The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

With the Old Breed

Eugene Sledge’s With the Old Breed follows one Marine company from Peleliu to Okinawa. Its most revealing moments are the ones a campaign map leaves out.

Book review

With the Old Breed

E. B. Sledge

Edition cover of With the Old Breed
With the Old Breed

Sledge arrives on Peleliu listening to men who know more than he does. By Okinawa he has become such a man, and the change carries little comfort.

With the Old Breed. Edition cover via Penguin Random House.

A young Marine from Alabama goes ashore on Peleliu as a replacement who still has things to learn from the veterans. By Okinawa he has become the man a newcomer might look to. The distance between those two people is the real subject of Eugene Sledge’s memoir. A piece of dry ground, a chance to wash, the sight of a familiar face carry extraordinary weight because he has shown exactly what it costs to lose them.

Sledge gives the same close attention to an act of kindness and to an American doing something shameful. That steadiness makes his account difficult to dismiss or to appropriate for a speech. Readers seeking a map of the Pacific campaign will want a companion history. For the narrower question of what happens to a conscientious person who must live among the dead and return to ordinary society, few books approach his precision.

What a man can see from ground level

A map can give you Peleliu in a glance. Find the island, the airfield, the high ground; in a minute you can see relationships that a young Marine on the ground might spend days trying to understand. Eugene Sledge makes the reader give that advantage back. The important unit of distance in his memoir is the stretch of exposed ground between a man and the place he needs to reach. He can know that stretch in exhausting detail and have only a dim idea of what it means to a general studying the island. The book asks you to live for a while with the discrepancy. Much of its honesty begins there.

Sledge came from Mobile, Alabama, and served with K Company, 3rd Battalion, 5th Marines. He fought on Peleliu and Okinawa. Read those two names slowly. To a historian they mark two campaigns separated by time and water. To the people of one company the second begins with an absence. Some of the men who might have explained things on Peleliu can no longer speak. Others now possess an authority they never sought, simply because they are still present when a frightened replacement arrives. Sledge has the literary sense to let us meet him first as that replacement. Much later, when we realize that he has become one of the men a newcomer would study, the promotion is a bleak one.

The education he actually received

The novice measures competence in small things. A man who keeps his head when a noise breaks overhead commands a respect that cannot be conferred by rank. So does a man who sees that somebody younger is coming apart and knows when a quiet word will do more than an order. Watch how few speeches the Marines Sledge most admires require. Their influence is visible in the behavior of other people. That gives his account of leadership an unusual precision. It is also a demanding standard for the reader. We have to learn enough about an ordinary day in the company to recognize when someone has made the day a little less terrible.

On Peleliu the ground itself starts to undo the vocabulary a civilian would bring to the story. A reader might come prepared to admire the men for taking an objective. Sledge first makes you understand why a person might care about water with an intensity that leaves no room for an objective at all. Heat, coral, exhaustion, the handling of the dead: each asks something specific of a body that still has to keep moving afterward. By the time a commander’s purpose comes back into view, the reader has some grasp of the extraordinary cost hidden in the neutral language of an advance.

Two islands, two kinds of memory

It would be easy for a second campaign to feel like a repetition in a less observant writer’s hands. Okinawa has weather of its own, above all the rain, and rain changes the meaning of nearly every ordinary action. Ground on which a Marine could stand becomes something he must fight to stand in. What has been buried can reappear. The distance between the living and the dead can cease to be a distance at all. Sledge understood that general words wear out quickly under these conditions. He goes back to surfaces, smells, weight, how long a task takes. Anyone can say that conditions deteriorated. It takes a particular witness to show what happened to the definition of a dry place.

The difference between the islands also exposes a weakness in the familiar idea of the hardened veteran. Experience gives Sledge better judgment about certain things. It gives him no corresponding immunity to grief, disgust, or the fear that another person may have reached the end of what he can bear. In some respects experience makes the next ordeal worse. The newcomer can still imagine that his fear belongs to his inexperience and will go away once he knows enough. The veteran knows exactly how much a person can learn while remaining afraid. Sledge never treats that discovery as a failure of character.

The incident that complicates the word souvenir

One of the hardest episodes to discuss takes only a moment to describe. Sledge is tempted to take gold teeth from a dead Japanese soldier. A corpsman discourages him. Pay attention to how the intervention works. A public accusation would require the young Marine either to defend himself or to accept humiliation in front of other men. The corpsman gives him a practical reason to desist. The small act of mercy in the scene extends in more than one direction. Someone stops an indignity to the dead, and someone also leaves a living man a way back from doing something he might have spent the rest of his life remembering.

Why put the temptation on the page at all? Sledge could have written a very fine indictment of cruelty using only things he saw other people do. It would have been an easier book to admire and an easier book to put away. By placing himself inside the moral danger, he makes it harder for readers to reserve their disgust for people unlike themselves. He also allows no comforting conclusion that an honest admission balances an account. The person whose body is at issue has no voice in the scene. The reader should feel that limit even while recognizing the courage it took to record the experience.

What survived the crossing home

Sledge kept observations tucked into his Bible. Years passed between the fighting and the appearance of the book in 1981. That interval matters as much as the wartime notes. A young man could record a name, a place, a smell he feared forgetting. The older writer had to decide how to give strangers enough context to understand why a name still hurt. A note made on the spot has the authority of proximity. The memoir has the additional burden of having lived with what the note means. Read the Auburn archive’s description of the surviving papers alongside the finished work and the neat division between an immediate account and a later recollection begins to look artificial. Explore Sledge’s papers at Auburn University.

An especially moving companion photograph shows him at a reunion in 1982. His old comrades have presented him with a plaque, and beside him is a company casualty list. The book has made its way back to some of the people whose judgment could reasonably have frightened its author most. The men who could hand him a plaque stand in a different relation to the story from the men whose names only a list could bring to that gathering. It is worth opening the photograph after you finish the memoir and sitting for a minute with the difference. See the reunion portrait and its archival caption.

Survivors of the cruiser USS Indianapolis lying in cots in a field hospital on Peleliu in August 1945
Peleliu after the fightingIn August 1945 the island where Sledge had fought the previous year held recovering survivors of USS Indianapolis. U.S. Navy photograph, National Archives.

Read alongside

How does a witness decide which small moment can stand for a much larger catastrophe?

The Last of the Old BreedScott Davis

What does a Marine remember when the people who knew him at nineteen have almost all gone? Scott Davis builds an oral history of the Pacific war around interviews with surviving World War II Marines.

HiroshimaJohn Hersey

John Hersey arranges his account of the atomic bombing around six people who were in Hiroshima on August 6, 1945. Before the blast they have appointments, work and people depending on them.

Reading group guide

Which act of ordinary decency requires more effort on Okinawa than it would have at home?

Find this book and edition

With the Old Breed · E. B. Sledge · War & Military History
Cover edition ISBN 9780891411192 · Look for this edition in a library