The Jesus Papers
Michael Baigent

An investigation of supposedly hidden evidence presents a particular challenge. How much can a reader check without first accepting the author’s account of why the evidence is unavailable?
Cover of The Jesus Papers. Image from Open Library.Michael Baigent frames his inquiry into Jesus and the crucifixion as a search for suppressed evidence. The book borrows the pace of a detective story. Someone has heard of a document, someone else may have seen it, and a journey or conversation moves the inquiry tantalizingly close to a new account. It is easy to see why this structure works on a reader. Few things are so difficult to leave alone as a locked archive.
The demands of historical proof make a less accommodating ending than the demands of a thriller. An object unavailable for independent examination cannot establish its date, authorship, provenance, or meaning by the intensity of somebody's recollection. Nor can an absence in the archive establish who caused it. The book's most rewarding use is as a close study of how narrative suspense can increase while evidentiary certainty stays exactly where it was. Readers curious about the historical Jesus should keep the questions Baigent raises distinct from the sweeping answers his title suggests.

Gérard · CC BY-SA 4.0.
Open the full imageRead alongside
Follow one significant claim back to its source. Does the evidence support the author’s conclusion or leave alternatives open?
JFK and the UnspeakableJames W. DouglassFor James Douglass, the central question about John F. Kennedy is the distance he traveled politically after the Cuban Missile Crisis. A Catholic peace activist, Douglass follows Kennedy's encounters with nuclear danger, his public gestures toward coexistence, and the resistance such a course could provoke in Cold War Washington.
Holy Blood, Holy GrailMichael Baigent, Richard Leigh and Henry LincolnA mystery in the French village of Rennes-le-Château opens into a theory involving the Grail, the descendants of Jesus, and a secret organization charged with guarding their history. The scale keeps expanding.
Reading group guide
What would establish the provenance of a document before its contents could alter a historical account?
Find this book and edition
The Jesus Papers · Michael Baigent · Faith & Philosophy
Cover edition ISBN 9780060827137 · Look for this edition in a library