Under the Banner of Heaven
Jon Krakauer

Krakauer begins with two murders in Utah. As the inquiry widens, keep the perpetrators’ beliefs, the histories he recounts and the lives of other believers distinct.
Edition cover from Penguin Random House.Jon Krakauer begins with the murders of Brenda Lafferty and her infant daughter Erica in Utah. Ron and Dan Lafferty claimed a divine sanction for their actions. Taking that claim seriously as evidence of how they understood themselves, Krakauer pursues the history of the Mormon fundamentalist milieu in which they moved, including its break with the mainstream Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
The historical chapters give the crime a wider context and raise one of the book's most uncomfortable questions. How do members of a community challenge someone who claims an instruction comes directly from God? The risk in carrying a thread across generations is that a genealogy of ideas can start to sound like an inevitable route to violence. Readers should keep the brothers' choices and the lives of the much larger community distinct. The book earns sustained attention for placing religious authority alongside domestic power, where the consequences of obedience fall upon people with the least opportunity to refuse.

Carol M. Highsmith / Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.
Open the full imageRead alongside
Pay attention to where a writer moves between describing belief from the outside and explaining it from within.
Joseph Smith: Rough Stone RollingRichard Lyman BushmanA biographer of Joseph Smith faces an unusual problem of grammar. Saying that Smith saw something, said he saw something, or believed he saw something tells the reader a great deal about the biographer before the sentence has even ended.
Islam: A Short HistoryKaren ArmstrongKaren Armstrong gives a small book a daunting job. She follows the community formed around Muhammad through disputes over succession, the rise of empires, the development of religious traditions, and encounters with modern political power.
Reading group guide
Where does Krakauer distinguish the beliefs of a whole religious community from the choices of particular perpetrators?
Find this book and edition
Under the Banner of Heaven · Jon Krakauer · Crime & Investigation
Cover edition ISBN 9781400032808 · Look for this edition in a library