Book Reviews · Science, Nature & Technology
James Nestor

James Nestor makes an involuntary act the subject of a reporting adventure, moving among researchers, breathing traditions, and experiments on himself.
Breathing is an unusual subject for a writer because virtually every reader becomes aware of doing it as soon as the subject comes up. Nestor uses that intimacy well. The distance from the page to the reader’s own experience is short, which gives the reporting a lively sense of discovery. It also poses the book’s central difficulty. A sensation one can reproduce immediately feels persuasive well before its cause or significance has been established.
The self-experiments work best as accounts of how a curious reporter arrived at a question. They carry less weight as predictions about another person. Read with an eye to changes of scale, especially when a result from a few participants sits beside a claim about a whole population. The most interesting passages invite curiosity without requiring the reader to adopt the experiment.
Which claim would still persuade you if Nestor removed his own experience from the chapter?
Identify the independent evidence left on the page and the question the anecdote raised.