Book Reviews · World History & Society
Matthew Restall

Matthew Restall studies both the Genoese sailor and the many later Columbuses made by admirers, opponents, historians and nations. Their disagreements have histories of their own.
A biographer usually has one death to account for. Restall’s title promises a subject who repeatedly returns to public life because later people need him to mean something. Names shift across languages. Qualities once celebrated become grounds for condemnation. Reputations can change faster than the underlying archival material, which makes the distance between a person and a public symbol an essential part of the inquiry.
The approach is particularly useful for readers tired of disputes over whether famous people deserve a place of honor. Before judging an image, Restall asks what it consists of and when it came into being. That does not suspend judgment about conquest or its consequences. It makes judgment more exact by identifying which claims concern the man’s conduct, which concern the age in which he lived, and which belong to commemorators centuries later.
Which version of Columbus tells you most about the people who constructed it?
Identify a detail that would have mattered little to his contemporaries and a great deal to theirs.
Further reading on The Nine Lives of Christopher Columbus · Return to this shelf