
The Sixth Crusade: Jerusalem by Treaty
Frederick II, al-Kamil, and an agreement that recovered holy places without settling the struggle around them.
In this chapter
A crusader under excommunication
Frederick II had repeatedly promised to go east. His obligations intersected with the government of Germany and Sicily, papal concerns about imperial power, and his claim to the kingdom of Jerusalem through his marriage to Isabella II, also called Yolande. A delayed departure after illness brought excommunication by Gregory IX in 1227.
When Frederick sailed in 1228, he did so as an excommunicated ruler. The situation exposed a fundamental tension: the emperor was attempting the objective of a papally promoted movement while remaining in conflict with the pope. Some local leaders and churchmen were reluctant to cooperate, and the kingdom’s baronial politics complicated his authority.
The emperor and the sultan
Frederick and al-Kamil negotiated within a changing Ayyubid political environment. The sultan had reasons to reduce pressure from the coast while managing struggles with other members of his family. The emperor possessed bargaining power, but he did not have an army capable of effortlessly conquering and defending the whole region.
Their agreement in February 1229 placed Jerusalem, Bethlehem, and a corridor of access within a negotiated arrangement favorable to the Latin kingdom. Muslim religious use of the Haram al-Sharif was preserved, and the city’s defenses and jurisdiction remained contentious. The result was not a simple transfer of every holy place and every form of authority to Frederick. [1]
Why the treaty was possible
Diplomacy could produce concessions because the parties valued different things at that moment. Jerusalem’s religious prestige exceeded its immediate military value compared with some fortified and economically productive positions. An agreement could therefore offer Frederick a major symbolic victory while allowing al-Kamil to pursue other strategic priorities.
This does not mean religion was a disguise for secular calculation. Both rulers had to justify their actions to audiences for whom the holy city mattered deeply. The settlement’s political usefulness existed inside a world of religious claims, obligations, and potential accusations of betrayal.
The campaign in place
Explore the selected sites in this chapter. Locations are approximate and route lines connect major stages schematically.
Follow a campaign. Find a place.
Land outline: Natural Earth, public domain. Points are approximate city/site locations. Dashed lines join selected stages schematically; they are not exact marching routes, frontiers, or navigational directions. Use named buttons for keyboard access. Zoom changes the view; Reset returns to the selected campaign.
Two letters, two verdicts
Frederick’s announcement presented the agreement as an extraordinary achievement accomplished with limited force. Patriarch Gerold’s account condemned the emperor’s conduct and questioned the settlement. Read together, they reveal a dispute about legitimacy, conditions, and control—not a simple contrast between a true report and an obviously worthless complaint.
The key questions are precise. What territory was actually transferred? Which communities retained access? Could the city be defended? Who had authority to represent the kingdom? A victory proclamation answers these questions differently from a hostile ecclesiastical report. Neither should be mistaken for the complete text of an uncontested peace. [1]
Jerusalem without a secure surrounding kingdom
Frederick entered Jerusalem and took part in a ceremony associated with his royal claim. The city was not recovered through the sort of siege that made 1099 a military legend. That difference later encouraged descriptions of a uniquely enlightened crusade. Such a verdict overlooks the coercion inherent in bargaining backed by armed power and the emperor’s hard conflict with local opponents.
Philip of Novara, aligned with the Ibelin side in the struggles over imperial authority, preserves another highly interested view. His narrative is indispensable for that political world but cannot be used without identifying the faction from which it came. [2]
A temporary and contested achievement
The agreement did not permanently settle Jerusalem’s status. The years after the truce’s expiration brought reversals, renewed negotiations, and further changes of control. The city’s sack by Khwarazmian forces in 1244 ended this phase of Latin possession and was followed by a disastrous defeat of a Latin-led coalition near Gaza.
For that reason, a simple chart coloring Jerusalem continuously Latin from 1229 to 1244 would imply more stability than the evidence warrants. This collection instead charts dated settlements and conquests. The distinction between an agreement’s signing and uninterrupted control is essential to accurate historical visualization.
What success means here
Frederick recovered access and political claims that previous armies had failed to obtain. He also left a settlement with significant vulnerabilities and a kingdom divided over his authority. The Sixth Crusade demonstrates diplomacy’s potential, the significance of rival Muslim dynasties, and the difficulty of translating a spectacular agreement into durable government. It is neither a proof that warfare had become unnecessary nor a story that should be dismissed because its chief achievement was negotiated.
Sources for this page
- Primary sourceFrederick II's Crusade: Letters, 1229Translation hosted by the Internet History Sourcebooks Project. Editorial introductions and translations must be read critically; medieval authors had their own allegiances.
- Primary sourceThe Crusade of Frederick IITranslation hosted by the Internet History Sourcebooks Project. Editorial introductions and translations must be read critically; medieval authors had their own allegiances.
Read translations and historical narratives in context. Linked institutional accounts and recommended monographs have different purposes. The source guide explains the collection’s methods and limits.


