The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Bosch: Hell and the Last Judgment

The Vienna Last Judgment triptych, its central and right panels filled with scenes of torment in a dark burning landscape | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins

Art › Hieronymus Bosch

Hieronymus Bosch · Chapter 6 of 9

Hell and the Last Judgment

No painter before Bosch had imagined damnation in such detail, and few have matched him since.

By · · 8-minute read

Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain

Medieval churches had shown the Last Judgment for centuries, usually over the door, as a diagram: Christ in the middle, the saved to his right, the lost to his left. Bosch turned the diagram into a place.

Souls guided by angels rise through a tunnel of light toward heaven | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
Ascent of the Blessed (Venice): souls drawn through a tunnel into light.Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Dark panels showing the damned falling and tormented by demons | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
Fall of the Damned and Hell, two more of the four Venice panels.Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain

Hell before Bosch

The doctrine was simple and everyone knew it. At the end of time the dead would rise, Christ would return as judge, and each soul would be sent either to eternal joy or to eternal fire. Sculptors carved the scene over the west doors of cathedrals, where the congregation passed under it on the way in. Painters put it on the walls of town halls, where judges sat. In the Netherlands the great example was Rogier van der Weyden’s altarpiece for the hospital at Beaune, painted in the 1440s: a calm gold sky, St. Michael weighing souls, the blessed walking to a church door on one side and the damned stumbling, naked and howling, into a dark crack on the other.

Rogier shows the damned but hardly shows Hell. Other sources did. The Vision of Tundale, a twelfth-century Irish account of a knight’s journey through the afterlife, described in detail a beast that swallows sinners and passes them out again onto a frozen lake, and a bridge studded with nails over a valley of fire. It was printed in Dutch in ’s-Hertogenbosch itself in 1484. Preachers elaborated on the punishment that fit each sin, and at mystery plays the entrance to Hell was a painted monster’s mouth that opened and belched smoke. Bosch gave these scattered materials a landscape, a light and a population.

The Vienna triptych

In the Last Judgment at the Academy of Fine Arts in Vienna, heaven is a small bright patch at the top where Christ sits on a rainbow with the Virgin, John the Baptist and the apostles, and four angels blow long trumpets. Almost nobody is going up. Everything else in the central panel, perhaps nine-tenths of it, is punishment.

The earth is a scorched plain under a black sky lit by burning towns. The damned are roasted on spits, fried in pans, shod like horses, ground in mills and made to drink from barrels. A fat man is force-fed by a devil from a cask filled by another devil in a way best left undescribed. A woman is put to bed with a lizard. Men are hung from a meat hook, sliced by a knife the size of a ship, and turned on a wheel. Each torment fits a sin, and the instruments are the tools of an ordinary Brabant kitchen and forge, which is part of what makes them hard to shrug off.

The left wing gives the reason. It runs from top to bottom: the rebel angels fall from heaven as a swarm of dark insects, God creates Eve, the serpent offers the fruit, and an angel drives the first couple out of the garden. The right wing is Hell proper, darker and hotter than the center, with Satan as a lord in a doorway receiving his new subjects. The story therefore has no happy ending. It is the history of the world as a slide, with the central panel showing the last day arriving on an earth that has already become most of the way to Hell.

Closed, the wings show two saints in gray: St. James the Greater as a pilgrim walking through a landscape full of robbers, and St. Bavo of Ghent giving alms to the poor. The triptych is a little over five feet high. It has been in Vienna since 1822, when Count Lamberg-Sprinzenstein left his collection to the Academy.

