The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

And Then There Were None

Agatha Christie strands ten strangers on Soldier Island. This spoiler-free review follows the invitations, the recorded accusation, and the shaky evidence the guests build against one another.

Book review

And Then There Were None

Agatha Christie

Edition cover of And Then There Were None
And Then There Were NoneAnd Then There Were None by Agatha Christie. Edition cover from Bookshop.org.

Ten strangers arrive at a house on an island. A recorded voice accuses each of causing a death that escaped ordinary justice. Christie has already closed one avenue of escape before she removes the boat. Nobody can establish innocence simply by pointing to a clean legal record. The guests have to decide whom to trust on evidence that requires them to explain things they have spent years concealing.

A counting rhyme supplies a timetable the reader can follow even as the guests lose their bearings. Its childish regularity is particularly cruel. Knowing the pattern brings almost no advantage to the people caught in it. Christie trades the leisurely pleasures of Poirot interviewing a roomful of suspects for the mounting difficulty of assembling a roomful at all. Some of her characters are drawn with the speed and flatness of playing cards. In this book that economy earns its keep. A change of seat at dinner or an empty place at breakfast can carry the force of an entire chapter in a more expansive novel.

Ten people read their invitations

The first act of trust in And Then There Were None happens on the mainland. A person reads an invitation and decides that the proposed visit sounds sufficiently plausible to attend. A holiday, perhaps; a paying position; an arrangement made by someone who knows somebody. Agatha Christie gets a surprising amount of character into the space between receiving a letter and boarding a train. Each traveler can supply whatever the invitation has left out. It is the first occasion on which a group of intelligent adults will help somebody else deceive them by doing perfectly sensible things. The distinction is important. A mystery built largely on stupidity begins to feel like an argument with its author. This one can make a reader distinctly uneasy about the habits that usually get us safely through the day.

Soldier Island lies off the Devon coast, near enough to imagine the lives going on over there, far enough for a missed boat to matter. Christie gives the guests a house thoroughly equipped for company and omits the person company has come to see. The absence of a host is an exquisite little social embarrassment before it becomes a threat. The guests still know, approximately, what they are supposed to do. There are rooms to occupy, meals to sit down to, strangers to place by profession or manner. Every minute spent doing these things is a minute in which nobody quite asks the other nine whether the arrangement makes any sense.

The accusation is only a voice

After dinner a recorded voice accuses the people present of responsibility for deaths. Consider how much would be different if a human accuser had stood in the doorway. Somebody could challenge a particular allegation, demand an explanation, threaten the speaker, or simply watch the speaker’s face for uncertainty. A recording has already finished with the people who are just beginning to hear it. The listeners are left in possession of one another’s reactions and almost no way to test the authority that provoked them. If you reread this chapter, listen for the moment when an expression of shock begins to be treated as information about guilt.

The accusations also create a second mystery whose answer matters even if you solve the first. What does a person owe somebody who died in circumstances the law has missed, misunderstood, or could never properly reach? A bare statement of responsibility can conceal crucial distinctions between an intentional act, a choice made under pressure, and a moment of self-serving indifference. The voice provides none of the procedures by which those distinctions might be explored. Yet the very precision of the accusations makes the people hearing them sound individually known. That combination gives the novel a moral chill independent of the growing body count.

Vera listens to the water

Watch Vera Claythorne in the stretches when nobody is questioning her. An imaginative person can be excellent at anticipating danger and just as good at furnishing fear with fresh material. An ordinary sound reaches one listener as background and another as a private reminder. Christie moves close enough to Vera for a reader to feel that difference without handing over the comfortable assurance that proximity and innocence are the same thing. It is possible to know what a person fears at one moment and still know remarkably little about what she did at another. Detective fiction often encourages us to believe that close access will settle the matter. Christie makes the access itself part of the puzzle.

Her treatment of professional authority is equally sharp. A doctor can pronounce on a body. A judge knows how to conduct a discussion. A former police officer has a useful idea of what a search should look like. In a crisis it is reasonable to turn to each for help. It is much less reasonable to let a limited competence become a certificate of general trustworthiness. The guests have trouble observing that boundary. So do most readers. While following an early meeting, try keeping track of who has actually established a fact and who has merely spoken last. It is a surprisingly effective way to discover whom you instinctively believe.

Counting changes the meaning of a room

A nursery rhyme supplies an order; small figures on the table give the order a physical presence. Both devices are almost aggressively simple. You can remember the existence of a missing object even when you cannot remember the exact order of two people’s movements in a corridor. Once the pattern is recognized, the characters have an excellent reason to spend time trying to anticipate its next step. That use of their intelligence turns out to be another diversion of attention. While a person is asking how a line of verse might come true, they may forget to ask who told them that verse was the right way to think about the room.

Ten is also a very different number from three. At dinner, a person can exchange a glance and escape the notice of several others. Every departure creates new conditions for the people left. The same dining table first offers social cover and eventually exposes almost everyone at it. The house can seem to contract while keeping exactly the same dimensions. Christie achieves the effect with cuts between viewpoints, short conversations, and the changing number of people available to contradict what somebody says. A more elaborate description of the building would contribute less to the book’s atmosphere than a single empty chair.

What the mechanism costs

The design leaves limited room for certain kinds of curiosity. Some of the guests come into focus more as a social type and a past offense than as people with histories extending beyond those facts. The people whose deaths brought the guests together have still less room. You can reasonably finish the book wanting a chapter in which one of those people gets to exist independently of what a guest remembers or denies. Such a chapter would deepen the moral field. It would also take us off the island, give us another measure of what is true, and loosen the extraordinary pressure Christie has created by restricting the company. The omission has an artistic purpose and a human cost.

For a second reading, let yourself stop hunting the culprit and keep a modest ledger instead. Give one column to things you see happen, one to statements by the guests, and one to statements that other people repeat until they sound like things everybody saw. Where does a piece of evidence move between columns without anyone noticing? That movement is the novel’s most durable trick. Long after a particular solution is known, it is still possible to be surprised by the spectacle of ten frightened people trying to establish a shared account of reality, and by the very small number of unexamined assumptions on which such an account can rest.

The invitation letters are an early lesson in inference. Each guest supplies missing context from familiar social arrangements, helping to authenticate a message whose author has yet to be established.

Ocracoke Inlet from the air in 1966, the passage emigrant ships used to reach the sounds.
From the visual archiveOcracoke Inlet from the air, 1966An inlet seen from above makes both a boundary and a route visible. Christie’s island mystery depends on the difference between knowing that the mainland exists and being able to reach it.

Cape Hatteras National Seashore · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Open the full image

Read alongside

How fairly can a mystery hide its answer in plain sight? Watch the order in which each detective lets you see the evidence.

The Honjin Murders
Seishi Yokomizo

A bride and groom are killed at a rural Japanese estate, snow complicates the question of how anyone got away, and the sound of a koto adds a detail so strange it almost demands an explanation of its own.

Death on the Nile
Agatha Christie

Before anybody dies, Hercule Poirot can see disaster coming.

Reading group guide

Before the next accusation, separate what you witnessed from what another guest told you. How many suspicions survive?

Find this book and edition

And Then There Were None · Agatha Christie · Mystery & Thrillers
Cover edition ISBN 9780062073488 · Look for this edition in a library

More by Agatha Christie (1)