Their Eyes Were Watching God
Zora Neale Hurston
Janie Crawford returns to Eatonville knowing that her neighbors have already supplied an explanation for where she has been. She tells her story to Pheoby instead. That choice of listener changes the whole novel. Through marriages, work and travel, Janie keeps encountering people with strong ideas about what a woman's life ought to signify. Telling one person what happened, in the language she chooses, becomes an achievement as consequential as any event she recounts.

Hurston moves easily between the teasing invention of porch conversation and a narration capable of startling lyrical reach. The voices carry particular social knowledge, including how a joke can establish a person's standing and how the same pleasure can become an instrument of exclusion. Readers who need a few pages to hear the dialogue can try reading a passage aloud. The reward is hearing how much distinct personality survives inside collective speech. The great storm eventually changes the scale of the story without drowning out the painfully individual choices people still have to make.
Hurston gives the porch audience and the private listener different powers. Janie has an answer to the people who watched her come home, yet she also has the freedom to decide who deserves to hear it.

Jerzy Strzelecki. CC BY 3.0.
Explore the visual sourceRead alongside
Listen for the shift between an individual voice and the community that claims to speak for it.
The Time of CherriesMontserrat Roig
Natàlia Miralpeix returns to Barcelona after twelve years abroad.
JazzToni Morrison
Somebody who sounds as if they know the whole neighborhood tells us almost at once what Joe Trace did to Dorcas and how Violet, his wife, behaved afterward.
Reading group guide
How does Janie’s choice of Pheoby as a listener change what it means for her to tell the story?
Find this book and edition
Their Eyes Were Watching God · Zora Neale Hurston · Fiction & Classics
Cover edition ISBN 9780063068537 · Look for this edition in a library