Artificial Intelligence
Melanie Mitchell

A computer recognizes a photograph. Change one detail and its answer falls apart. Melanie Mitchell uses puzzles like this to ask what a successful prediction tells us about a machine’s understanding.
Artificial Intelligence. Edition cover via Macmillan.Melanie Mitchell separates an impressive result from the much harder question of what a machine has learned. A system can classify an image correctly and still rely on features a person would find incidental. Change the circumstances slightly and the gap between the machine’s successful performance and our interpretation of it becomes visible.
Mitchell’s gift is making that gap interesting in its own right. Her discussion of analogy and common sense explains why easy tasks for people can be exceedingly difficult to specify, and why a hard-won benchmark victory should prompt better experiments. The examples reflect the technology available when the book was written. They are most valuable today as instruction in how to question a demonstration, especially one that seems uncannily fluent. Readers can take a simple habit away from the book. When a person says that a system “understands,” ask what change in the task would let the two of you find out.

Albrecht Dürer, 1515. Woodcut. Public-domain artwork.
Explore the visual sourceRead alongside
Where does the writer move from describing a mechanism to predicting what it will make possible?
The Coming WaveMustafa Suleyman with Michael BhaskarWho gets to set limits on a technology everyone has a reason to adopt? An AI entrepreneur and his coauthor follow that question from the research lab into government, where the incentives look very different.
GenomeMatt RidleyMatt Ridley gives each pair of human chromosomes a chapter. Along the way, a tour of inheritance turns into a series of arguments about memory, ancestry and how much a gene can explain about a life.
Reading group guide
What would you change about a test to see whether a system learned the concept or merely a shortcut?
Find this book and edition
Artificial Intelligence · Melanie Mitchell · Science, Nature & Technology
Cover edition ISBN 9780374257835 · Look for this edition in a library