The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762
LKN LawThe Lake Norman Brief

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

Portnoy’s Complaint

Book review

Portnoy’s Complaint

Philip Roth

Alexander Portnoy has finally found a listener who cannot easily interrupt him. On the analyst's couch, he ranges over an American Jewish childhood, his parents, his sexual history and the humiliating distance between his political ideals and his private conduct. The joke depends on an extraordinary technical feat. Roth sustains the sound of a man speaking impulsively while arranging each accusation, imitation and indignant aside with the precision of a comic routine.

Edition cover of Portnoy’s Complaint
Portnoy’s ComplaintEdition cover from Penguin Random House. ISBN 9780679756453.

Portnoy is an exceptionally talented advocate for his own case. His willingness to admit something appalling can become a way of keeping control of the room. The people he desires get particularly little opportunity to escape the roles he assigns them, and readers may reasonably grow weary of being trapped in his company. The ending gives that weariness a formal payoff. Think of the book as a performance in which the speaker has misunderstood how much his audience can infer. His account of an overbearing family becomes an equally revealing portrait of the child who grew up to narrate it.

The analyst’s silence gives Portnoy extraordinary freedom to arrange his own prosecution and defense. A reader laughing at his account has briefly become the audience he would most like to have.

Albrecht Dürer wears a black-and-white outfit beside a landscape window in his painted Self-Portrait of 1498 in the Prado.
From the visual archiveSelf-Portrait, 1498Notice what Dürer can control about the viewer’s first impression of him. How much control remains with a narrator who appears to confess everything?

Albrecht Dürer. Museo Nacional del Prado. Public-domain artwork.

Explore the visual source

Read alongside

Listen for the gap between a speaking voice and what its author expects you to make of it.

Notes of a Dirty Old Man
Charles Bukowski

The newspaper column is a useful form for a writer who likes to arrive unexpectedly and leave before anyone can ask him to defend himself.

Factotum
Charles Bukowski

Henry Chinaski can usually get another job.

Reading group guide

What changes if the listener in the analyst’s office takes one of Portnoy’s best jokes literally?

Find this book and edition

Portnoy’s Complaint · Philip Roth · Fiction & Classics
Cover edition ISBN 9780679756453 · Look for this edition in a library