Book Reviews · Ancient & Medieval Worlds
Mary Beard

Mary Beard follows images of Rome’s first emperors into later palaces, galleries and collections. A portrait’s mistaken identity can be as historically interesting as its correct one.
Stand before a marble head labeled as an emperor. What makes you accept the label? A resemblance to a coin, a long collecting tradition, a dealer’s confidence and a modern museum caption are different sorts of authority. Beard shows why the history of an identification belongs beside the history of the carved stone. Someone once bought, displayed or copied the head because of the person they thought it represented.
The book’s reach beyond antiquity is its special pleasure. A line of Caesars displayed in a later European interior tells us something about its owner’s relationship to power, even if a modern scholar would change half the names. Readers of Tom Holland’s Dynasty will find a rewarding second question here. Once a dynasty ends, who gets to keep making use of its faces?
If a bust loses its imperial identification tomorrow, what part of its history survives intact?
Think of the decisions made by earlier viewers who trusted the old label.