Book Reviews · Faith & Philosophy
Richard Dawkins

Richard Dawkins argues against belief in a supernatural creator and asks why religious explanations receive special deference. The book belongs on a shelf where its claims can meet serious disagreement.
Dawkins writes with the energy of a scientist who thinks a proposed explanation should be available for public challenge. That gives the book a clear voice and an inviting target for a careful reader. What exactly is the proposition he believes he has answered? A claim about a designer intervening in nature and a claim about the meaning of existence may share religious vocabulary while making different demands on evidence.
The strongest discussion begins when readers formulate an opponent’s view precisely enough that the opponent would recognize it. That standard applies to Dawkins’s portraits of religious belief and to religious readers’ portraits of evolutionary explanation. The book is uneven terrain for such a meeting, which is part of its value in a discussion group. People who disagree about the conclusion can still discover that they have been disputing different questions.
Which argument would a thoughtful believer recognize as directed at an actual belief?
Identify the premise on which the disagreement turns before deciding who has the stronger case.