Tried by War
James M. McPherson

Lincoln had to learn what to ask of a general while the war was already underway. McPherson follows the education of a commander answerable to voters as well as armies.
Edition cover from Penguin Random House.Abraham Lincoln had very little military experience when the country handed him command of a war. James M. McPherson follows his education in the job through arguments with generals, decisions about competing theaters, and the growing recognition that policy toward slavery would change what the Union armies could accomplish. The president has to think beyond the immediate question of who holds a town after a campaign.
The book is particularly clear about the distinction between conducting an operation well and choosing an operation that serves the country's purpose. That helps explain Lincoln's frustration with generals who could give perfectly sound reasons for waiting. McPherson's concentration on the presidency leaves the reader seeing those officers largely through the problems they presented to Washington. In return, he gives unusual coherence to military and political decisions often studied in separate books. It is an excellent short study of how a civilian leader learns what to ask of experts when the responsibility for their answers ultimately belongs to him.

James Peale. Reproduction via Wikimedia Commons, CC0.
Open the full imageRead alongside
Consider how a single decision or photograph becomes the version of war that a later generation remembers.
The Last Full MeasureJeff ShaaraGettysburg makes a dramatic ending. The war, however, continued, and people who had survived one extraordinary battle still had to get up and fight in the next one.
Flags of Our FathersJames Bradley with Ron PowersWhat does a famous photograph do to the people believed to be in it? James Bradley began with the reticence of his father, John, a Navy corpsman who served on Iwo Jima.
Reading group guide
Which question from Lincoln obliges a general to explain what an army is for, as well as where it ought to go?
Find this book and edition
Tried by War · James M. McPherson · War & Military History
Cover edition ISBN 9780143116141 · Look for this edition in a library