The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle

Portrait of the German physicist Werner Heisenberg

Outer Space › Space, Time & Physics

Space, Time & Physics · The Quantum World

The Uncertainty Principle: Nature’s Fine Print

In 1927 a 25-year-old physicist showed that the more exactly nature fixes where a particle is, the less it fixes where the particle is going. The limit is built into the world, not into our tools.

By · · 12-minute read

Unknown author · CC BY-SA 3.0 de

In the spring of 1925 Werner Heisenberg, 23 years old and miserable with hay fever, retreated to Helgoland, a treeless island in the North Sea. There he worked out a new way to calculate the behavior of atoms that used only quantities an experiment could measure, such as the colors of light an atom gives off, and made no attempt to picture the electron’s path. It worked. Within a year Erwin Schrödinger had produced a rival version based on waves, the two were shown to be the same theory in different dress, and physicists had a working quantum mechanics.

What they did not have was agreement on what it meant. In February 1927, alone in Copenhagen while Niels Bohr was away skiing, Heisenberg found a consequence of the new mathematics that has carried his name ever since.

The island of Helgoland in the North Sea
Helgoland, where Heisenberg found the first form of quantum mechanics in June 1925.Louis-F. Stahl · CC BY-SA 3.0 de
Physicists at the 1927 Solvay Conference
Seven months after the uncertainty paper, at the Solvay Conference in Brussels. Heisenberg stands third from the right in the back row.Benjamin Couprie · Public domain

What the principle says

Some pairs of properties cannot both be sharp at the same time. The best-known pair is position and momentum (mass times velocity). Squeeze the range of places a particle might be found, and the range of momenta it might have widens in exact proportion. The product of the two spreads can never fall below a fixed amount set by Planck’s constant, a number so small that the effect vanishes for anything you can see.

6.6 × 10⁻³⁴Planck’s constant in joule-seconds, the scale of quantum fuzziness
1927Year of Heisenberg’s paper
25Heisenberg’s age
1932Heisenberg’s Nobel Prize

For a baseball the limit is absurdly far below anything measurable, many billions of times smaller than a proton. For an electron confined to an atom it is everything. Pin an electron within the width of an atom and its speed becomes uncertain by hundreds of kilometers per second.

It is not about clumsy measurement

Heisenberg first explained the idea with a thought experiment. To see an electron you must bounce light off it; light sharp enough to locate it carries a kick that changes its motion. That picture is easy to remember and it misleads, because it suggests the electron has an exact position and speed that we merely disturb.

The modern understanding is different and stranger. The uncertainty comes from the wave nature of matter. A pure musical note, one exact pitch, must last a long time; a sharp click, located exactly in time, is a jumble of many pitches. No instrument is at fault. A sound simply cannot be both a single pitch and a single instant. In quantum mechanics a particle’s momentum plays the part of pitch and its position the part of the instant. A particle with one exact momentum is a wave spread everywhere, and a particle at one exact place is a mix of all momenta. The property is not hidden. It is not there to be had.

Probability clouds of the electron in a hydrogen atom at different energies
An electron in an atom is not a tiny planet on a track. These are maps of where it is likely to be found. Confinement to so small a space is what gives it its energy.Umberto NURS · Public domain

The double-slit experiment above shows the same trade. Know which slit the particle used (position) and you lose the stripes (which depend on a well-defined momentum).

Why atoms do not collapse

Opposite charges attract, so why does the electron in a hydrogen atom not fall into the proton? The uncertainty principle is the answer. To sit on the nucleus the electron would have to be confined to a tiny space, and that would force its momentum, and so its energy of motion, to be enormous. The atom settles at the size where the pull inward and the quantum push outward balance. Every solid object owes its bulk to this.

For the same reason nothing can be perfectly still. Even at absolute zero, atoms keep a minimum jitter called zero-point energy. It is why liquid helium never freezes at ordinary pressure, however cold it gets.

Tunneling

Because a particle’s position is spread out, a little of its wave leaks through barriers that should be impassable, and now and then the particle turns up on the far side. This is quantum tunneling, and a good deal depends on it.

  1. The SunProtons in the Sun’s core do not move fast enough to overcome their electrical repulsion and fuse. They tunnel. Without tunneling the Sun would not shine.
  2. RadioactivityIn 1928 George Gamow explained alpha decay as a particle tunneling out of a nucleus.
  3. MicroscopesThe scanning tunneling microscope, built by Gerd Binnig and Heinrich Rohrer at IBM Zürich in 1981, images single atoms by measuring electrons tunneling across a gap. It won the 1986 Nobel Prize.
  4. MemoryFlash storage in phones and solid-state drives writes and erases data by tunneling electrons through an insulating layer.
The first scanning tunneling microscope, a small gold-colored instrument
The first scanning tunneling microscope, which turned a quantum leak into a way of seeing atoms.J Brew · CC BY-SA 2.0
The Sun in ultraviolet light
The Sun shines because protons tunnel through a barrier they could not climb.NASA/SDO (AIA) · Public domain

Einstein’s objection

Einstein helped start quantum theory and never accepted this part of it. If the theory gives only odds, he argued, it must be leaving something out. Writing to Max Born in December 1926, he said he was convinced that God “does not play dice.” At the Solvay conferences of 1927 and 1930 he brought Bohr one ingenious thought experiment after another meant to beat the uncertainty limit. Bohr found the flaw each time, once by using Einstein’s own general relativity against him.

Einstein’s last and best challenge, in 1935, did not attack the principle directly. It led somewhere no one expected: to entanglement.

Niels Bohr and Albert Einstein in conversation
Bohr and Einstein, friendly opponents for thirty years.Paul Ehrenfest Original uploader was Graf at de.wikipedia · Public domain
Albert Einstein in 1921
Einstein held that a complete theory should say what happens, not what probably happens.Ferdinand Schmutzer / Adam Cuerden · Public domain
Check yourself

What does the uncertainty principle limit?

The limit is a property of nature, not of measuring devices.

Why does the electron in an atom not fall into the nucleus?

Tighter confinement means larger momentum spread and more energy.

Questions people ask

What is the uncertainty principle in simple terms?

It says that certain pairs of properties, most famously a particle’s position and its momentum, cannot both have exact values at the same time. The more precisely one is defined, the less precisely the other is.

Is the uncertainty principle caused by measurement disturbing the particle?

No. That was an early way of explaining it. The limit follows from the wave nature of matter and holds whether or not anyone measures anything.

Does the uncertainty principle affect everyday objects?

In principle yes, but the effect is far too small to detect for anything much larger than a molecule.

What is quantum tunneling?

It is the passage of a particle through a barrier it does not have enough energy to cross classically. It is a consequence of the particle’s wave-like spread and is essential to nuclear fusion in the Sun.

Sources and further reading

  1. Heisenberg (1927), Zeitschrift für Physik 43 — the uncertainty paper
  2. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Uncertainty Principle
  3. Nobel Prize in Physics 1932 (Heisenberg)
  4. Nobel Prize in Physics 1986 (scanning tunneling microscope)
  5. The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. III, Ch. 2
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, where the Outer Space collection sits beside the site’s history, Lake Norman and law sections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.