Book Reviews · Fiction & Classics
Ottessa Moshfegh

An injured sailor tries to remember whether he killed his friend. Ottessa Moshfegh gives the one witness a murder story most needs very limited access to his own mind.
McGlue’s predicament offers a neat puzzle on paper. In practice, being inside his head is abrasive, cramped and physically disagreeable. Sobriety brings flashes of a past he can hardly bear. The man whose account we want has powerful reasons to resist giving it, including reasons more tender than self-preservation. The missing memory concerns a relationship before it concerns a charge.
The period setting does not offer the comfort of a historical panorama. The hold of a ship, the pressure of a body in pain, the fragment of a remembered exchange occupy nearly all the available space. That severity makes this debut novella a demanding choice for a reader seeking a conventional maritime adventure and an unusually good one for anyone interested in how a narrative voice can enact impairment sentence by sentence.
What do you learn about the friendship before you can establish the sequence of events?
Notice how attachment can be clear even when chronology is impossible.