The open Last Judgment triptych in Vienna: Paradise on the left, a vast dark scene of punishment in the center and Hell on the right | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
The Vienna Last Judgment open. Christ and the saints occupy a small bright area at the top of the central panel. The rest belongs to the demons.Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
The closed wings of the Vienna Last Judgment showing two saints painted in gray tones | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
The closed wings: St. James the Greater on the road and St. Bavo with the poor at his feet, both painted in grisaille.Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain

The duke’s Judgment

In September 1504 Philip the Fair, ruler of the Netherlands, paid Bosch an advance of thirty-six pounds for a painting of “the Judgment of God, namely Paradise and Hell,” to be nine feet high and eleven feet wide. It is the only documented commission of his career. Philip died suddenly in Spain two years later, and nothing more is heard of the picture.

Is the Vienna triptych connected with it? It is far too small to be the work described. But St. James is the patron saint of Spain, where Philip had just become king through his wife, and St. Bavo is the patron of Ghent, a chief city of his Netherlandish lands. That pairing would suit him better than anyone else. One suggestion is that the Vienna painting is a reduced version, made in Bosch’s shop, of the huge lost original. Tree-ring dating places it comfortably in the right years.

A second Last Judgment, in the Groeningemuseum in Bruges, is smaller again. It was long treated as a workshop piece. After studying the underdrawing, the Bosch Research and Conservation Project concluded in 2016 that it is by Bosch himself, painted about 1495 to 1505. In it the earth and Hell have merged completely. There is no separate middle zone at all, only a paradise with a fountain and a ship of the blessed on the left, and fire everywhere else.

One more candidate has been put forward for the duke’s commission. The Alte Pinakothek in Munich owns a fragment, about two feet high, cut from the lower corner of a much larger Last Judgment. On a dark ground the dead climb out of their graves, among them a king and a bishop, while demons with insect wings and fish bodies move in to collect them. If the figures are taken as a guide to scale, the complete painting would have been enormous. For much of the twentieth century it was thought to be the only surviving piece of Philip’s picture. The 2016 project attributed it to a follower working after Bosch’s death, so the mystery of the lost Judgment remains open.

The loss matters because the big painting was presumably the version of Hell that the court saw, and the one that fixed Bosch’s name with the subject. What survives in Vienna and Bruges is Hell at household size.

How the demons are made

The demons are his invention. Earlier devils were shaggy men with horns, bat wings and a second face on the belly. Bosch’s are assembled from parts that should not go together: a head on legs with no body, a bird in armor, a fish with a human face, a knife between two ears, a lizard wearing a nun’s veil. Many are part animal and part household object. A jug has feet, and a helmet has a tail.

They are convincing because every piece is painted from life. The fur is real fur, the pewter shines like pewter, and the frog is a frog he had looked at. The same care goes into what they carry. Hell’s equipment is a full inventory of a late medieval town: ladders, barrels, bellows, harrows, lanterns, cooking pots, funnels, hunting horns and knives stamped with a cutler’s mark. That mark, a letter on the blade of the great knife, appears in several of his paintings. Den Bosch was known for its knives, and writers have tried without success to tie the mark to a real maker.

Just as striking is how busy the demons are. In older pictures devils gloat. Bosch’s devils work. They carry, stoke, saw, pour and keep lists, with the bored competence of people doing a job, and they pay little attention to the victims. The effect is closer to a factory than to a battlefield, and it is the detail later centuries found most modern.

The Last Judgment triptych in Bruges, with a small heaven above a dark landscape of fires and tormented figures | LKN Law art history, Chris Adkins
The Bruges Last Judgment (Groeningemuseum). Since 2016 it has been accepted as Bosch’s own work.Hieronymus Bosch and workshop · Public domain
Sixteenth-century engraving after Bosch showing a Last Judgment in three sections with many small demons | lkn-law.com, Charles Christopher Adkins
A Last Judgment “after Bosch,” engraved in Antwerp in the 1560s. Prints of this kind spread his version of Hell across Europe.Cornelis Cort · Public domain

The punishments

The logic of Bosch’s Hell is the logic of the sermons, which taught that each sinner would be punished through the thing he had loved. So gluttons are fed filth, or are themselves cooked and eaten. The lazy are hammered on an anvil. The angry are butchered. The proud woman is made to look into a mirror on a demon’s backside. Misers are boiled, or made to pass gold coins, and in The Garden of Earthly Delights musicians are racked on their own instruments.

