The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Road

In Cormac McCarthy’s The Road, a can of soda and an ill-suited shopping cart reveal what a father can still teach his son, and what the boy learns to question.

Book review

The Road

Cormac McCarthy

Edition cover of The Road
The RoadEdition cover via Penguin Random House. ISBN 9780307387899.

A father has a shopping cart, a pistol, a few supplies and a boy who still asks what they can do for strangers. They move through the ash of a ruined country toward the coast. McCarthy supplies little explanation for the catastrophe. What matters in the present is whether a house has anything left to eat, whether its occupants are still nearby and what a child might learn from the way his father answers a knock or passes a traveler.

The boy's questions give the novel a second moral intelligence. The father keeps calculating the risks of compassion. The child notices the cost of finding a reason to withhold it every time. Some of their exchanges approach the simplicity of a fable, a tone that will either focus a reader's attention or occasionally strain belief. Against it McCarthy sets exact, grubby physical work. The effort it takes to keep somebody warm grounds the book's largest claims about love in a sequence of small and never permanently completed tasks.

A can with a history

A father finds a can of Coca-Cola and gives it to his son. The boy has never known the ordinary pleasure that a machine in a store once sold to anybody with change in a pocket. The father can remember that ordinary world. For a moment he has found an object capable of crossing the difference between their childhoods. The scene in The Road could easily have become a little advertisement for the things a lost civilization manufactured. Watch what the boy does with the drink. He is concerned about whether his father will have some too. The boy has learned nothing about brands, almost nothing about the world that filled the can, and a considerable amount about sharing from the person who opened it.

That particular disagreement about who gets a swallow is closer to the heart of Cormac McCarthy’s novel than the nature of the catastrophe. The book offers little help to readers intent on diagnosing what happened to the earth. Its curiosity runs in another direction. What is the smallest piece of a civilization that one person could carry into the future? A recipe would require ingredients. A description of a bird would require a listener who could imagine something alive in the branches. A parent looking at a hungry child can still make a decision about who eats first. The danger, as the book very clearly understands, is that a child taught to behave generously may one day try to be generous to somebody who will do him harm.

The cart has the wrong wheels

Spend a moment thinking about the shopping cart. It was designed to move along a smooth floor while somebody selected more than they could easily carry. Its shape preserves a whole arrangement of surfaces, buildings, goods, and expectations that no longer exists. The father pushes it down a ruined road anyway. It permits him to move more supplies than he could carry on his back. It can also make noise, get caught, or force him to choose between the supplies and the ability to move quickly. McCarthy makes the practical problem clear before inviting the reader to see a symbol. That order accounts for much of the force of the novel. You can have an opinion about what the cart means after you have had some reason to care whether it rolls.

Scale up from the cart to one of the abandoned houses. A house once offered evidence that a person with keys and a right to remain could expect something like privacy. What can its exterior tell a traveler now? It may conceal food, occupants, danger, or nothing at all. Experience helps the father read the signs, and the reader has strong reasons to wish he reads them correctly. Yet the meaning of hospitality is also at stake each time the pair approach a door. The question of what could be inside gradually becomes inseparable from a second one. What sort of people will these two have to become in order to keep opening doors?

The boy hears an answer twice

Conversations between father and son are brief enough that a reader may think they have finished well before they actually have. The boy asks a question. The father supplies the answer he believes the moment requires. Often a little later, perhaps under conditions that make the answer inconvenient, the boy acts as if his father meant what he said. Parents will recognize the predicament. A rule explained in the safety of one situation returns from a child’s mouth in another, and the adult discovers whether it was a rule or an expedient. The experience is unsettling even in a world where the consequences of consistency are comparatively small.

McCarthy gives the boy a powerful intelligence here. To call him a symbol of hope misses how difficult he can be for his father to answer. He remembers who needs help. He notices when a reassuring explanation fits badly with the thing he has just seen. In a setting stripped of schools, courts, congregations, and other adults who might dispute an account, he becomes the person to whom his father must explain himself. The son’s moral education has an unforeseen complication. Once he can recognize an injustice, he can recognize one committed by the person who taught him the word.

Two ways of telling time

The father has memories of a world the boy never occupied in quite the same way. An old place can therefore ask very different things of the two people who enter it. The father sees something missing from a room. The boy sees the room. Any parent can show a child the street where they grew up and discover how little of what matters most is currently visible. In this novel there is the additional grief of knowing that many of the ordinary comparisons by which people explain a memory have also vanished. To explain one absent thing, the father must borrow another absent thing. McCarthy’s spare conversation feels appropriate to a world in which a surprising number of everyday words have lost their examples.

The narration occasionally breaks into a much more elaborate language. Some readers find these passages the novel’s finest achievement. Others hear a voice lifted too far above a man who mostly needs to find dry bedding. Both responses make sense. Notice when the heightened language occurs. It can give a remembered form of life a precision no longer available to the eye. It can also make ruin seem almost luxurious for a paragraph. The tension is productive so long as the reader can still feel the weight and cold of the world the people inhabit. When admiration for a sentence starts to eclipse them, the father and son usually have a very short exchange that restores the proper order of concern.

What do they expect of the coast?

A coastline supplies a direction even when a traveler has little evidence that conditions will be better there. That is one of the practical advantages of a destination. It settles the question of which way to turn on a morning when the larger question of why to continue is too much to ask. The ocean also carries a stock of images a modern reader may supply automatically: open space after confinement, the edge of known land, the possibility of another shore. McCarthy can make use of those expectations with very little description. A child meeting the sea for the first time has none of our literary obligations to it. His response is worth taking on its own terms.

This is a novel to discuss through a single decision rather than an argument about whether its vision is hopeful. Choose an occasion on which a stranger needs something, and make the best case you can for the father’s response using only what he knows at that moment. Then make the boy’s case using only what he has learned from his father. The disturbing thing is how much evidence they share. The affection between them cannot settle every dispute the world brings to their feet. It has, however, given them reasons to dispute those things with one another. In a landscape that has lost most of the sounds of ordinary life, the possibility of hearing an objection from someone who loves you begins to sound like a considerable inheritance.

McCarthy lets the boy apply his father’s moral lessons to cases the father would rather exempt. A child capable of learning what goodness means has also acquired the capacity to disagree with his teacher.

Dante in the Dark Wood: A tiny traveler stands beneath towering trunks and dense darkness.
From the visual archiveDante in the Dark WoodThe dark wood in Doré’s illustration almost swallows its traveler. McCarthy builds a much more intimate relation between a threatening landscape and the two people crossing it together.

After Gustave Doré. Wood engraving. Public-domain artwork.

Explore the visual source

Read alongside

Look closely at the small exchanges between people under extreme pressure, and at what the writer chooses to leave unexplained.

Reading group guide

Which ordinary object teaches the boy something about a world he has never known?

Find this book and edition

The Road · Cormac McCarthy · Science Fiction & Dystopia
Cover edition ISBN 9780307387899 · Look for this edition in a library

More by Cormac McCarthy (2)