Book Reviews · Mystery & Thrillers
Shari Lapena

Fred and Sheila Merton are murdered after an Easter gathering. Their adult children inherit money, motives, and an urgent interest in what their siblings will tell the police.
An inheritance gives a mystery writer an elegantly uncomfortable fact. The same death can constitute a terrible loss and a considerable financial advantage. Lapena multiplies that ambiguity across three siblings who have spent a lifetime learning different ways to survive their father. Each knows exactly which family story can make another person look bad. Very little of that knowledge is neutral.
The short shifts in perspective invite the reader to keep a mental ledger. A fact useful to the police may have been disclosed for an entirely selfish reason. A sibling concealing an ugly detail may be ashamed of something unrelated to murder. The pleasure is in feeling those categories slip apart. The family dinner remains the right starting place because everybody arrived already rehearsed in the art of withholding.
Which secret most distorts your view of a sibling without proving anything about the killings?
Notice how easily bad conduct can pass for evidence of a particular crime.
Further reading on Not a Happy Family · Return to this shelf