The Shadow of What Was Lost
James Islington
Davian is apprenticed to a kind of magic that the law barely tolerates. A generation earlier, the rulers called Augurs fell, and the surviving Gifted accepted binding limits on their abilities. Being born after the rebellion offers Davian no exemption from its settlement. Discovering a forbidden ability of his own makes an already miserable bargain considerably worse.

Davian is learning an art his neighbors have good historical reasons to fear. The past becomes personal before he has learned enough to defend himself against it.
Edition cover from Little, Brown.James Islington's first Licanius novel has an appealing sense of history as unfinished business. The rules Davian learns at school carry somebody else's idea of justice inside them. Elsewhere a man wakes with blood on him and no memory, so even the ownership of the past becomes an open question. Following the separate strands asks for patience with unfamiliar names and explanations that arrive late. Readers who enjoy fitting distant pieces of a fantasy world together will find the delay productive. The most persuasive reason to keep going, though, is the boy being punished for a war he never had the chance to fight.
Islington makes the possession of a gift inseparable from the rules governing its public use. Fear of what others will infer can shape a decision before any overt exercise of power takes place.

After Gustave Doré. Wood engraving. Public-domain artwork.
Explore the visual sourceRead alongside
Watch the scale shift between an ordinary task and the invented history that gives it unexpected weight.
The HobbitJ. R. R. TolkienBilbo Baggins begins his adventure worried about his pantry and the alarming number of unexpected guests. The joke lasts because those domestic priorities retain their dignity throughout the journey.
The Lord of the RingsJ. R. R. TolkienFrodo inherits an object whose usefulness is precisely what makes it dangerous. Powerful people can think of good things they might accomplish with the Ring, an argument Tolkien makes more frightening by taking their good intentions seriously.
Reading group guide
When do the legal limits placed on the Gifted influence a character more than the limits of the gift itself?
Find this book and edition
The Shadow of What Was Lost · James Islington · Fantasy & Retold Myths
Cover edition ISBN 9780356507750 · Look for this edition in a library