Book Reviews · Fiction & Classics
Barbara Hinske

Emily Main loses her sight after an accident on her honeymoon. In a parallel story, a Labrador named Garth is learning the work of a guide dog.
The reader knows what Emily and Garth do not yet know, that their individual stories belong together. Hinske uses that anticipation to give ordinary training and adjustment a narrative pull. A skill practiced repeatedly by a puppy can look charming in isolation. The parallel human story makes the eventual consequences of that skill much easier to appreciate.
There is also a worthwhile question about what counts as help. A stranger eager to do everything for Emily and a trained dog responsive to her direction offer very different ideas of support. The alternating perspectives give the book warmth, though some readers will find the canine voice sweet. Its strongest underlying idea is about partnership. Independence can involve learning how to work with another living being who has learned something difficult, too.
Where does help enlarge Emily’s choices?
Find a moment when an observer might think the task itself matters most, while Emily might care more about who decides.