Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
John Berendt

A shooting in a Savannah house is the legal question at the center of the book. Berendt spends enough time with the neighbors to explain why nobody tells it quite the same way.
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. Edition cover via Penguin Random House.An antique dealer shoots a young man in a Savannah mansion, and the question of what happened takes years to work through the courts. John Berendt lets the city make a lengthy entrance before the trials take over. This is a place where a party invitation, an old address and the quality of a story can all count as social currency.
The book owes much of its vitality to people who could have walked away with a chapter of their own, particularly the Lady Chablis. Their talent for performance complicates the role of the visiting writer, who is himself arranging memorable entrances and exits. The resulting account is an engrossing example of literary nonfiction, shaped through scene, dialogue and a storyteller’s sense of timing. A reader examining the prosecution and defense should look to the underlying record for precision. Berendt’s achievement belongs as much to social observation as to courtroom narrative. By the time the trial begins, reputation has already been hard at work.

Thomas T. Waterman / Historic American Buildings Survey · Public domain
Explore the visual sourceRead alongside
Consider what a striking house or place persuades you to believe before the evidence is in.
The Only One LeftRiley SagerA caregiver arrives at a Maine mansion to look after Lenora Hope, the sole survivor of an infamous family massacre decades earlier. Lenora has lived for years under the weight of a local story that has already decided what she did.
The FallsJoyce Carol OatesAriah Erskine spends her honeymoon waiting for the body of her husband to surface at Niagara. Tourists turn her vigil into a spectacle. One of the people watching is Dirk Burnaby, a local lawyer who will become her second husband.
Reading group guide
When does Berendt invite you to enjoy Savannah’s social performance, and when does that pleasure complicate your judgment?
Find this book and edition
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil · John Berendt · Crime & Investigation
Cover edition ISBN 9780679429227 · Look for this edition in a library