Book Reviews · American History
Alan Taylor

Alan Taylor tells the settlement of North America across Indigenous homelands, rival empires and the Atlantic slave trade. The thirteen colonies take their place inside a much larger and less predictable story.
Begin with a map of what later became the United States and some of the most important decisions will seem to have happened offstage. Taylor turns the reader toward the Caribbean, the borderlands and the interior. Now a mainland settlement’s dependence on commerce elsewhere in the Atlantic world comes into focus. A community that looks like the edge of one empire may be the center of an Indigenous diplomatic world.
For a reader headed toward the American Revolution, the great virtue of the book is the time it spends before independence looked like an outcome anyone should anticipate. Land, labor, disease, alliances and forced migration shape the choices available to people living under very different systems. The plural in the title earns its place. Carry it into a familiar Carolina story and a new question presents itself. Which colony, and from whose side of the boundary?
Which event looks least like a step toward the United States when seen by a participant at the time?
Describe the future that person might reasonably have expected instead.