The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling

Book review

Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling

Richard Lyman Bushman

Edition cover of Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling
Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling

Bushman writes about the origins of a faith whose participants and critics use different words for the same event. How the biographer attributes a claim matters sentence by sentence.

Cover of Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling. Image from Penguin Random House.

A biographer of Joseph Smith faces an unusual problem of grammar. Saying that Smith saw something, said he saw something, or believed he saw something tells the reader a great deal about the biographer before the sentence has even ended. Bushman, a historian and a Latter-day Saint, makes his position visible and takes Smith's religious world seriously enough to explain its appeal. The resulting portrait can accommodate a translator of scripture, a city builder, a husband, and a man exercising extraordinary authority over other people's lives.

The book is especially strong on the speed at which revelation could become an institutional fact. People moved, built, married, and accepted obligations in response. Bushman's sympathy can leave a skeptical reader wanting more space for people who interpreted those events differently, particularly around plural marriage. But sympathy also equips him to explain why intelligent contemporaries stayed. The biography rewards readers willing to notice where an author's convictions enable a question and where the same convictions narrow the answer.

Two hands meet in prayer, drawn with dark strokes and white highlights on blue prepared paper in Dürer’s Praying Hands of 1508.
From the visual archivePraying HandsDürer prepared this drawing for a figure in an altarpiece. Compare the evidence a devotional image supplies about religious practice with the quite different evidence a biographer needs about an individual revelation.

Albrecht Dürer, 1508. Albertina, Vienna. Public-domain artwork.

Explore the visual source

Read alongside

Pay attention to where a writer moves between describing belief from the outside and explaining it from within.

Islam: A Short HistoryKaren Armstrong

Karen Armstrong gives a small book a daunting job. She follows the community formed around Muhammad through disputes over succession, the rise of empires, the development of religious traditions, and encounters with modern political power.

The Jesus DynastyJames D. Tabor

James Tabor asks what early Christianity looks like if the reader follows Jesus's family, especially his brother James, through the decades around the crucifixion. The shift of emphasis is immediately productive.

Reading group guide

How does Bushman handle an event that believers and skeptics can describe together yet interpret differently?

Find this book and edition

Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling · Richard Lyman Bushman · Biography & Memoir
Cover edition ISBN 9781400077533 · Look for this edition in a library