The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Tragic History of the Sea: Shipwrecks from the Bible to Titanic

Book review

The Tragic History of the Sea: Shipwrecks from the Bible to Titanic

Anthony Brandt, editor

Edition cover of The Tragic History of the Sea: Shipwrecks from the Bible to Titanic
The Tragic History of the Sea: Shipwrecks from the Bible to Titanic

A survivor remembers the moment. An inquiry reconstructs a sequence. Reading these shipwreck accounts together shows how much a change of narrator can change the meaning of a disaster.

Cover of The Tragic History of the Sea: Shipwrecks from the Bible to Titanic. Image from Penguin Random House.

A shipwreck has two chronologies. In one, people act with incomplete information while the ship is still in danger. In the other, somebody on shore constructs a story in which every sign of disaster looks unmistakable. Anthony Brandt's anthology invites readers to move between those clocks across centuries of writing about loss at sea. A biblical narrative and an account of the Titanic may concern comparable terror while making entirely different claims about what that terror means.

The change in voices is more valuable than an uninterrupted succession of calamities. Read one selection for what its author considers a cause, another for how it assigns blame, and another for the detail a survivor cannot leave behind. As with any anthology, excerpting works can diminish the context that made an original account distinctive. Reading slowly helps. The collection makes an unusually good choice for a discussion about testimony, memory, and the reader's appetite for an ending when the people aboard had only the next few minutes.

U.S. Coast Guard historical photograph of the five-masted schooner Carroll A. Deering under sail
An Atlantic schoonerThe five-masted Carroll A. Deering under sail. U.S. Coast Guard photograph, Herbert Hoover Presidential Library.

Read alongside

Read the voyage from the deck, then from the countinghouse. Profit and survival give the same crossing different stakes.

The WagerDavid Grann

The British warship Wager breaks apart off the coast of Patagonia during an eighteenth-century expedition. Some survivors eventually reach South America with a story of almost unimaginable endurance.

The Sugar BaronsMatthew Parker

A spoonful of sugar at a British table sat at the end of a chain that reached across an ocean. Matthew Parker follows planter families in the Caribbean to show how fortunes built on enslaved labor moved into houses, marriages and political influence.

Reading group guide

Compare two wreck accounts. Which details survive because they mattered to the survivors, and which because an audience expected them?

Find this book and edition

The Tragic History of the Sea: Shipwrecks from the Bible to Titanic · Anthony Brandt, editor · Seafaring & Exploration
Cover edition ISBN 9780792259084 · Look for this edition in a library