What sets these scenes apart from earlier ones is that the damned are not grotesque. They are slim, pale and naked, exactly like the lovers in the Garden, and exactly like the souls in paradise. Bosch does not let the viewer think of them as a different kind of person. The only difference between the people on the left wing and the people on the right is what they chose.

There is also the fire. No earlier painter had shown night like this. The backgrounds of the Vienna triptych, the Garden and the Haywain are black, with towns burning from inside so that windows and doorways glow, sparks rise, and the light catches the underside of the smoke. Bosch had seen a town burn when he was a boy. Whatever the source, these are the first great night scenes in northern painting.

The tunnel of light

Four narrow panels in Venice, the Visions of the Hereafter, show both outcomes. They were probably the wings of a lost altarpiece and are painted on the back in imitation of red and green stone. Two are dark. In the Fall of the Damned bodies drop through blackness, pulled down by demons. In the River to Hell a man sits on the bank of a burning lake with his head in his hand while a devil tugs at his arm.

The other two are bright. In the Earthly Paradise angels lead a small group of the saved up a green hill to a fountain, an old idea of a waiting place where souls are washed before going on. In the Ascent of the Blessed naked souls, each escorted by one or two angels, float up through the darkness toward a great cylinder of light. It is drawn in rings, like the inside of a tunnel. At the far end a tiny figure stands waiting in a white glare, and the souls closest to it have let go of their angels.

Nothing like it exists in earlier art. The idea may come from the Flemish mystics, such as Jan van Ruusbroec, who wrote of the soul passing through an abyss into a brightness without form. Readers of modern accounts of near-death experiences find it uncannily familiar. The panels were in the collection of Cardinal Domenico Grimani in Venice by 1521 and have never left the city.

Panel from the Visions of the Hereafter: a despairing man sits by a dark burning lake as a demon pulls at him | Lake Norman Brief art series, Christopher Adkins
The River to Hell from the Visions of the Hereafter (Venice). One of the damned sits with his head in his hand at the water’s edge.Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Panel from the Visions of the Hereafter: angels guide the saved up a green hill toward a fountain | The Lake Norman Brief, by Christopher Adkins
The Earthly Paradise from the same set. Angels lead the saved to the fountain on the hill before their ascent.Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain

Why it lasted

Bosch’s Hell replaced what had come before. For a century after his death, a painter in the Netherlands who was asked for a Last Judgment or a Temptation painted it more or less in his manner, and the prints issued in Antwerp under his name took the imagery to Spain, Italy and Germany. Pieter Bruegel’s Triumph of Death and Dulle Griet are unthinkable without it, as the last chapter describes.

Its hold on later imaginations has a simple explanation. Other painters asked the viewer to believe in Hell. Bosch made it possible to picture one, down to the brand of the knives. The modern idea of what damnation looks like, with its night sky, its fires and its busy, inventive devils, owes more to these few panels than to any theologian.

Works and details related to this chapter. Select any image to enlarge it; each carries its source and credit.

