Book Reviews · Fiction & Classics
Katie Yee

After learning that her husband has a lover named Maggie, Katie Yee’s narrator gives the same name to her breast tumor. The collision of the two Maggies gives a devastating joke somewhere to go.
The title promises a bar joke. The news arrives over dinner, and the narrator cannot choose the punch line. She can, however, choose the name by which she addresses what is happening in her own body. That small act of verbal control explains why the book’s comedy can be sharp without making either illness or betrayal feel trivial. One Maggie can be addressed in private while the other goes on living an independent life.
Yee tells the story in fragments that include a user’s manual for the narrator’s husband and Chinese family stories retold to her children. These forms give grief different jobs. A manual knows someone’s irritating habits in almost loving detail. A bedtime story has to carry something a child can use into tomorrow. Readers tired of tidy narratives of personal growth may appreciate how many kinds of work an unfinished, funny, furious person can do in a single day.
What does a user’s manual let the narrator say that a farewell letter could not?
Consider how long she had to love and observe someone to assemble those instructions.
Further reading on Maggie; or, A Man and a Woman Walk Into a Bar · Return to this shelf