The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Treaties and Indian Law: From Fort Pitt to McGirt

Treaties and Indian Law

Tribal nations are governments older than the United States. Two and a half centuries of treaties, statutes and court decisions define, and often confuse, what that means.

By · Updated November 15, 2026 · 12 min read

Photo: Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
A lawyer’s guide

Three sovereigns

American law recognizes three kinds of sovereign governments: the United States, the states and the tribes. A tribal nation’s authority does not come from Washington. It is inherent, the continuing power of a people that governed itself before the Constitution was written, and it survives except where a treaty or an act of Congress has taken part of it away. That one idea explains most of what seems odd about Indian law: why a tribe can run a court, tax a business or operate a casino that state law would forbid, and why a treaty signed in 1855 can decide a fishing case in 2025.

The Constitution mentions Indians three times. The Commerce Clause gives Congress power to regulate commerce “with the Indian Tribes”; the apportionment clauses twice exclude “Indians not taxed.” From the Commerce Clause and the treaty power the Supreme Court has built a doctrine with three legs: tribes are sovereign; Congress has broad (“plenary”) power over them; and the United States owes them a trust responsibility, a duty of good faith that arises from the treaties and from the dependence the government itself created.

This chapter is general history and information, not legal advice. Indian law is a specialty; anyone with a real question about it should consult a lawyer who practices in the field.

374treaties ratified by the Senate, 1778–1871
575federally recognized tribes
56 millionacres held in trust
about 400tribal court systems
1778–1871

The treaty era

General William T. Sherman and the Indian Peace Commission in council with Lakota and Arapaho leaders at Fort Laramie, Wyoming, 1868.
General William T. Sherman and the Indian Peace Commission in council with Lakota and Arapaho leaders at Fort Laramie, Wyoming, 1868.Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

European powers dealt with Native nations by treaty because they had to: the nations were militarily strong and held the land. The United States inherited the practice. Its first Indian treaty was signed with the Lenape (Delaware) at Fort Pitt on September 17, 1778, and even contemplated a fourteenth state of Native nations with a seat in Congress. Under the Constitution, treaties with tribes were negotiated by the President’s commissioners and ratified by two thirds of the Senate, exactly like treaties with France or Spain, and Article VI makes them “the supreme Law of the Land.”

The Trade and Intercourse Act of 1790, still in force in amended form, forbade anyone but the federal government from buying Indian land. States, especially New York and Massachusetts, ignored it, and those unlawful purchases became the basis of eastern land claims two centuries later.

In 1871 the House of Representatives, resentful of its exclusion from Indian policy, attached a rider to an appropriations bill: no tribe would henceforth be recognized as an independent nation “with whom the United States may contract by treaty.” The same sentence preserved every treaty already made. Agreements continued by statute and executive order, and the 374 ratified treaties remain law.

Peace commissioners in council with the Arapaho and Cheyenne
Peace commissioners in council with the Arapaho and CheyenneAlexander Gardner, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Wampum belts recorded agreements before paper did
Wampum belts recorded agreements before paper didNosferattus, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
Penn’s treaty with the Lenape, as imagined by Benjamin West
Penn’s treaty with the Lenape, as imagined by Benjamin WestBenjamin West, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Treaty of Canandaigua marker, New York
Treaty of Canandaigua marker, New YorkDanielPenfield, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
A map drawn to the Royal Proclamation of 1763
A map drawn to the Royal Proclamation of 1763Carver, Jonathan; Robert Sayer And John Bennett (Firm), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
1823–1832

The Marshall Trilogy

Chief Justice John Marshall, who wrote the three opinions on which federal Indian law still rests.
Chief Justice John Marshall, who wrote the three opinions on which federal Indian law still rests.Asher Brown Durand / After Henry Inman, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Three opinions by Chief Justice John Marshall set the terms. In Johnson v. M’Intosh (1823), a dispute between two white claimants, he held that European “discovery” gave the discovering nation, and its successor the United States, the exclusive right to acquire Indian land; the tribes kept a right of occupancy but could sell only to the federal government.

When Georgia extended its laws over the Cherokee Nation, the Cherokee sued in the Supreme Court as a foreign state. In Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831) Marshall held that they were not one: tribes were “domestic dependent nations.” The next year a better vehicle arrived. Georgia had imprisoned the missionary Samuel Worcester for living in Cherokee country without a state license. In Worcester v. Georgia (1832) the Court freed him and declared the Cherokee Nation “a distinct community, occupying its own territory, with boundaries accurately described, in which the laws of Georgia can have no force.”

Georgia defied the ruling and President Jackson did nothing to enforce it. (The line “John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it” was first printed thirty years later and is probably apocryphal, though it describes his conduct fairly.) Worcester nonetheless remains the foundation of tribal sovereignty, cited by the Court as recently as 2020.

