name on the page. Rudolph Dirks went through the same thing in 1912 to 1914. He left Hearst for Pulitzer, the courts awarded the title The Katzenjammer Kids to Hearst, and Dirks continued his own version as The Captain and the Kids. The two strips ran side by side for decades.
These rulings look odd today, when a character is treated as property in its own right, protected by both copyright and trademark. In the first years of the century the law had not caught up with the business. Judges reasoned from older ideas about the names of newspapers and books, and artists had enough bargaining power to walk away with their creations. That balance would shift decisively toward publishers in the 1930s, with consequences described in the chapters on the Golden Age and after.
It is also worth noting how many of these pioneers were immigrants or the children of immigrants, drawing for an audience of the same. The broken English of the Katzenjammers and the Irish slang of Hogan’s Alley were jokes the readers were in on.
Syndication
One more invention completed the system. A newspaper outside New York could not afford its own comic artists. In the first years of the century Hearst and others began selling their features to papers across the country, shipping out printed supplements or printing plates each week. Hearst organized this business as King Features Syndicate in 1915.
Syndication changed the scale of the thing. A popular strip might run in several hundred papers and reach tens of millions of readers a day. It made cartoonists some of the best-paid people in America, and it meant that a child in Charlotte and a child in Chicago were reading the same page on the same Sunday. It also fixed a pattern of ownership. The syndicate, in most cases, owned the strip, and the artist was an employee who could be replaced.
By 1905 every large American newspaper had a color comic section, and a new profession existed. The artists who entered it in the next few years took the crude, noisy form invented in the newspaper war and turned it into something no one had expected.


Gallery
More works related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.









Questions people ask
Who created the Yellow Kid?
Richard F. Outcault, who drew the character in his Hogan’s Alley panels for Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World beginning in 1895 and then for William Randolph Hearst’s New York Journal from 1896.
Where does the term “yellow journalism” come from?
From the Yellow Kid. In 1897 the editor Ervin Wardman called the sensational reporting of Pulitzer’s World and Hearst’s Journal, which both ran Yellow Kid comics, “yellow-kid journalism,” later shortened to “yellow journalism.”
Was the Yellow Kid the first comic strip?
Not strictly. Picture stories and strips existed earlier, and the Yellow Kid mostly appeared in single large panels. But it was the first newspaper comic to become a national sensation, and it showed publishers that comics sold papers.
What was the first comic strip to use speech balloons regularly?
Rudolph Dirks’s The Katzenjammer Kids (1897) and Frederick Opper’s Happy Hooligan (1900) made speech balloons and sequential panels the standard form of the American strip.
Who was Buster Brown?
A comic strip character created by Richard Outcault in 1902, a wealthy, mischievous boy with a bulldog named Tige. Outcault licensed him widely, most famously to the Brown Shoe Company.
Who owned early comic strip characters?
Courts in the Buster Brown and Katzenjammer Kids cases held that the newspaper owned the title of a strip, while the artist could continue to draw the characters elsewhere under another name.
Sources and further reading
- Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum — Yellow Kid digital album and original pages
- Library of Congress — newspaper comic supplements and the Pulitzer-Hearst cartoon
- The Yellow Kid — publication history
- The Katzenjammer Kids — the strip and the ownership lawsuit
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Yellow journalism |