Book Reviews · Mystery & Thrillers
Charlotte McConaghy

On the storm-battered island of Shearwater, a father and three children tend a seed bank as the sea rises. A stranger named Rowan arrives with reasons to distrust their story.
A seed bank is a poignant setting for a suspense novel. Its contents are valuable because of futures nobody can predict, yet somebody has to decide in the present what can be saved. The Salt family’s work lends the island a daily life beyond the demands of the mystery. The weather may give everyone a common enemy without giving them a common account of the past.
Rowan’s arrival changes the household’s balance of knowledge. A broken communication link or a patch of disturbed earth looks one way to a newcomer and quite another to the person who knows its history. McConaghy lets environmental loss and domestic secrecy exert pressure on each other. The question of what survives becomes painfully specific when answering it means choosing whose account to trust and whose labor to leave behind.
What does the seed bank teach you about the family before anyone offers an explanation?
Compare the things they preserve meticulously with the things they have decided to keep from Rowan.