1830–1850

Removal

President Andrew Jackson, who made the removal of the eastern nations the first priority of his administration.
President Andrew Jackson, who made the removal of the eastern nations the first priority of his administration.Ralph Eleaser Whiteside Earl, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Indian Removal Act of May 28, 1830, passed the House by 102 votes to 97. It authorized the President to exchange land west of the Mississippi for tribal lands in the East. On paper the exchanges were voluntary. In practice federal commissioners signed treaties with whatever faction would sign, and the army carried them out. Between 1830 and 1850 about 100,000 people were moved west from the South and the Old Northwest, and many thousands died on the way: Choctaw, Muscogee, Chickasaw, Cherokee and Seminole, and from the north the Potawatomi, Shawnee, Lenape, Miami, Sauk and others.

The Cherokee case is the best documented. The Treaty of New Echota (1835) was signed by about twenty men who held no office; the elected government, with a petition bearing nearly 16,000 signatures, protested to the Senate, which ratified the treaty by a single vote. See the Southeast and Native North Carolina.

1871–1934

Reservations, allotment and assimilation

Tom Torlino, a Navajo student, as he arrived at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in 1882 and three years later. The school used such pairs of pictures to advertise its work.
Tom Torlino, a Navajo student, as he arrived at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in 1882 and three years later. The school used such pairs of pictures to advertise its work.John N. Choate (sometimes credited as J. N. Choate), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

With the tribes confined to reservations, policy turned to ending them as peoples. The method was the General Allotment Act of 1887, sponsored by Senator Henry Dawes. Reservations held in common were surveyed and divided: 160 acres to each family head, 80 to each single adult. What was left over was declared “surplus” and opened to homesteaders. After twenty-five years, or sooner if an agent judged the owner “competent,” the allotment became taxable and saleable, and most were soon lost. Tribal land fell from 138 million acres in 1887 to 48 million in 1934. Many reservations became checkerboards of Indian and non-Indian parcels, which is the source of the jurisdictional tangles courts still struggle with.

The same decades brought the boarding schools. The first off-reservation school opened at Carlisle, Pennsylvania, in 1879 under Captain Richard Henry Pratt, whose motto was “Kill the Indian in him, and save the man.” Children were taken hundreds of miles from home, forbidden their languages, and put to work. A 2022–24 Interior Department investigation identified 417 federal boarding schools and confirmed the deaths of at least 973 children in them.

Congress made all Indians born in the United States citizens in 1924, partly in recognition of the 12,000 who had served in the First World War. Several states, among them Arizona and New Mexico, kept them from voting until 1948 or later.

Tribal land base (million acres)

1887138
190078
193448

Source: U.S. Department of the Interior; Felix Cohen’s Handbook of Federal Indian Law.

Senator Henry L. Dawes of Massachusetts
Senator Henry L. Dawes of MassachusettsMathew Brady, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Students at Carlisle, 1879
Students at Carlisle, 1879Bonta & Curtiss, Syracuse, NY, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Coolidge with Osage leaders, 1925
Coolidge with Osage leaders, 1925National Photo Company Collection, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Signing of the Indian Citizenship Act, 1924
Signing of the Indian Citizenship Act, 1924National Photo Company Collection, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
1934–today

Reorganization, termination, self-determination

John Collier, Commissioner of Indian Affairs from 1933 to 1945 and architect of the Indian Reorganization Act.
John Collier, Commissioner of Indian Affairs from 1933 to 1945 and architect of the Indian Reorganization Act.Harris & Ewing, photographer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 stopped allotment, allowed the government to take land back into trust, and invited tribes to adopt written constitutions. Many did, though the model governments it offered often fit poorly with older ways of governing.

After the Second World War the pendulum swung back. Under termination, announced in House Concurrent Resolution 108 (1953), Congress ended federal recognition of more than a hundred tribes, among them the Menominee, the Klamath and, in 1959, the Catawba. Public Law 280 (1953) handed criminal and some civil jurisdiction on reservations to six states without tribal consent. A relocation program moved tens of thousands of people from reservations to cities.

Termination was a disaster and was abandoned. In a 1970 message to Congress, President Nixon called for “self-determination without termination.” The Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 let tribes contract to run the federal programs that serve them, and it has been the basis of policy ever since. Around it stand the Indian Civil Rights Act (1968), the Indian Child Welfare Act (1978), the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (1988), the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (1990), and the provisions of the Violence Against Women Act (2013 and 2022) that restored tribal criminal jurisdiction over certain crimes by non-Indians.

For a North Carolina practitioner, the statute most likely to come up is the Indian Child Welfare Act. In any custody proceeding involving the foster care placement or adoption of a child who is a member of a tribe, or eligible for membership, the tribe has a right to notice and to intervene, and placement preferences favor the child’s family and tribe. The Supreme Court upheld the Act in Haaland v. Brackeen (2023).

