The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Double-Slit Experiment

Four frames showing single electrons building up an interference pattern in the Hitachi double-slit experiment

Outer Space › Space, Time & Physics

Space, Time & Physics · The Quantum World

The Double-Slit Experiment: One Particle, Two Paths

Richard Feynman said this one experiment holds “the only mystery” of quantum mechanics. You can run it below.

By · · 12-minute read

Dr. Tonomura and Belsazar · CC BY-SA 3.0

Drop two pebbles into a still pond. The rings spread, overlap, and where crest meets crest the water heaps higher; where crest meets trough it lies flat. That crisscross of reinforcement and cancellation is called interference, and it is the signature of a wave. Bullets do not do it. Fire bullets through two gaps in a wall and you get two heaps of bullets behind the gaps and nothing more.

So here is a clean test for whether something is a wave or a particle: send it at a barrier with two narrow slits and look at what arrives on a screen behind. Two bands means particles. Many stripes means waves. The trouble that started modern physics is that light, electrons, atoms and even large molecules give both answers, and which one you get depends on what you choose to measure.

Young settles it, for a century

In the 1700s the argument about light was between Newton, who favored particles, and those who favored waves. In November 1803 the English physician Thomas Young described to the Royal Society how a thin beam of sunlight, split in two, produced bands of light and dark. Only waves could cancel each other to make the dark bands. With James Clerk Maxwell’s 1860s equations showing light to be an electromagnetic wave, the case seemed closed.

Thomas Young's drawing of two overlapping sets of waves producing an interference pattern
Thomas Young’s own sketch of two wave sources interfering, from his lectures.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
Engraved portrait of James Clerk Maxwell
James Clerk Maxwell showed in the 1860s that light is a wave of electric and magnetic fields.Gravure of engraving by Stodart based on photograph by Fergus. · CC0

The particle comes back

Then the particles returned. In 1900 Max Planck could explain the glow of hot objects only by assuming energy is given off in lumps, which he called quanta. In 1905 Einstein proposed that light itself travels as lumps, later named photons, and used the idea to explain why light knocks electrons out of metal the way it does. That work, not relativity, earned his 1921 Nobel Prize.

In 1924 a French doctoral student, Louis de Broglie, proposed the reverse: if waves of light can act like particles, particles of matter should act like waves. Three years later Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer at Bell Labs bounced electrons off a nickel crystal and found them diffracting exactly as waves would.

Portrait of Max Planck in 1933
Max Planck, who introduced the quantum in 1900 and never fully made peace with where it led.Unknown author · Public domain
Group photograph of physicists at the 1927 Solvay Conference in Brussels
The 1927 Solvay Conference in Brussels. Of the 29 people here, 17 held or would win Nobel Prizes; the debate between Einstein and Niels Bohr over what quantum theory means began in earnest at this meeting.Benjamin Couprie · Public domain

One at a time

The version that still unsettles people was done with electrons. Claus Jönsson built real double slits for electrons in Tübingen in 1961. In 1974 Pier Giorgio Merli, Gian Franco Missiroli and Giulio Pozzi in Bologna dimmed the beam until electrons crossed the apparatus singly. In 1989 Akira Tonomura’s group at Hitachi filmed the result with enough clarity to convince anyone.

Each electron lands as one dot at one place. The first few dozen dots look random. But keep going and stripes emerge, thousands of single arrivals sketching an interference pattern together, although each electron crossed alone with nothing to interfere with but itself.

Four panels showing an electron interference pattern building up from scattered single dots to clear stripes
Tonomura’s 1989 experiment. Electrons arrive one by one (first panel) and build stripes over time (last panel). Each dot is a particle; the pattern is a wave.Dr. Tonomura and Belsazar · CC BY-SA 3.0

The standard account goes like this. Between source and screen the electron is described by a wave function that passes through both slits and interferes. The wave does not say where the electron is. It gives the odds of where it will be found. At the screen one spot lights up, with the bright stripes more likely than the dark.

Looking changes the result

Now put a detector at the slits to learn which one each electron uses. It works: each electron is recorded at one slit or the other. And the stripes disappear. The screen shows two plain bands, as for bullets. Remove the detector and the stripes return.

