Book Reviews · Science, Nature & Technology
Lisa Feldman Barrett

Lisa Feldman Barrett asks how a racing heart becomes fear in one setting and excitement in another. Her account gives prediction, bodily sensation, and learned concepts central roles.
Imagine being asked to identify an emotion from a face cropped out of a photograph. Now imagine seeing the whole scene. The answer can change without a single muscle in the face moving. Barrett uses puzzles of this kind to challenge the confidence with which people infer a private state from an outward sign. That has particular force for readers accustomed to judging a witness’s composure.
Barrett’s constructionist theory is an argument with competitors, and the book is livelier when read as an argument. A persuasive demonstration that context matters leaves room to debate exactly how the brain uses it. The practical intellectual payoff comes early. Before saying someone looked afraid, try saying what the person actually did and which features of the situation supplied the rest of your interpretation.
What did you observe before you supplied an emotion word?
Describe the face or gesture twice, changing only the circumstances around it, and compare the two readings.
Further reading on How Emotions Are Made · Return to this shelf