Alcatraz, occupied by Indians of All Tribes, 1969–71
Alcatraz, occupied by Indians of All Tribes, 1969–71Bonnie Byler, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Wounded Knee, 1973
Wounded Knee, 1973The Alliance Times-Herald, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Deb Haaland, Secretary of the Interior 2021–25
Deb Haaland, Secretary of the Interior 2021–25Department of the Interior, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
The Supreme Court of the United States
The Supreme Court of the United StatesMathieu Landretti, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
National Museum of the American Indian
National Museum of the American IndianO Palsson, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Landmark cases

Seventeen decisions to know

CaseYearWhat it held
Johnson v. M’Intosh1823Tribes hold a right of occupancy; only the United States can buy Indian land. The “doctrine of discovery” enters American law.
Cherokee Nation v. Georgia1831Tribes are “domestic dependent nations,” neither foreign states nor mere subjects; their relation to the United States “resembles that of a ward to his guardian.”
Worcester v. Georgia1832Tribes are “distinct, independent political communities”; state law has no force in Indian country.
Ex parte Crow Dog1883Federal courts have no jurisdiction over a crime by one Indian against another on a reservation. Congress answers with the Major Crimes Act (1885).
Lone Wolf v. Hitchcock1903Congress has “plenary power” over Indian affairs and may break a treaty.
Winters v. United States1908Creating a reservation implicitly reserves enough water to fulfill its purpose.
Williams v. Lee1959States may not infringe “the right of reservation Indians to make their own laws and be ruled by them.”
Morton v. Mancari1974Indian preference in federal hiring is a political classification, not a racial one.
Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe1978Tribes lack criminal jurisdiction over non-Indians unless Congress says otherwise.
Santa Clara Pueblo v. Martinez1978Tribes are immune from suit in federal court under the Indian Civil Rights Act; membership is the tribe’s own business.
United States v. Sioux Nation1980The 1877 taking of the Black Hills required just compensation.
Montana v. United States1981Tribes generally lack civil authority over non-members on non-Indian fee land, with two exceptions.
California v. Cabazon Band1987States that permit gambling cannot bar it on reservations. Congress responds with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (1988).
McGirt v. Oklahoma2020A reservation persists until Congress clearly ends it; the Muscogee reservation still exists.
Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta2022States share jurisdiction with the United States over crimes by non-Indians against Indians in Indian country.
Haaland v. Brackeen2023The Indian Child Welfare Act is within Congress’s power and is upheld, 7–2.
Arizona v. Navajo Nation2023The 1868 treaty does not oblige the United States to take affirmative steps to secure water for the Navajo.
Today we are asked whether the land these treaties promised remains an Indian reservation for purposes of federal criminal law. Because Congress has not said otherwise, we hold the government to its word.Justice Neil Gorsuch, McGirt v. Oklahoma, 591 U.S. ___ (2020)
North of the border

Canada: Crown, treaties and section 35

Canadian law starts from the Royal Proclamation of 1763, issued by George III at the end of the French and Indian War, which reserved the lands west of the Appalachians to the Indians and provided that they could be acquired only by the Crown, in public council. From it grew the Upper Canada treaties, the Robinson treaties of 1850 and the eleven numbered treaties of 1871–1921. Most of British Columbia, Quebec, the Atlantic provinces and the North were never ceded by treaty at all.

The Indian Act of 1876 put First Nations under close federal control; it defined who was an “Indian,” imposed elected band councils, and at various times banned ceremonies, required passes to leave the reserve and forbade hiring lawyers to press land claims. It is still in force, much amended.

Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, “recognized and affirmed” existing Aboriginal and treaty rights. The Supreme Court of Canada has since held that Aboriginal title exists (Calder, 1973), that oral history is evidence of it (Delgamuukw, 1997), that the Crown must consult before acting on claimed lands (Haida Nation, 2004), and that title can be declared over specific territory (Tsilhqot’in, 2014). Since 1975 some twenty-six modern treaties have been concluded, covering more than 40 percent of Canada’s land mass.

Check yourself

Three questions

What phrase did John Marshall use for the tribes in 1831?

Cherokee Nation v. Georgia.

When did Congress stop making treaties with tribes?

Existing treaties were expressly preserved.

What did the Dawes Act of 1887 do?

About 90 million acres passed out of tribal hands.
Questions

Frequently asked

Are Indian treaties still valid?

Yes. A ratified treaty is federal law until Congress clearly repeals it, and courts enforce treaty rights to land, water, hunting and fishing every year.

Do Native Americans pay taxes?

Yes. Native Americans pay federal income tax like everyone else. The main exceptions are narrow: income earned by a tribal member on that member’s own reservation is generally free of state income tax, and tribal governments, like states, are not taxed.

Can a tribe prosecute a non-Indian?

Generally not, under Oliphant (1978). Congress has made exceptions for domestic violence and certain related crimes committed in Indian country, under the Violence Against Women Act.

What is “Indian country”?

A legal term defined at 18 U.S.C. § 1151: all land within a reservation, dependent Indian communities, and Indian allotments still in trust. It determines which government, tribal, federal or state, has jurisdiction.

Does North Carolina law apply on the Qualla Boundary?

Only in part. The Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians has its own courts and police. Federal and tribal authorities handle most crimes involving Indians there; the state has authority over crimes between non-Indians and shares some civil matters by agreement.