Book Reviews · World History & Society
Stephen Greenblatt

Stephen Greenblatt follows a Renaissance book hunter to a surviving copy of Lucretius. A chain of fragile physical accidents stands behind a poem’s intellectual afterlife.
Poggio Bracciolini had to recognize a text worth copying before anyone could argue with its ideas. That material fact gives Greenblatt’s account its most durable appeal. Literary survival depends on handwriting, access, money, storage and people willing to do tedious work. A civilization can come perilously close to losing a philosophy through perfectly ordinary neglect.
The larger proposition is more contestable. Lucretius’s poem offers an arresting line through a complicated history, and a line is easier to narrate than a network of influences. The best way to enjoy the book is to distinguish its gripping account of transmission from its claim about what made the modern world possible. The discovery is remarkable even for a reader who assigns it a smaller share of historical causation.
At what point does the story change from how a manuscript survived to what it caused?
Try naming the evidence you would need to carry the second argument.