Book Reviews · Seafaring & Exploration
Julian Sancton

A chance archival find sends Roger Dooley after the San José, a Spanish galleon lost off Colombia. Julian Sancton makes the paper chase as absorbing as the search at sea.
A shipwreck is unusually good at producing several defensible answers to the question of what has been lost. An investor may see precious metal. A historian may see a commercial system and evidence of the labor that supplied it. The families of those aboard lost people. Sancton’s narrative gains depth whenever the search for coordinates brings these incompatible measures of value into view.
Dooley’s work in a Spanish archive is an appealing corrective to the image of treasure hunting as a matter of spotting something glittering underwater. Someone first has to interpret a record prepared centuries ago for a purpose entirely different from his own. The physical location may eventually admit a precise answer. The question of who has the strongest claim over what is found has a much longer and more troubled history.
Would the discovery still count as a success if nothing were removed?
Compare the answers a finder, an archaeologist and a descendant might give.