Chain of Command
Seymour M. Hersh

The photographs answer some questions at once. Hersh pursues the harder ones about what happened outside the frame and how responsibility traveled through institutions.
Chain of Command by Seymour M. Hersh. Edition cover from Google Books.The photographs from Abu Ghraib showed particular people doing particular things. Seymour Hersh asks what a photograph cannot show. Who established the conditions under which the abuse occurred, who received warnings, and what did officials in Washington understand about the treatment of prisoners? His book expands the field of inquiry beyond the people visible in the frame.
Hersh works through documents, interviews and confidential accounts in the compressed time of an unfolding controversy. That proximity gives the reporting force and also demands discrimination from the reader. A documented finding, an unnamed official's assessment and Hersh's inference about policy have different evidentiary weight, even when they appear within a page of one another. The chapters sometimes retain the overlaps of magazine reporting gathered into a book. Their recurring questions have aged better than any expectation of a simple line from a single decision to every subsequent abuse. The title identifies a structure whose purpose is to assign responsibility. Hersh asks what happens when the people inside it find that structure equally serviceable for passing responsibility along.

U.S. Army occupation photographer. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
Open the full imageRead alongside
Track the distance between a troubling allegation, a documented fact and the conclusion an investigator draws.
Journal of the DeadJason KerstenRaffi Kodikian and David Coughlin went into the New Mexico desert together. When rescuers reached them, Coughlin was dead, and Kodikian acknowledged killing his friend. He described an act of mercy.
Killed to OrderJan JekielekA transplant is usually told as a story about a recipient and a second chance. Jan Jekielek directs attention to the person from whom an organ came, developing an indictment of the Chinese state around allegations of forced organ harvesting from prisoners.
Reading group guide
Trace one claim from photograph to witness to institution. Where is responsibility documented and where is it inferred?
Find this book and edition
Chain of Command · Seymour M. Hersh · War & Military History
Cover edition ISBN 9780060195915 · Look for this edition in a library