The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Name of the Rose

In Umberto Eco’s The Name of the Rose, a medieval murder inquiry becomes a fight over who can read, who can ask questions, and who gets to keep the evidence.

Book review

The Name of the Rose

Umberto Eco

Edition cover of The Name of the Rose
The Name of the RoseEdition cover of The Name of the Rose. Image from Open Library.

A Franciscan named William of Baskerville and his young companion Adso arrive at a medieval abbey where a death calls for investigation. The library is an object of desire long before the detectives have understood its rules. Eco grasps a basic fact about archives. Whoever determines how a document can be found can exercise nearly as much power as someone who destroys it. The prayer schedule, the architecture and the habits of reading all become parts of the mystery.

Long arguments over poverty, authority and interpretation interrupt the chase. Some readers will feel the monastery doors closing on them in those passages. Yet one pleasure of the book is discovering that the arguments govern what these particular people might kill to protect. Adso remembers with an old man's uncertainty the events he encountered as a boy. His double perspective tempers William's faith in deduction and leaves a question lingering after the clues have done their work. How much order did the investigator discover, and how much did he bring along?

A horse before a corpse

Umberto Eco gives William of Baskerville an easy victory on the approach to the abbey. A horse is missing. William can say quite a lot about the animal before the people looking for it have even told him what they have lost. Adso, his young companion, finds the performance marvelous. So does a reader who has picked up a formidable-looking medieval novel in the hope of finding a detective story inside. There is a particular relief in discovering that this learned Franciscan knows what tracks in the ground mean. Remember that relief. A novelist who has established how good it feels to follow a clever explanation can subsequently make that feeling a very expensive habit.

The year is 1327. An important religious and political meeting is expected, and the abbey would much prefer its troubles dealt with before they become another party’s business. William has to negotiate permission even to begin understanding the place. Someone has died. Others possess pieces of a history nobody seems inclined to relate from beginning to end. Above them all, in an immense building, are books whose whereabouts and availability are carefully controlled. A contemporary investigator might ask who had a key. William must ask something a little more fundamental. Who has the right to know that a particular door exists?

The building has an argument to make

Eco understands why a reader might fall for this library before recognizing the danger it presents. A book copied by hand carries with it an account of time. Somebody had to obtain materials, prepare a space, spend hours making marks, then leave the result somewhere that another human being could find. Every volume implies an astonishing series of affirmative decisions about what deserves to survive. Enter such a place with a love of books and it is easy to feel gratitude toward the people who keep it. Eco lets that feeling live alongside the less comfortable fact that an institution can preserve a book and effectively abolish its readership.

The catalog interests me as much as the maze. A locked room announces a restriction to anyone who tries the handle. A catalog whose organizing principle remains private can leave a reader unaware that anything was withheld. The difference matters outside a medieval abbey. Anybody who has searched an archive using a modern word for something an earlier generation called by a different name has experienced an innocent version of the difficulty. William confronts a less innocent one. Before he can reason from the available evidence, he must decide how much of its apparent availability was designed by the very people he needs to investigate.

The older man who remembers being a boy

The story reaches us through Adso looking back on his youth. That gives Eco an unusually flexible instrument for regulating what a reader knows. Young Adso can misunderstand something directly in front of him. Old Adso can understand perfectly well what happened and still be unsure how to tell it, what judgment to attach to his younger self, or whether the local texture of a remembered moment has survived the years. Those are different limitations. When a description becomes especially elaborate, ask which Adso wanted to preserve it. A bewildered boy and an elderly man looking at the remnants of his own past need rather different things from the same sentence.

The encounter with a hungry young woman is the sharpest test of the arrangement. The people inside the institution have the books, the words, and in Adso’s case the future opportunity to tell the story. She has urgent material needs and far less power to determine what the meeting will signify. A reader can feel the force of Adso’s experience and still ask what the encounter would look like in a history of the people who supplied, depended on, or went hungry beside this magnificent establishment. Eco gives us abundant access to disputes among men over the meaning of poverty. The young woman makes that access feel temporarily inadequate.

Two kinds of questioning

Several people in the abbey can put together a persuasive explanation from fragments. The danger is most apparent when an authority possesses both a theory and the power to make a frightened person confirm it. A question that permits only one safe answer can produce an impressively consistent record. Its consistency tells you a great deal about the questioning and much less than you might like about the event. The scenes involving inquisitorial authority give this ostensibly remote mystery a disturbing immediacy. A case can look more orderly on paper precisely because the inquiry has stopped admitting anything that could disturb the order.

William is attractive because he can change his mind. That does not free him from the pleasure of finding a pattern, any more than admiring his intelligence frees the reader. Consider how satisfying it is when two obscure details suddenly seem to belong to the same design. The sensation arrives instantly. Testing whether the connection actually explains either detail takes much longer. Few detective novels give quite so much attention to that gap. Even readers who feel overmatched by the theological disputes can follow this strand by keeping a simple distinction in view. What has happened? What has William inferred? How much of the second answer have I already allowed into the first?

Where the long arguments pay off

There is no getting around the demands of the middle stretches. Some readers will find that a debate over whether Christ and the apostles owned property interrupts an absorbing investigation. Others will suspect a murder has interrupted an absorbing debate. Both responses seem fair. A profitable way to get through a difficult exchange is to identify who stands to lose something if a proposition is accepted. A dispute that sounds minute in the abstract can determine who has authority to speak, to accumulate goods, or to challenge a far more powerful institution. The book does not always distribute its explanations lightly. It generally rewards the effort of locating the stakes.

For a reading group, try returning to the missing horse after everyone has finished. On the first encounter, Adso’s amazement was easy to share. What part of the early demonstration now looks like excellent reasoning, and what part looks like a skillful man making the most of a cooperative set of circumstances? The distinction leaves plenty of room to enjoy the performance. It also allows the later book to reach backward and change the meaning of an apparently innocent welcome. Eco gives us the pleasure of meeting a great detective, then gives us something more unusual to take away: a feel for how much courage a detective needs to admit that a beautiful account of the facts may belong chiefly to its author.

Eco lets a catalog become an instrument of power. A door that will not open creates suspicion; a book omitted from the system by which readers discover books may never be missed at all.

Saint Jerome works at a desk in a sunlit room with a resting lion and dog in Dürer’s 1514 engraving Saint Jerome in His Study.
From the visual archiveSaint Jerome in His StudyJerome’s desk and books give scholarship a serene outward appearance. Eco’s monastery makes the question of who controls access to books considerably less tranquil.

Albrecht Dürer, 1514. Engraving, The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Public-domain artwork.

Explore the visual source

Read alongside

These books turn reading into detective work. Watch what happens when the object in the reader’s hands becomes evidence.

The Flanders Panel
Arturo Pérez-Reverte

Restoring an old Flemish painting, Julia discovers a concealed inscription that asks a question about the death of a knight.

Flaubert’s Parrot
Julian Barnes

A retired doctor named Geoffrey Braithwaite takes a serious interest in Gustave Flaubert.

Reading group guide

When William reads a sign correctly, does he also understand why somebody wanted it there?

Find this book and edition

The Name of the Rose · Umberto Eco · Mystery & Thrillers
Cover edition ISBN 9780544176560 · Look for this edition in a library