Book Reviews · War & Military History
W. Henry Sledge

W. Henry Sledge returns to the original manuscript behind his father Eugene Sledge’s With the Old Breed. Father and son occupy different positions in the history of the same war.
Readers who know Eugene Sledge’s account of Peleliu and Okinawa may feel they already know the witness. His son’s volume introduces another relationship, the one between a finished memoir and the material from which it was made. The original manuscript can preserve a detail that disappears in a published narrative without making the published account less honest. Every memoir has had to become a book of a particular length and shape.
Henry has two roles, family member and steward of a record of public importance. Those roles give the book emotional force and make attribution matter. Ask who saw an event, who first put it into words, and who is now explaining why it deserves another hearing. Reading father and son together produces something richer than simply accumulating more details of the Pacific war. It shows how testimony passes from a participant to a generation responsible for remembering him.
What can a son add to a witness’s account without claiming to have shared the experience?
Look for the difference between recovering a detail and explaining what its survival means.
Further reading on The Old Breed: The Complete Story Revealed · Return to this shelf