Hieronymus Bosch - The Last Judgment (Academy of Fine Arts Vienna) — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Hieronymus Bosch – The Last Judgment (Academy of Fine Arts Vienna)Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Jheronimus Bosch Last Judgment triptych (Vienna) exterior — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Jheronimus Bosch Last Judgment triptych (Vienna) exteriorHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Hieronymus Bosch, The Last Judgment — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Hieronymus Bosch, The Last JudgmentHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Hieronymus Bosch - The Last Judgement — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Hieronymus Bosch – The Last JudgementHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Jheronimus Bosch 097 central panel 02 detail 01 — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Jheronimus Bosch 097 central panel 02 detail 01Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
The Last Judgment (central panel), ca. 1482-1515 — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
The Last Judgment (central panel), ca. 1482-1515Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Jheronimus Bosch 097 central panel 02 detail 04 — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Jheronimus Bosch 097 central panel 02 detail 04Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Last judgement Bosch — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Last judgement BoschHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Bosch laatste oordeel drieluik wenen — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Bosch laatste oordeel drieluik wenenHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Hieronymus Bosch 013 — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Hieronymus Bosch 013Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Accademia - Visioni dell'Aldilà - L'inferno - Bosch — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Accademia – Visioni dell’Aldilà – L’inferno – BoschDidier Descouens · Public domain
Jheronimus Bosch Terrestrial Paradise — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Jheronimus Bosch Terrestrial ParadiseHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the Hereafter (downsized & contrasted) — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the Hereafter (downsized & contrasted)Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Hieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Heaven The Ascent of the Blessed — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Hieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Heaven The Ascent of the BlessedHieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Heaven: Th… · Public domain
Visions of the Hereafter - Ascent of the Blessed — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Visions of the Hereafter – Ascent of the BlessedHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the Hereafter (cropped4) — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the Hereafter (cropped4)Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the Hereafter — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the HereafterHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Hieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Hell The River to Hell — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Hieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Hell The River to HellHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Visions of the Hereafter - Hell — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Visions of the Hereafter – HellHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the Hereafter (cropped2) — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Poliptyk Hieronima Bocha Visions of the Hereafter (cropped2)Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain
Hieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Hell The Fall of the Damned — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Hieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Hell The Fall of the DamnedHieronymus Bosch, reverse after Visions of the Hereafter The Way to Hell: The … · Public domain
Bosch laatste oordeel drieluik — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Bosch laatste oordeel drieluikHieronymus Bosch and workshop · Public domain
Bosch - Laatste Oordeel, 1500 (circa), 0000.GRO0208.I — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
Bosch – Laatste Oordeel, 1500 (circa), 0000.GRO0208.IHieronymus Bosch · Public domain
After Hieronymus Bosch - The Last Judgment 0000134708 — Hieronymus Bosch and circle
After Hieronymus Bosch – The Last Judgment 0000134708Workshop of Hieronymus Bosch · Public domain

Questions people ask

What is unusual about Bosch’s Hell?

He replaced the conventional diagram of the Last Judgment with a detailed, believable landscape in which composite demons punish each sin with everyday tools.

What is the Ascent of the Blessed?

One of four panels by Bosch in Venice, showing souls rising through a tunnel of light toward heaven.

Where is Bosch’s Last Judgment?

The largest surviving version is in the Paintings Gallery of the Academy of Fine Arts in Vienna. A smaller triptych is in the Groeningemuseum in Bruges.

Did Bosch paint a Last Judgment for Philip the Fair?

He was paid an advance for one in 1504, the only documented commission of his career. The painting described, about nine by eleven feet, has not survived or has not been identified.

Where did Bosch get his ideas about Hell?

From sermons on the punishment of each sin, from texts such as the Vision of Tundale, which was printed in his home town in 1484, from mystery plays and from the monsters in the margins of manuscripts.

What are the Visions of the Hereafter?

Four panels by Bosch in Venice showing the Earthly Paradise, the Ascent of the Blessed, the Fall of the Damned and the River to Hell. They were probably wings of a lost altarpiece.

Sources and further reading

  1. Bosch Research and Conservation Project — high-resolution images and technical studies
  2. Museo del Prado: El Bosco
  3. Het Noordbrabants Museum, ’s-Hertogenbosch
  4. Ilsink et al., Hieronymus Bosch, Painter and Draughtsman: Catalogue Raisonné (2016)
  5. Wikimedia Commons: Hieronymus Bosch — image files
  6. The Last Judgment (Bosch, Vienna) — overview
  7. Paintings Gallery of the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna |
  8. Ascent of the Blessed — the Venice panels
  9. Musea Brugge: Groeningemuseum |
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, alongside the site’s history, Lake Norman, law and Outer Space collections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.