Book Reviews · Biography & Memoir
Kirstin Downey

Kirstin Downey follows Isabella of Castile through a disputed succession, a royal partnership, conquest, and religious persecution. Putting the queen at the center changes the familiar picture of a married pair of rulers.
Isabella and Ferdinand are so often named in one breath that it takes deliberate effort to see two political careers. Downey makes that effort. A woman whose right to rule was contested had to assemble allies, defend a claim and decide what authority a husband would exercise. Those decisions give the later story of royal power a specificity that the phrase Catholic Monarchs can obscure.
That specificity matters morally as well as politically. To restore Isabella’s agency is also to take seriously her responsibility for the uses of power, including religious coercion and the expulsion of Jewish communities. The biography is most rewarding when admiration for political ability and judgment about political ends remain possible on the same page. A reader can ask of a consequential queen everything a historian would ask of a king.
Where does naming Isabella individually change your judgment of a decision?
Consider both the accomplishment that might otherwise go unseen and the responsibility a joint royal title might conceal.
Further reading on Isabella: The Warrior Queen · Return to this shelf