The Devil in the White City
Erik Larson

A fairground must be finished by opening day. Elsewhere in Chicago, anonymity is an advantage. Larson draws two very different kinds of opportunity from the modern city.
Edition cover from Penguin Random House.Daniel Burnham must get the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago built and open on time. H. H. Holmes discovers that a fast-growing city crowded with visitors affords a dangerous degree of anonymity. Erik Larson moves between them, and the fair is the strand that may surprise readers who pick up the book for its notorious murderer. Getting architects, landscapers, laborers, and weather to cooperate can be as suspenseful as the crime story.
The juxtaposition gives the book its theatrical appeal, though the two accounts rest on different kinds of evidence. The fair generates plans, deadlines, and documented disagreements. A predator's private calculations are harder to recover, and a vivid reconstruction can feel more certain than its sources allow. Chicago itself makes the pairing work. Its appetite for novelty and its willingness to place confidence in impressive new enterprises sustain Burnham's achievement. They also help explain how a man with a reassuring manner could operate amid the comings and goings of strangers.
Before the gates opened
A visitor to a world’s fair buys a ticket to see an accomplished fact. The buildings stand where the guide says they stand. The paths go somewhere. A person can pause to admire a reflection without having to consider who decided that there ought to be water at that particular spot. Erik Larson takes the ticket out of your hand and makes you arrive early. Jackson Park is a site somebody has to make usable. People whose names look wonderfully harmonious on a commemorative list have inconveniently different ideas about what should be done. The gap between the view promised to visitors and the place in which the builders actually go to work is the source of some of the best suspense in this book.
The title leads many readers to expect the story of H. H. Holmes with a handsome architectural backdrop. Try reading the early chapters the other way around. Daniel Burnham has an astonishingly difficult assignment and a date by which strangers will be able to judge, with their own eyes, whether he has carried it off. Every choice to commission one thing, postpone another, or trust a particular person has consequences that will become public. Holmes has almost the opposite advantage. He can tell different people different things about his affairs, counting on the practical difficulties they would face in getting together to compare accounts. The two stories begin to illuminate each other where they differ most sharply: in who has to explain a failure, and to whom.
A landscape architect’s kind of suspense
Frederick Law Olmsted makes an excellent corrective to anybody who imagines that putting on a fair chiefly requires erecting impressive buildings. A building can announce its completion from across a park. A planting has to grow into its intended effect. A walk takes time to walk. Water, shade, distance, and a tired visitor’s line of sight may matter more to the experience of a place than a list of distinguished exhibits. Consider the difficult position of someone charged with the appearance of the whole landscape. At any moment a colleague can point to the unfinished ground and see a convenient place to put something urgently required. The fact that it should eventually feel spacious and unencumbered makes its intended use surprisingly hard to defend.
Larson is good on disputes of this kind because they give ambition a physical address. It is easy to announce that a fair should be beautiful, ingenious, affordable, and ready on time. Then two people need the same patch of ground. A reader starts to understand Burnham’s achievement as the management of conflicts between desirable things. A decision can improve the chances that the exposition will open while making one corner of it a disappointment to the person who knows that corner best. The story makes room for that local disappointment even when the eventual visitor will have little reason to suspect anything was sacrificed.
A wheel seen from the ground
The Ferris wheel poses an unusually legible problem. A person standing underneath can look up and decide, quite reasonably, that understanding the principle of rotation is different from wishing to entrust a family member to this particular example. To the fair organizers, however, the fact that the thing is difficult to imagine is part of its attraction. An exposition devoted to wonders needs something people will describe in a letter home. For the wheel to be the success its advocates want, anxiety has to survive long enough to make the ride memorable and then give way to sufficient confidence for the passenger to step aboard.
Look at the historical photograph linked below before returning to the prose. Find something in the foreground whose size you can estimate from ordinary experience. Then look up again. A photograph can establish scale in a way a superlative seldom manages. It can also demonstrate the limits of the knowledge it gives you. No amount of looking at a completed wheel will tell you everything about the arguments that went into trusting it. Larson earns the view from the top by giving the people below it reasons to disagree about whether it should ever have been built.
Two archives of very different depths
The alternating chapters produce an especially interesting difficulty when the narrative turns to Holmes. The work of a large public enterprise creates paper almost as a side effect. People have to authorize expenses, explain delays, and commit plans to forms that other people can examine. A person trying to conceal wrongdoing has rather different habits. What can a historian honestly reconstruct when a crucial conversation may have taken place between two people, one of whom can no longer give an account and the other of whom has excellent reasons to lie? The narrative fluency that makes Larson easy to read can briefly conceal a change in the quality of the available evidence.
Here is a good test to apply to a chapter break. Identify the last fact in the Burnham section that somebody besides Burnham had a reason to record. Now identify the first moment in the Holmes section at which the reader is invited to imagine a private reaction. They can be equally convincing pieces of prose without enjoying the same historical standing. Readers need not abandon the crime narrative to notice the distinction. Following it closely makes the investigation more absorbing. The surviving records have histories of their own, including the interests of reporters and audiences eager to hear the most sensational possible explanation.
The price of being a stranger
A fair depends on civic trust. People who have never met can enter a shared place, spend a day among crowds, and leave with a confident account of having seen the future. A growing city also depends on the ease with which an unfamiliar face can become an employee, a tenant, a customer, or a person asking directions. For somebody leaving home to look for work, the chance to be received without a long local pedigree can be a genuine freedom. It can also mean that people who knew the newcomer best are a long way away when an explanation starts to sound wrong. Larson’s juxtaposition is most persuasive at that human scale. Chicago has no single character that explains its architecture and its crimes. Particular features of life in the city open different possibilities to people pursuing very different ends.
The sharper reservation about the book concerns the people whose disappearance has supplied its most marketable mystery. A reader can become remarkably interested in what a criminal may have planned and correspondingly less curious about what a missing person had hoped to do on arriving in Chicago. Resist that imbalance when a name first appears. Pause over a prospective job, an attachment, a reason to travel. For the person involved, that prospect once occupied the foreground. Read with that small correction in mind and the two halves of the book come together in a more demanding way. Behind both the public marvel and the private crime are people making ordinary judgments about which strangers they can trust.

Pieter Bruegel the Elder, 1563. Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna. Public-domain artwork.
Explore the visual sourceRead alongside
Track the details that make a reconstruction vivid, then ask how each detail reached the writer.
Killing PabloMark BowdenThe pursuit of Pablo Escobar presents a reporter with an almost irresistible plot. There is a fugitive, a manhunt, and an ending everyone knows.
In Cold BloodTruman CapoteBefore the murder of the Clutter family in Holcomb, Kansas, Capote lets readers spend time with the rhythms of a household. Plans, errands and small obligations go forward while the alternating narrative draws two men closer.
Reading group guide
What does Larson’s alternating structure encourage you to connect, and which links are thematic rather than evidentiary?
Find this book and edition
The Devil in the White City · Erik Larson · Crime & Investigation
Cover edition ISBN 9780375725609 · Look for this edition in a library