The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Resurrection: Myth or Reality?

Book review

Resurrection: Myth or Reality?

John Shelby Spong

Cover of Resurrection: Myth or Reality? by John Shelby Spong, reviewed and curated by Christopher Adkins of Huntersville, NC, for LKN Law
Resurrection: Myth or Reality?

The Gospel witnesses preserve different details about Easter morning. Spong treats the differences as a starting point for interpretation and asks what kind of claim resurrection makes.

Cover of Resurrection: Myth or Reality?. Image from Google Books, HarperSanFrancisco edition.

The Easter accounts preserve different details about who went where and what they saw. Some Christian readers seek to reconcile them. The Episcopal bishop John Shelby Spong treats their differences as an opening into how the earliest believers made theological meaning out of loss and conviction. He brings Jewish scripture and storytelling traditions into the discussion and gives Peter a particularly important role in his reconstruction.

There is an engaging boldness to the undertaking. Spong wants to explain how a movement traumatized by an execution came to speak in a radically different register about the man it had lost. His doubts about literal reconstructions are often more convincing than the confidence with which he supplies an alternative course of events. A psychologically plausible portrait of Peter still asks for evidence. The book makes an especially good discussion partner for readers willing to keep several questions apart. What did each evangelist write, what might earlier believers have experienced, and what can a later theologian responsibly conclude?

Two hands meet in prayer, drawn with dark strokes and white highlights on blue prepared paper in Dürer’s Praying Hands of 1508.
From the visual archivePraying HandsAn image of prayer supplies evidence of a gesture and invites an interpretation of experience. How does Spong negotiate the considerably greater distance between an early Christian text and the event behind it?

Albrecht Dürer, 1508. Albertina, Vienna. Public-domain artwork.

Explore the visual source

Read alongside

Compare what changes when a religious claim is framed as a confession, a personal appeal or a challenge to the reader.

The Sins of ScriptureJohn Shelby Spong

What happens when a text experienced as sacred by one person has been used to injure another? John Shelby Spong takes that question into Christian arguments over gender, sexuality, religious authority, and human obligations to the natural world.

Jesus: An Intimate Portrait of the Man, His Land, and His PeopleLeith Anderson

The Gospels present four voices. Leith Anderson asks what it would be like to encounter their stories in one continuous telling, with political context, local custom, and imagined human reactions filling some of the spaces between familiar episodes.

Reading group guide

Which part of the resurrection argument turns on historical testimony and which on what the writer believes testimony can establish?

Find this book and edition

Resurrection: Myth or Reality? · John Shelby Spong · Faith & Philosophy
Cover edition ISBN 9780060675462 · Look for this edition in a library

More by John Shelby Spong (1)