Charles Burns’s Black Hole turns a Seattle biology class, a patch of woods, and an unreturned crush into a graphic novel about who gets to look and who gets seen.
Black Hole
Charles Burns

Teenagers are practiced at hiding changes in their bodies. Charles Burns imagines a change impossible to explain away, then watches who still gets invited inside.
Edition cover from Penguin Random House.In Charles Burns's version of suburban Seattle in the 1970s, a sexually transmitted condition leaves teenagers with strange physical alterations. Some changes can be hidden under clothes. Others announce themselves to every person in a room. That difference matters enormously in a world where being seen with the wrong person can already feel like a permanent change in social standing.
Burns works in stark black and white. Hair, foliage, wounds, and shadows sometimes seem to belong to a shared visual vocabulary, giving a walk through the woods something of the instability of a dream. The condition resists a single allegorical reading. It can suggest adolescent shame in one episode and reveal another person's remarkable capacity for care in the next. Readers looking for a medical explanation or a conventional horror payoff may be unsettled by what remains open. The drawings make a more enduring point about attention. Growing up can mean noticing, with horrified precision, every change in one's own body while scarcely seeing what is happening to friends.
The girl across the lab table
In the biology classroom, Keith has two excellent reasons to keep his eyes on the frog. The first is that the frog is being dissected and he is supposed to be learning something. The second is that the alternative is looking at Chris, the girl opposite him, who might look back. Keith faints. It is an undignified opening for a boy in a horror story, and an extraordinarily good introduction to the way Charles Burns thinks about seeing. The assigned subject is there in plain view. The subject that actually interests Keith is physically closer and infinitely harder for him to look at. Anyone who has ever invented an urgent interest in a school desk to avoid another person’s eyes already knows something about this book.
The opening grants a small reprieve from the marketing shorthand that describes Black Hole as a story about a sexually transmitted plague. That is a fair account of the premise and an oddly poor account of what it feels like to turn the pages. Burns places us among young people who have known one another from class, from the neighborhood, from hearing one person talk about another. The outbreak arrives in a society that already has an efficient system for assigning identities. Its informal public health authority is the kid who can point across a room and say who has it. Nobody asks where that authority came from.
The distance between knowing and being known
Chris and Keith give us two positions from which to watch this arrangement work. Keith is inclined to observe people from the comparative safety of unreturned interest. Chris has to negotiate the distance between what has happened to her and what she wants anyone else to understand about it. An account built entirely around Keith could have made Chris another inscrutable girl in a young man’s education. Burns instead gives her time alone with the page. A face that Keith might spend half a scene trying to interpret can have an existence outside his guessing. Some of the book’s most generous drawing occurs precisely when one young person has finally escaped another’s attention.
Consider how different it is to carry an alteration under clothing and to have it somewhere a stranger can see. Both people may have the same condition. Only one gets to choose the moment of disclosure. That imbalance does far more to organize the teenagers’ world than any medical explanation would. It determines who can still enter a familiar room and have an ordinary conversation. It determines whether a new acquaintance first encounters a name, a voice, a joke, or a body everyone else has already discussed. Burns can establish all of this by changing the angle from which a doorway is seen. Somebody entering a room and somebody watching its entrance have very different ideas about what is at stake.
A drawing in which darkness does two jobs
The absence of color can sound like a limitation until you watch Burns draw the woods. In a photograph a branch, a strand of hair, and the shadow under a chin would probably offer different tones and textures. Here they can all be made of precisely the same black. For a moment a reader cannot quite tell where one ends and another begins. It takes a second look to recover the ordinary distinction between a body and its surroundings. That moment of confusion is something the picture does to you. A prose narrator assuring you that a teenager felt uncomfortable in the woods could not achieve quite the same result.
Try covering the words on one forest page. Follow the outlines until you can say which figure commands your attention and where your eye wants to go next. Then uncover the words. Sometimes the language will offer comfort the image has already undermined; sometimes the drawing gives a speaker more dignity than their awkward phrasing might suggest. This is a useful book for someone who tends to read comics by hopping from balloon to balloon. Burns has placed much of the action in the trip between them. Go too fast and the story can seem thinner, and the people less interesting, than either actually is.
Where do the teenagers go?
Suburban horror often gets its effect by putting something dreadful behind the door of a well-kept house. Burns is equally interested in who can still go through that door and expect to be welcome. The woods become a place where some of the affected teenagers can exist in one another’s company. There is a temptation to call that freedom. Look again at what they have given up for it. A place where nobody will ask you to leave can still be a place you went because somebody else had already decided you should disappear. The cruelty of the arrangement consists partly in how little active supervision it requires.
Burns also resists making desire itself the villain. Attraction lets a person see something lovely where the larger group has agreed to see something grotesque. It can also make people remarkably incurious about injuries happening only a few feet away. Keith’s interest in Eliza is especially revealing on this point. It opens his eyes and narrows his field of vision at the same time. An illustrator can show both effects within a single panel by giving a face exquisite attention and allowing the background to slip into dark. The reader who follows that invitation shares a little of Keith’s responsibility for whatever goes unnoticed.
What the monster story leaves unresolved
The ambiguity has a cost. Readers who invest in the condition as a puzzle can reasonably feel that the book has encouraged expectations it has little interest in satisfying. The recurring visual echoes sometimes invite such close decoding that other pleasures get crowded out. On a first pass, let a few of those echoes go. Notice instead whose company you miss when the story shifts, and whether a scene is frightening because somebody might be harmed or because somebody might be recognized. Those are distinct fears. Burns is exceptionally good at making the second arrive where another horror writer would have relied on the first.
The original publication in twelve installments helps explain why a concentrated reading of the collected edition can feel so relentless. A reader following the issues had time away from these faces. Read the collection over a weekend and the patterns begin to occupy your sight the way a bright shape lingers after you shut your eyes. That makes the book unusually rewarding to revisit on paper. Turn back from a late stretch of woods to the clean surfaces of the biology room. The early scene now seems full of things that you, like Keith, did not know how to see. The frog has stayed exactly where Burns put it. The person looking at it has changed.
Burns gives a single black shape permission to mean several things. The reader can mistake hair for a branch or shelter for concealment, experiencing in the drawing the uncertainty the teenagers feel about being seen.

Albrecht Dürer. Engraving, The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Public-domain artwork.
Explore the visual sourceRead alongside
Read a page without the dialogue, then return to the words. See which part of the story the artist has already told in the gutters.
HicksvilleDylan HorrocksBiographer Leonard Batts goes to a New Zealand town to research Dick Burger, a cartoonist of extraordinary commercial success. The townspeople know their comics remarkably well.
Sam Zabel and the Magic PenDylan HorrocksSam Zabel is a cartoonist who has lost the pleasure of drawing. An old New Zealand comic offers an unexpected route back when the border between its imagined world and his own proves surprisingly permeable.
Reading group guide
368 pages in the edition shown. Check the edition record.
Follow a patch of solid black across several panels. When does it stand for shelter, and when does it make the scene threatening?
Find this book and edition
Black Hole · Charles Burns · Graphic Novels & Comics
Cover edition ISBN 9780375714726 · Look for this edition in a library