Book Reviews · Fiction & Classics
Raymond Carver

In Raymond Carver’s title story, two couples sit over gin and try to settle the meaning of love. The rest of the collection gives ample reason to doubt a tidy answer.
A table, four chairs and a bottle supply nearly everything a playwright would need. As the light changes and the gin goes down, each speaker borrows an incident to support a definition. A story can sound decisive right up to the moment another person asks one question. The distance between the couples’ assurance and their ability to understand each other is where the drama lives.
Across the collection, Carver makes readers do much of the work ordinarily assigned to a narrator. A change of subject can be the most consequential action in a scene. That economy has a risk. Readers sometimes turn every silence into evidence for their own favorite explanation. The stories repay a second reading that asks which interpretation the exact words support and which one we supplied to finish the scene.
When does someone answer a story by telling a different story?
Consider whether the second speaker has challenged the argument or quietly changed its terms.
Further reading on What We Talk About When We Talk About Love · Return to this shelf