Nothing mystical is needed to see why something must change. To learn the path, the detector has to interact with the electron, and it turns out that any record of the path left anywhere in the environment, whether or not a person reads it, is enough to erase the interference. Physicists call this decoherence. What remains strange is that the electron has no definite path when no record exists.

How big can a wave be?

If electrons do it, what about bigger things? In 1999 Anton Zeilinger’s group in Vienna sent buckyballs, soccer-ball-shaped molecules of 60 carbon atoms, through a grating and saw interference. By 2019 the Vienna group had done it with molecules of about 2,000 atoms. No upper limit has been found. The practical barrier is isolation: the larger the object, the faster the surrounding world records where it is.

Physicist Anton Zeilinger
Anton Zeilinger, whose Vienna group showed interference with large molecules; he shared the 2022 Nobel Prize for work on entanglement.Jaqueline Godany · CC BY 4.0
Richard Feynman's Los Alamos identification badge photograph
Richard Feynman as a young physicist at Los Alamos. He taught that the double slit contains the whole puzzle of quantum mechanics.Credit Line: Los Alamos National Laboratory, courtesy AIP Emilio Segrè Visual … · CC0
Grid of probability density plots for an electron in a hydrogen atom
The same wave behavior shapes atoms. These are probability clouds for the single electron in hydrogen at different energies.Umberto NURS · Public domain
Portrait of Niels Bohr around 1922
Niels Bohr argued that wave and particle are complementary pictures: each valid, never both at once in a single experiment.The American Institute of Physics credits the photo [1] to AB Lagrelius & West… · Public domain

What it means

Everyone agrees on the arithmetic. Quantum mechanics predicts the stripe spacing, the dot statistics and the effect of a detector to as many decimal places as anyone can measure. The disagreement is over what is happening when nobody looks. The Copenhagen view of Bohr and Heisenberg declines to say. The many-worlds view holds that both paths are taken in branching versions of reality. Pilot-wave theory keeps a real particle guided by a real wave. All three give the same predictions for this experiment, which is why the argument has lasted a hundred years. The next chapter takes it up with a cat.

Check yourself

What pattern do single electrons build up when no one checks which slit they use?

The stripes show each electron behaves as a wave passing through both slits.

What happens when a detector records which slit each electron passes?

Any which-path record destroys the interference.

Who first demonstrated interference of light, in the early 1800s?

Young reported it to the Royal Society in 1803.

Questions people ask

What does the double-slit experiment prove?

It shows that light and matter have both wave and particle properties. Individual particles arrive at single points, yet their arrival pattern is the interference pattern of a wave that passed through both slits.

Does a conscious observer cause the pattern to change?

No experiment shows that consciousness is required. Any physical interaction that records which slit the particle took, including a stray photon or air molecule, removes the interference.

Has the double-slit experiment been done with single particles?

Yes. Single-electron versions were done in Bologna in 1974 and at Hitachi in 1989, and single-photon, atom and large-molecule versions have followed.

What is wave-particle duality?

It is the finding that quantum objects such as photons and electrons show wave behavior (interference) in some experiments and particle behavior (single localized detections) in others.

Sources and further reading

  1. Young, "Experiments and Calculations Relative to Physical Optics" (1804) — Bakerian Lecture
  2. Tonomura et al., "Demonstration of single-electron buildup of an interference pattern," Am. J. Phys. (1989)
  3. Arndt et al., "Wave–particle duality of C60 molecules," Nature (1999)
  4. Fein et al., "Quantum superposition of molecules beyond 25 kDa," Nature Physics (2019)
  5. The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. III, Ch. 1 — free online
  6. Hitachi: Double-slit experiment
About the author. Christopher Adkins is an attorney at Adkins Law, PLLC in Huntersville, North Carolina, a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer and a former U.S. Army engineer officer. He writes and edits The Lake Norman Brief, where the Outer Space collection sits beside the site’s history, Lake Norman and law sections. Corrections are welcome through the site’s contact page.